Supreme - Reviews

My experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing, especially concerning the pizza. The amazing online reviews made me wonder if they were written by people who were not sober, as my actual experience was far from it. The pizza was atrocious, flopping worse than a Costco slice with a pound of cheese. It felt and tasted like the slices were reheated in a microwave, resulting in a soft and rubbery texture. Despite the pizza's poor quality, the person at the bar seemed friendly. I couldn't understand what was wrong with the pizza; it was so bad that after holding a slice, I questioned if I had offended the staff, even though I just ordered a slice and left a 20% tip. I've concluded that the pizza just sucks there. It's surprising given the online hype. Honestly, Whole Foods pizza is significantly better. The place has a typical dive bar feel, and the service was normal. The food was offensive, to be blunt.

My experience at the restaurant was okay. It's fine, and not expensive, but still somehow a bit expensive for what it is. Though to be fair, Talarico's across the street is $10 a slice, so maybe pizza prices are just getting out of hand in general.

My first time at this restaurant was a bit confusing as there was no guidance on how to order. I ordered two slices of pepperoni and a salad to share with my husband. The food portions were plentiful and tasted okay, but nothing stood out as particularly special. The music, a mix of funk and rap, didn't contribute to a fun or inviting atmosphere. The two workers we encountered were unfriendly and seemed robotic. I might give it another chance, perhaps they were just having an off day.

I still believe Supreme offers the best NY style pizza in the area, but I've noticed a decline in quality over the past few years. It seems like they're rushing orders, leading to sloppy preparation. While I enjoy garlic, I don't appreciate chunks the size of teeth; more finely chopped garlic would be appreciated. Additionally, the pizza hasn't been finishing properly in the oven lately, resulting in soft, undercooked dough and barely melted cheese.

My experience at Supreme was a great value for pizza by the slice when I just wanted a snack. The restaurant has an old-school dive bar feel, with friendly staff and a lively atmosphere. There are a few TVs for sports, making it a fun place to catch a game. While the atmosphere and service were top-notch (rated 5/5), it's important to note that this restaurant is 21+. Parking can be somewhat difficult to find, and it's a paid parking lot. The price per person is very affordable, ranging from $1–$10.

Visiting West Seattle for a month, and this was my favorite bar. We asked for a channel on one of the TVs, and the bartender accommodated us in less than 30 seconds. The French 75 I ordered was perfect, and my husband said the beer recommendation was on point. They have a classic video game system with a ton of games, and we both played games from our (millennial) childhood while sitting at the bar. The bartender made us feel funny and smart, even though we were a little drunk. Pizza by the slice!

My experience at Supreme was absolutely incredible. I dream about their pizza, and the chef is the nicest person alive, always custom making a goat cheese Detroit-style pizza for me. I can't say enough good things about the staff, the food, and everything about Supreme. It was a 10/10 stars experience.

I visited this restaurant, which was on my list from a Seattle food magazine, specifically for their Portuguese sausage, ham, and jalapeno pizza. As someone of Portuguese heritage, I was particularly excited about the linguica offering. Unfortunately, the pizza didn't deliver the expected flavor, or much flavor at all. For a $44 pie, I was hoping for more, and this left me wanting. On the positive side, the sizes are huge, so even though it was pricey, my husband and I enjoyed this for three lunches later in the week. I'd recommend getting a slice instead of a whole pie, as they reheat slices to be crisper on the bottom, whereas the whole pie was a bit softer. The atmosphere was rated 5, and service was also rated 5, but the noise level was very loud, making it hard to hear.

My friend and I visited Supreme for the first time due to a late-night craving. We ordered two slices to-go: the Detroit and the chef's choice. The atmosphere was great, and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves, which built our excitement. However, after waiting for about 20 minutes, we still hadn't received our slices. Initially, we didn't think much of it, assuming they were still heating them. We then noticed the bartender take two slices out of the oven that appeared to be ours, but they were completely burnt. While we understood it was an honest mistake, the lack of acknowledgment or a replacement order was frustrating. After an additional 5–10 minutes with no update, we approached the bar. The bartender confirmed our order and stated it would be ready in three minutes. Ultimately, we received our slices over 30 minutes after ordering, with no apology or attempt to rectify the situation. The pizza itself was good, but the overall experience left a negative impression.

My experience at this restaurant was centered around their insanely delicious pizza. While the food quality, particularly the pizza, was a perfect 5 out of 5, the atmosphere was more suited for adults. It's a bar, so it's not a family-friendly place. However, it's perfect for a date night or hooking up with friends. The service received a rating of 3, and the atmosphere a 4.