Highlights
- Great dessert
oChef » Pie Bar – Seattle
Pie Bar - Seattle
Photo from Pie Bar
Pie Bar at a glance
Seattle Greenwood
- 🍽️ Restaurant
$$
Price per Person $21–$30
mentioned by 35 of the guests
#801 out of 858 places to eat in Seattle
#89 Restaurant out of 94 in Seattle
Average
5 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
295
Reviews
43.1%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Delicious pies
- Cozy atmosphere
- Great cocktails
Frequently criticized
- Inconsistent service
- High prices
- Variable quality
The restaurant Pie Bar in Seattle’s vibrant Greenwood neighborhood offers a truly cozy and casual experience, known for its great dessert. This spot is a local favorite for those looking for a delightful escape, whether it’s for a quick bite, late-night food, or a relaxing happy hour drink.
It provides a welcoming atmosphere for all.
Overview: Introducting Pie Bar
Pie Bar offers a delightful experience for those seeking a cozy spot with a focus on delicious pies and well-crafted cocktails. Many appreciate the fresh ingredients and the inviting, chill atmosphere, making it a pleasant place to unwind.
The decor often receives praise for its charm. However, experiences at Pie Bar can be quite inconsistent, particularly regarding customer service, which some describe as unhelpful or even rude.
The value proposition is also a point of contention, with several guests feeling the prices are steep for what’s offered, leading to disappointment.
Average
5
out of 10
295
Reviews
43.1%
Satisfaction
152
negative
16
neutral
127
positive
Pie Bar holds an overall Restaurant Score of 5, placing it squarely in the average category. This is reflected in a Customer Satisfaction rate of 43.1%, indicating a mixed reception from patrons.
With 295 customer remarks, the feedback shows a slight lean towards negative experiences, with 152 negative comments compared to 127 positive ones. Looking closer, the Food (5.8) and Ambience (6) are the strongest aspects, with many positive comments highlighting the quality of the offerings and the pleasant setting.
However, the experience is often hampered by inconsistent Service (3.9), which falls below average. The Value (2.5) is a clear area for improvement, frequently cited as a significant drawback by guests.
What people like
- Delicious pies
- Cozy atmosphere
- Great cocktails
What people don't like
- Inconsistent service
- High prices
- Variable pie quality
With a Recommendation Score of 4.9, Pie Bar presents a mixed bag. If you’re seeking a charming spot for a casual drink and a potentially delightful pie, it could be worth a visit.
However, be prepared for potential inconsistencies in both service and the overall value proposition. Ultimately, your experience here might hinge on what you order and who serves you.
While the cozy setting and some of the offerings are appealing, the notable drawbacks in service and pricing suggest it might not be a reliable choice for every occasion.
Similar Restaurants in Seattle
- Restaurant
9.6
out of 10
out of 10
150
100%
- €€€
- Madrona
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Restaurant
9.4
out of 10
out of 10
127
99.2%
- $$
- Roosevelt
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Restaurant
9.4
out of 10
out of 10
322
95.3%
- $$
- West Edge
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Restaurant
9.3
out of 10
out of 10
304
98.7%
- $$
- Morgan Junction
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Restaurant
9.1
out of 10
out of 10
135
97.8%
- $$
- Yesler Terrace
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Restaurant
9.1
out of 10
out of 10
249
98%
- $$
- Greenwood
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Pie Bar
Food (5.8 out of 10)
mentioned by 90% of the guests
When it comes to the food here, theres a definite mixed bag of opinions, with 73 positive remarks against 57 negative ones out of 144 total comments. Many rave about the delicious "Forager pie, " "apple crumble, " and "chocolate and Marion berry pie, " often highlighting the "fresh" ingredients and the availability of "savory options" and "vegan options. " It seems the sweet and savory pies, along with some "pie themed cocktails, " can truly hit the spot.
However, the food experience isnt always consistent, reflected in an average score of 5.8 and mixed customer satisfaction at 50.7%. Some diners have encountered issues with crusts being stale or tough, pie flavor being bland or artificial, and a limited pie selection or items being out of stock. There are also mentions of pies being microwaved, which can detract from the overall experience.
Food
144
Reviews
50%
Satisfaction
57
negative
14
neutral
73
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Delicious pie flavors
- Savory, vegan options
- Generous pie servings
What people don't like
- Inconsistent pie crusts
- Bland pie flavors
- Limited pie selection
Often praised
- pieMy experience was at a walk-up window where I ordered delicious BIG pieces of pie. I tried the pumpkin amaretto and banana cream.
- cocktailstonight we popped in just for cocktails and it was terrific
- foodWe LOVE the food at pie bar
- piesloved this place for their pies
- crustGreat crust, really tasty.
- dessertfavorite places for dessert
- menuIt's become one of my favorite spots for dinner, dessert, and cocktails. Everything tasted incredibly fresh, and I appreciated that the menu changes seasonally. The atmosphere is wonderfully cozy and chill, making it the perfect place to relax after a long week.
- peanut butter cream piepeanut butter cream pie with vanilla ice-creams
- peanut butter piepeanut butter pie presentation was gorgeous
- slicesThese slices are big enough to split
Frequently criticized
- pieI paid $40 and left with an unboxed pie, as the staff member stated they had no boxes for to-go orders. Upon bringing the pie home, my family agreed it was awful. We found humor in the entire experience and will not be returning.
- chicken pot pieI paid $40 and left with an unboxed pie, as the staff member stated they had no boxes for to-go orders. Upon bringing the pie home, my family agreed it was awful. We found humor in the entire experience and will not be returning.
- banana cream pieslice of the banana cream pie for my dad
- crustThe crust was cardboard in taste and texture.
- piesoverall quality of the pies and drinks has been much worse
- drinksMy experience at this restaurant was marred by a server who was obviously and extremely wasted. She struggled to string a sentence together and blamed the slow service and bad drinks on a trainee. This was despite us witnessing her pour alcohol from our drinks for herself before serving them, resulting in drinks that were only about 80% full.
- foodthe food was equally bad
- sliceI stopped by last night to pick up a slice of something yummy and ended up ordering the Banana Pie. The very small slice cost $12+ and tasted like fake banana flavored glue. It was not worth the time or money.
- Banana PieI stopped by last night to pick up a slice of something yummy and ended up ordering the Banana Pie. The very small slice cost $12+ and tasted like fake banana flavored glue. It was not worth the time or money.
- Cookies and Creme piereceived the incorrect slice. Ordered the cookies and creme and received some sort of creme pie
If youre craving a specific, well-loved pie flavor and dont mind a bit of hit-or-miss, this spot might be worth a try. However, be prepared for potential inconsistencies in crust quality or flavor, and dont be surprised if your first choice isnt available. It's a place that could delight or disappoint, depending on your luck.
Service (3.9 out of 10)
mentioned by 59% of the guests
When it comes to service, it seems like experiences here are quite a mixed bag, leaning heavily towards the challenging side. With a score of just 3.9 and customer satisfaction at a low 34.2%, its clear theres significant room for improvement. While some customers praised the friendly service, Staff, and hospitality, noting attention from servers, these positive remarks are unfortunately overshadowed by a larger volume of less favorable feedback.
Out of 76 total customer comments, 50 pointed to issues, highlighting concerns like poor customer service, disrespect, and encounters with a rude young man. Many also mentioned frustrating wait time and a general lack of basic manners. This suggests that while some staff members shine, there are consistent problems that can really impact your visit.
Service
76
Reviews
34%
Satisfaction
50
negative
0
neutral
26
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly service
- Attentive staff
- Great hospitality
What people don't like
- Rude customer service
- Long wait times
- Disrespectful staff
Often praised
- serviceWhile I'd previously paid too much attention to their delicious pies, tonight we decided to pop in just for cocktails, and it was terrific. The cute decor and great service made for a wonderful experience.
- staffIt has different ownership and products. The Cap Hill location is a great bar with a great owner and staff.
- Rain and JeffRain and Jeff were SO fun to talk with, SO welcoming
- ServiceService:5
- StaffStaff was friendly
- attentiondid provide plenty of attention
- bartender and server girlthe bartender and server girl were so nice
- contactless payment optioncontactless payment option available
- customer servicethe customer service was top tier, extremely friendly and welcoming
- dine-inService:Dine in
Frequently criticized
- customer serviceMy husband and I recently had an extremely unpleasant experience at Pie Bar on Phinney Ridge that left us feeling frustrated and disappointed. We went in with high hopes for a casual date night, eager to enjoy a slice of pie together, but were met with some of the rudest and most condescending customer service we’ve ever encountered. While I understand that everyone can have an off day or be dealing with personal challenges, there comes a point where a bad attitude crosses the line, especially when you’re charging $11 for a single slice of pie—before tip!
- serviceThe person on the phone asked "flavors of pies? " They then told me I could find them online and quickly hung up. My experience was one of unhelpful and dismissive service.
- staff memberguy behind counter took a bite — yes a real bite! — out of the pie
- staff' I sarcastically thanked her for being super nice, and she glared at me again, said 'yeah, ' and stomped off. It was REALLY mean. I was in my scrubs after a long day, feeling meek, and she looked at me as if I shouldn't have approached the place.
- staff attitudevery rudely and unapologetically informed
- waiting timewaited over an hour not once but twice
- apologyThe staff member said, “it’s gonna be a while, I have other orders to do. ” No smile, no apology. We did not get a fork or napkin to eat said pie with.
- basic mannersEven though we were simply trying to make a choice about our dessert. If she was having a bad day or dealing with a medical condition, I could have found it in myself to extend some compassion, but her complete disregard for basic manners was too much to overlook and made our first experience at their establishment a horrible one. To add insult to injury, the pie itself was just okay—nothing special.
- boxesguy said they didn’t have boxes for “to go” orders
- closing timeWe did not get a fork or napkin to eat said pie with. We then sat down at a table and were told that we might get “swept out” because they don’t usually seat people 30 minutes before closing, even though there were like 5 other tables still eating. I’m spending money at your establishment, not breaking into your kitchen at home demanding you heat me up a hot pocket.
If youre heading here, be prepared for potentially inconsistent service; you might get a friendly face or a less-than-pleasant interaction. While some find the staff attentive, others report significant issues with rudeness and long waits. Its a bit of a gamble, so manage your expectations accordingly.
Ambience (6 out of 10)
mentioned by 46% of the guests
When it comes to atmosphere, this spot offers some real charm! Many guests (24 out of 42 observations) loved the cute and cozy space, praising the outdoor seating and great atmosphere, with some even enjoying a unique PNW vibe. While the overall score for ambience is an average 6, theres definitely a pleasant side to the setting.
However, the experience isnt always smooth sailing, as 16 observations point out some bumps. Some found the entrance difficult to locate, mentioned tight spaces, and frequently struggled with impossible parking. This contributes to a mixed 57.1% customer satisfaction, suggesting that while the vibe can be good, practicalities can be a challenge.
Ambience
42
Reviews
57%
Satisfaction
16
negative
2
neutral
24
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Cute, cozy space
- Great outdoor seating
- Relaxing PNW vibe
What people don't like
- Difficult to find
- Impossible parking
- Can get crowded
Often praised
- atmosphereCozy and chill atmosphere
- outdoor seatingThe outdoor seating is relaxing
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- PNW atmosphereFar out PNW atmosphere
- booth seatingMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic! It's a great place to warm up or chill out with its cozy bar and booth seating indoors, and a street-side deck outdoors. The atmosphere is a far out PNW vibe.
- covered outdoor seatingCovered outdoor seating area
- cozy barMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic! It's a great place to warm up or chill out with its cozy bar and booth seating indoors, and a street-side deck outdoors. The atmosphere is a far out PNW vibe.
- cute and cozy spaceit's a very cute and cozy space
- date spotGreat date spot
- decorWhile I'd previously paid too much attention to their delicious pies, tonight we decided to pop in just for cocktails, and it was terrific. The cute decor and great service made for a wonderful experience.
Frequently criticized
- atmosphereAtmosphere: speakeasy meets late night Denny’s
- entrancedifficult to find the entrance & it is not clearly marked
- parkingattempting to park nearby on a Friday Night
- counterThis is totally different from the cookies and cream slices I have had in the past from here and is really disappointing for the price. I'm not sure what’s going on at this place; the counter they prepared it on also was pretty dirty.
- crowdedIt gets crowded as anywhere I've been
- date nightThe whole ordeal left us with a sour taste, both literally and figuratively. A date night that should have been relaxing and enjoyable turned into a frustrating experience. When you’re running a business—especially one as niche as a pie bar—treating your customers with respect should be a given.
- display casenever saw a display case
- front doorHad a hard time finding the front door
- getting into the buildinggetting into the building is always so sketchy
- protest out frontThere was a protest out front.
So, if youre looking for a charming, cozy spot with outdoor options and dont mind a bit of a hunt for parking or navigating tight spaces, you might enjoy the vibe. But if ease of access and spaciousness are top priorities, you might find it a bit frustrating.
Value (2.5 out of 10)
mentioned by 35% of the guests
When it comes to value, a few customers have found some silver linings, noting that certain items, particularly large slices, can be worth what they're paying and well worth every bite. Terms like price per slice and worth what I'm paying pop up in the 4 positive remarks, suggesting that for specific offerings, the perceived value can be quite good. However, the overall sentiment paints a different picture, with a poor score of 2.5 and customer satisfaction sitting at a poor 12.1%.
Out of 33 total comments, a significant 29 express disappointment, frequently using terms like expensive, overpriced, and pricey. Many feel the portions are small for the cost, leading to a general sense that the value just isn't there.
Value
33
Reviews
12%
Satisfaction
29
negative
0
neutral
4
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Large slices worth price
What people don't like
- Pie is overpriced
- Small portions, high price
- Not worth the money
Often praised
- priceThe price is well worth every bite
- price per personPrice per person:$10–20
- price per sliceI tried the pumpkin amaretto and banana cream. These slices are big enough to split between two people, which makes it worth the price per slice. The crust is made in house and doesn't taste factory-made.
- worth what im payingit will be worth what im paying for it
Frequently criticized
- priceIt used to be a white pie with cookie chunks in it, but I received a nondescript tasting brown pie that just tastes like whipped cream, with chocolate sauce and cookies thrown on top. This is totally different from the cookies and cream slices I have had in the past from here and is really disappointing for the price. I'm not sure what’s going on at this place; the counter they prepared it on also was pretty dirty.
- pie40 dollar pie in what world be for real
- slice of pieWe went in with high hopes for a casual date night, eager to enjoy a slice of pie together, but were met with some of the rudest and most condescending customer service we’ve ever encountered. While I understand that everyone can have an off day or be dealing with personal challenges, there comes a point where a bad attitude crosses the line, especially when you’re charging $11 for a single slice of pie—before tip! The issue started when we asked the woman at the counter if they had a cherry pie flavor available.
- expensiveBut expensive
- pricescharge understandable prices but it seems like every small shop wants to charge 2-3 times as much
- $10 slice of pieexpect more for a $10 slice piece of pie
- credit cardcharged our credit card a higher price than what they verbally stated
- discountshould have at least received a $5.00 discount, as he ate part of the pie
- everything in this cityeverything in this city. For this reason im going to go to safeway
- price pointespecially considering the price point
If youre looking for great value, this spot might leave you feeling short-changed. Many customers find the prices dont match the portion sizes or quality, making it a tough recommendation for those on a budget.
How are the prices at Pie Bar?
On average, you’ll spend around 21 per person – from 35 guests. That puts the restaurant in the $21–$30 category. For a Restaurant, that’s mid-range, maybe slightly above.
While the average lands at 21, its interesting to note that most diners actually spend a bit less, with the biggest group falling into the $11–$20 range. Theres a good mix, but it leans towards the more affordable side for a Restaurant.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 35 reviews.
Lets see how this restaurants value for money stacks up against similar spots in Seattle.
Overall, we think the pricing here feels pretty fair for a Restaurant in Seattle. It offers a good mid-range option, especially since many guests find themselves spending a bit less than the average.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Pie Bar
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
3
Disappointing Pies, Okay Experience
My experience at this restaurant was a mixed bag. I ordered a piece of banana cream pie and a cookies and cream pie. The banana cream pie was served as a liquid pile of slop, which we returned.
The cookies and cream pie was delivered as a peanut butter and cream pie. While structurally sound and adequate, it wasn't what I ordered, though I ate it anyway. Mistakes happen, but serving that banana pile of disappointment was baffling.
The individual who served us was nice about it, though. Overall, a well-prepared piece was okay, but expensive. I might try elsewhere next time.
- cookies and cream pie5
- well prepared piece6
- dude8
- banana cream pie2
- price3
- expensive3
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
2
Disappointing Pie Change
Like August’s review, I too ordered the cookies and cream pie tonight and am so confused by it. It used to be a white pie with cookie chunks in it, but I received a nondescript tasting brown pie that just tastes like whipped cream, with chocolate sauce and cookies thrown on top. This is totally different from the cookies and cream slices I have had in the past from here and is really disappointing for the price.
I'm not sure what’s going on at this place; the counter they prepared it on also was pretty dirty.
- cookies and cream pie2
- price3
- counter2
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
2
Incorrect Pie Received, Disappointing Experience
I was disappointed to receive the incorrect slice of pie. I ordered the Cookies and Creme pie but received what appeared to be a creme pie with chocolate syrup and some cookie toppings. Upon cross-referencing with the photo, it was very different from what was listed.
The pie was missing whipped cream, I'm unsure if chocolate syrup was a standard topping, and the creme pie itself contained no cookie. My guess is that it was a chocolate pie. Whatever it was, it was disappointing, especially considering the price point.
- Cookies and Creme pie2
- creme pie2
- price point3
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
2
Disappointing Pies and Difficult Entrance
It was difficult to find the restaurant's entrance as it was not clearly marked. I ordered a slice of beef pie and a slice of chicken pie. The chicken pie was unrecognizable as pie; it was just a mound of crumbled crust with chicken gravy mush.
While the crust was good, that's where the positives ended. The beef pie was even worse, lacking flavor, and the beef chunks were the size of boxed carrots and peas. The server was friendly and provided plenty of attention.
However, despite the friendly conversation, we will not be returning.
- crust7
- server8
- attention8
- entrance2
- chicken pie1
- beef pie2
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
2
Expensive Pie, Upset Stomach
My experience was disappointing. I found the pie to be expensive, and the cookies and cream pie was not stored in the fridge. This led to me feeling quite upset stomach.
Paying $15 for a slice was definitely a shock.
- pie2
- slice1
- expensive2
What Pie Bar offers
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Amenities
- Gender-neutral restroom
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Offerings
- Late-night food
- Hard liquor
- Vegan options
- Happy hour drinks
- Quick bite
- Wine
- Coffee
- Beer
- Small plates
- Cocktails
- Vegetarian options
- Alcohol
Dining options
- Catering
- Brunch
- Counter service
- Table service
- Dessert
- Dinner
- Seating
- Lunch
Service Options
- Delivery
- Takeout
- Curbside pickup
- Dine-in
- Outdoor seating
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside
Parking
- Usually difficult to find a space
- Free street parking
Atmosphere
- Cozy
- Casual
FAQs
What accessibility features does Pie Bar - Phinney offer?
Pie Bar in Greenwood ensures a comfortable visit for everyone, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, seating, and restroom. The venue is designed to be inclusive, allowing all guests to enjoy its cozy atmosphere and great dessert offerings without hindrance.
Does Pie Bar - Phinney cater to specific dietary needs or late-night cravings?
Yes, Pie Bar offers a diverse menu including both vegan and vegetarian options to accommodate various dietary preferences. Additionally, it’s a fantastic spot for late-night food, ensuring you can satisfy those cravings well into the evening.
How is Pie Bar rated overall by customers?
Pie Bar holds an overall Restaurant Score of 5 with a Customer Satisfaction of 43.1%. Its Ambience (6) and Food (5.8) are generally well-regarded, but Service (3.9) and Value (2.5) often fall short.
What do customers enjoy most about Pie Bar?
Many patrons appreciate the delicious pies and creative cocktails. The cozy and chill atmosphere, often described as a great date spot, is also a significant draw.
What are the common complaints about Pie Bar?
Frequent concerns revolve around inconsistent service, with some experiences described as unhelpful or rude. The value for money is also a recurring issue, with many finding the prices to be on the higher side.