Highlights
- Sports
oChef » Supreme – Seattle
Supreme - Seattle
Photo from Supreme
Supreme at a glance
Seattle Alaska Junction
- 🍕 Pizzeria
$$
Price per Person $21–$30
mentioned by 35 of the guests
#695 out of 858 places to eat in Seattle
#29 Pizzeria out of 43 in Seattle
Good
6.4 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
426
Reviews
60.3%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Quality pizza
- Great staff
- Lively vibe
Frequently criticized
- Slow service
- High price
- Loud venue
The pizzeria Supreme in Seattle’s vibrant Alaska Junction neighborhood offers a fantastic spot for delicious pies and a lively atmosphere. You can catch your favorite game here, making it a prime destination for sports enthusiasts.
This casual and cozy eatery is known for its trendy vibe, perfect for a relaxed evening out. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a full dinner, Supreme has you covered with its inviting setting and diverse menu.
Overview: Introducting Supreme
Supreme offers a lively experience, often praised for its high quality pizza slices that many find satisfying. Guests frequently highlight the friendly staff and a generally fun atmosphere, making it a popular spot for a casual outing.
However, some opinions suggest that the value proposition can be a point of contention. While the food often hits the mark, Supreme occasionally faces criticism regarding its pricing, with some finding it overpriced for certain items.
Service, though often lauded, can sometimes be inconsistent, and the overall environment might be perceived as loud and crowded by some patrons.
Good
6.4
out of 10
426
Reviews
60.3%
Satisfaction
135
negative
34
neutral
257
positive
Supreme achieves an overall Restaurant Score of 6.4, placing it in the average category, while customer satisfaction stands at a mixed 60.3%. This indicates a generally acceptable experience, though there’s room for improvement in certain areas.
The feedback comes from 426 customer opinions, with 257 positive and 135 negative remarks. Looking closer, Food leads with a score of (6.6), suggesting it’s a strong point for many.
The Ambience also performs well at (7.8), indicating a generally enjoyable setting. However, Service (5.6) and Value (5.1) hover in the lower average range, reflecting areas where experiences can vary and some customers feel less satisfied.
What people like
- Quality pizza slices
- Engaging staff
- Lively atmosphere
What people don't like
- Inconsistent service
- Perceived high price
- Noisy environment
Supreme appears to be a solid choice if you’re primarily seeking good pizza in a vibrant setting. The establishment clearly excels in delivering a satisfying meal and a lively atmosphere, making it suitable for those who appreciate a casual, energetic spot.
With a Recommendation Score of 6.7, it’s worth considering, especially if you prioritize quality food and a fun vibe over absolute quiet or strict budget adherence. Be prepared for a potentially bustling environment and service that, while often good, might occasionally be a bit slow.
Similar Restaurants in Seattle
- Pizzeria
9.2
out of 10
out of 10
93
94.6%
- $$
- Ballard
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
9
out of 10
out of 10
414
92.3%
- $$
- South Lake Union
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.6
out of 10
out of 10
228
89%
- $$
- Fremont
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.6
out of 10
out of 10
237
92.8%
- $$
- Portage Bay
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.4
out of 10
out of 10
587
84.8%
- $$
- Queen Anne
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.4
out of 10
out of 10
417
87.1%
- $$
- Uptown
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Supreme
Food (6.6 out of 10)
mentioned by 92% of the guests
When it comes to the food here, many diners are absolutely raving! With 148 positive remarks out of 238 total, the pizza is a clear standout, particularly the beloved Detroit style and classic NY style pizza. Guests frequently praise the delicious crust, quality ingredients, and even the tasty wings and boozy slushies.
It seems theres a lot to love, contributing to a solid 6.6 score. However, the culinary journey isnt always perfect, as reflected in a mixed 62.2% customer satisfaction. Some experiences point to a decline in overall quality and preparation, with concerns about undercooked dough and skimpy toppings.
Issues like soggy crust and cold food have also been noted, suggesting there's still room for improvement in consistency and execution.
Food
238
Reviews
62%
Satisfaction
71
negative
19
neutral
148
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Delicious NY/Detroit pizza
- Great crust
- Tasty wings
What people don't like
- Inconsistent quality
- Soggy/cold pizza
- Skimpy toppings
Often praised
- pizzaMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The pizza is perfectly priced for its quality, and the novelty slices are all delicious and undervalued. The beer and mixes are on par with the rest of the junction and are cheap for the greater Seattle area.
- drinksIt has a dive bar vibe but serves high quality pizza slices and drinks. I enjoyed sipping on boozy slushy drinks to beat the heat, and they also offer bottles and draft beer. The atmosphere includes pinball, with options for bar or table seating.
- foodthe food, everything about Supreme
- pizza slicesMy experience at this restaurant was great! It has a dive bar vibe but serves high quality pizza slices and drinks. I enjoyed sipping on boozy slushy drinks to beat the heat, and they also offer bottles and draft beer.
- FoodFood:5
- crustExcellent undercarriage & bake on the crust again
- pepperoni pizzabest pepperoni pizza available in West Seattle
- sauceSomething about the sauce the make, just makes this one of the best slices
- slicestill thinking about that slice from here
- slicesThe slices are huge and always delicious
Frequently criticized
- pizzaI believe it's worth driving out of the way to find better and more consistent pizza. Furthermore, anyone claiming this is East Coast style pizza hasn't spent much time on the East Coast or has no sense of taste.
- toppingsMy family LOVES pizza from Supreme in West Seattle. However, they really skimp out on toppings. I ordered one topping basil for my cheese pizza and received only 8 basil leaves for $2, which is 25 cents per leaf.
- cheeseThe slice was not even warm and did not look appealing. The cheese left a weird aftertaste. However, the staff was friendly.
- crustthe crust was NOT the best
- foodFood and variety alone could be better
- raw garlicuse of raw garlic in the plain cheese slice
- wingswings were discontinued by the owner. So sad!
- Caesar saladThe salad was to tart that we can't take the 3rd bite
- Detroit styleThe Detroit style I would not recommend here
- NY pizza doughNY pizza dough was both under-proofed and under cooked
If youre craving a delicious slice of New York or Detroit style pizza, especially late at night, this spot often hits the mark with its great crust and tasty options. However, be aware that consistency can be an issue, with some experiences reporting quality dips and cold food. Its worth a try for the highlights, but manage expectations for a perfect meal every time.
Service (5.6 out of 10)
mentioned by 58% of the guests
When it comes to service, this spot offers a mixed bag, with a customer satisfaction hovering around 49.5%. Many guests, however, rave about the friendly staff, especially the bartenders and servers, who often go above and beyond. With 50 positive opinions out of 101, theres definitely a bright side to the interactions here, highlighting great customer service from individuals like Joe and Stephanie.
On the flip side, the service score of 5.6 suggests theres room for improvement. About 48 opinions point to issues like slow service and long waiting times, particularly for online orders. Some experiences mention unresponsive communication and even rude interactions, indicating inconsistency in the overall customer experience.
Service
101
Reviews
49%
Satisfaction
48
negative
3
neutral
50
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly staff
- Great bartenders
- Attentive servers
What people don't like
- Slow service
- Unresponsive communication
- Rude interactions
Often praised
- staffWhen Supreme is on its game, there isn’t a better East Coast slice in town in my opinion. They’ve always tried their best with staffing, and I’ve never had a bad experience interacting with any of the staff. The people are very friendly, but can understandably be stressed when it’s very busy.
- serviceMy experience at Supreme was delicious with good service and a fun atmosphere. It's a top pick for a late-night snack because not many places in West Seattle serve food after 11 pm, but Supreme always does.
- ServiceService:5
- bartenderthe bartender accommodated us in less than 30 seconds
- bartendersThe place was clean, and they serve good pizza. What truly stood out were the amazing bartenders; they even started ordering more of what I like as I became a regular. I can't say enough good things about this place!
- customer serviceThe fellow named Joe behind the bar has never ceased to impress us. He should teach a master’s course on customer service. We also love the other all-stars who have served us over the last month: Stephanie, Milo, Armine, and Nicole.
- friendly staffMy experience at Supreme was a great value for pizza by the slice when I just wanted a snack. The restaurant has an old-school dive bar feel, with friendly staff and a lively atmosphere. There are a few TVs for sports, making it a fun place to catch a game.
- ArmineHe should teach a master’s course on customer service. We also love the other all-stars who have served us over the last month: Stephanie, Milo, Armine, and Nicole.
- JoeJoe behind the bar who has never ceased to impress us
- MiloHe should teach a master’s course on customer service. We also love the other all-stars who have served us over the last month: Stephanie, Milo, Armine, and Nicole.
Frequently criticized
- serviceThe services was a bit slow.
- responseAfter no response for several days
- waiting timeAfter about 20 minutes of waiting, we still hadn’t received our slices
- bartendershe asked if I had squeezed the lemon on it. Thought that was an odd thing to ask
- deliverydelivery using Caviar has ended up with cold pizza
- ordershe only took 1/2 the order
- accountabilityno inkling of accountability
- acknowledgementhe didn’t acknowledge the error or put in a replacement order
- apologywith no apology or effort to make the situation right
- attention to detaillast two visits showed a lack of attention to detail
The service here can be a bit of a gamble. If youre lucky, youll encounter friendly and attentive staff who make your visit enjoyable. However, be prepared for potential delays or communication issues that might dampen the experience.
Ambience (7.8 out of 10)
mentioned by 40% of the guests
The ambience here generally hits the mark, with a 7.8 score indicating a good experience for most. Customers are quite happy, with 83.3% satisfaction, reflecting a great vibe. Many of the 50 positive comments praise the super chill atmosphere, retro feel, and lively atmosphere, often highlighting the full bar and game playing options.
However, its not always perfect. A few of the 4 negative comments point to issues like the noise level being too high, sometimes creating a poor vibe. Its also noted that while it has a dive bar vibe, its not family friendly, ' which might be a dealbreaker for some.
Ambience
60
Reviews
83%
Satisfaction
4
negative
6
neutral
50
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Super chill atmosphere
- Retro games, pinball
- Lively dive bar
What people don't like
- High noise level
- Not family friendly
Often praised
- atmosphereMy experience at Supreme was delicious with good service and a fun atmosphere. It's a top pick for a late-night snack because not many places in West Seattle serve food after 11 pm, but Supreme always does.
- barMy experience at the restaurant was fantastic! I chose to sit at the bar, enjoy a drink, and was so happy when the pizza was placed in front of me. The overall experience was excellent, with top marks for service, atmosphere, and food.
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- vibeThe pizza, vibe and booze smoothies were amazing!
- placecertainly fun for a lively place
- PS2 controllerscouple PS2 controllers at the end of the bar
- This placeShane at the bar truly changed my life, and the heroes running the kitchen were beyond words. This place is heaven, and today's visit felt like a revival. While I'm often reminded why I can't bartend again, the folks here, especially Shane, make it look like a dream, even on a crazy busy day.
- arcadeDope arcade
- artsee the art there
- clean environmenta clean environment
Frequently criticized
- atmosphereThe atmosphere gets a lower rating from me because it's usually loud and crowded
- family friendlyit is a bar so not a family friendly place
- noise levelNoise level:Very loud, hard to hear
- poor vibeit created a poor vibe right from the start
If you're looking for a lively, adult-friendly spot with a retro, chill atmosphere and games, this place is definitely worth checking out. However, if you prefer a quiet, family-oriented environment, you might find the noise level and vibe less appealing.
Value (5.1 out of 10)
mentioned by 20% of the guests
When it comes to value, some customers are quite pleased, noting the pizza is perfectly priced for its quality, offering money's worth with large slices and cheap prices, even for beer and mixes. These positive feelings come from 9 reviews out of 27 total, contributing to an overall score of 5.1, which is about average, though customer satisfaction lags at a poor 33.3%. However, a larger group of 12 reviews out of 27 express disappointment, finding the restaurant overpriced, especially for a whole pie or when adding toppings.
Many felt the cost was too high for the quality, leading to a sense of being overcharged and not worth the hype.
Value
27
Reviews
33%
Satisfaction
12
negative
6
neutral
9
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Perfectly priced pizza
- Affordable beer/mixes
- Get money's worth
What people don't like
- Overpriced whole pies
- Costly extra toppings
- Poor value for quality
Often praised
- priceThe price is reasonable for the area
- $10And only $10!
- Price per personPrice per person:$1–10
- beer and mixesThe pizza is perfectly priced for its quality, and the novelty slices are all delicious and undervalued. The beer and mixes are on par with the rest of the junction and are cheap for the greater Seattle area. I love the bartenders.
- money's worthyou get your money's worth
- pizzaPizza is perfectly prized for it's quality
- pricesLiving in New York on a grad student budget, pizza was a staple, and Supreme Pizza is the closest I've found to authentic New York Pizza on the West Coast. They offer large slices with quality ingredients at cheap prices. My partner and I both LOVE this place, and we're usually not ones to revisit spots often because there's so much to explore.
- tiphappy to pay the tip
Frequently criticized
- priceI ordered pizza for delivery, and my experience was just okay. The restaurant was way over hyped and over priced. The pizza itself was quite thin, and in terms of taste, it was disappointing.
- Parking spaceParking space:Somewhat difficult to find parking
- costworse than dominos but three times the cost
- extra cheese, onion, pepper and sausagepaid $12 extra for the extra (supposedly) cheese, onion, pepper and sausage.
- hypeWay over hyped
- one piepaid $44 for one pie and this was so not worth it.
- overpriced pizzaout the overpriced pizza
- pieFor a $44 pie I was hoping for more and this left me wanting more.
- pre-tipIt's a simple gesture, but it's difficult to understand why saying thank you to a new, friendly customer is a challenge, especially when no extra service like cleaning up or dealing with excessive alcohol consumption was required. The order cost $20, plus a 10% pre-tip, which felt undeserved given the experience. I genuinely wanted to like this place 🤷🏻.
- price for toppingspaid $15 just for the toppings
Overall, value here is a mixed bag. If youre looking for a cheap slice and a drink, you might find it reasonable. But be cautious if youre ordering a whole pie or piling on the toppings, as many find it overpriced.
How are the prices at Supreme?
You’re looking at roughly 22 per person – reported by 35 diners. That puts it in the $21–$30 category. For a Pizzeria, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
Looking at what folks actually spend, we see prices mostly clustering in the $11–$20 and $21–$30 ranges, which is right around our average. But there are also some great budget-friendly options and a few choices for those looking to splurge a bit more.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 35 reviews.
How this Pizzeria’s value stacks up against similar spots in Seattle.
Overall, we think the pricing here feels pretty fair for a Pizzeria in Seattle. It offers good value for that mid-range sweet spot, with options for different budgets.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Supreme
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Group Type
- Solo Dinner
Group Size
- Solo
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Lunch
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
Noise Level
- Quiet
2
Disappointing Pizza, Average Experience
My experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing, especially concerning the pizza. The amazing online reviews made me wonder if they were written by people who were not sober, as my actual experience was far from it. The pizza was atrocious, flopping worse than a Costco slice with a pound of cheese.
It felt and tasted like the slices were reheated in a microwave, resulting in a soft and rubbery texture. Despite the pizza's poor quality, the person at the bar seemed friendly. I couldn't understand what was wrong with the pizza; it was so bad that after holding a slice, I questioned if I had offended the staff, even though I just ordered a slice and left a 20% tip.
I've concluded that the pizza just sucks there. It's surprising given the online hype. Honestly, Whole Foods pizza is significantly better.
The place has a typical dive bar feel, and the service was normal. The food was offensive, to be blunt.
- person at the bar7
- dive bar feel5
- service5
- pizza1
- food1
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
5
Expensive for what it is
My experience at the restaurant was okay. It's fine, and not expensive, but still somehow a bit expensive for what it is. Though to be fair, Talarico's across the street is $10 a slice, so maybe pizza prices are just getting out of hand in general.
- price5
- pizza prices5
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Casual Outing
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
5
Okay Food, Lacking Service and Atmosphere
My first time at this restaurant was a bit confusing as there was no guidance on how to order. I ordered two slices of pepperoni and a salad to share with my husband. The food portions were plentiful and tasted okay, but nothing stood out as particularly special.
The music, a mix of funk and rap, didn't contribute to a fun or inviting atmosphere. The two workers we encountered were unfriendly and seemed robotic. I might give it another chance, perhaps they were just having an off day.
- food portions5
- pepperoni5
- salads5
- workers2
- ordering process3
Visit Type
- Regular Visit
6
Supreme Pizza Quality Declining
I still believe Supreme offers the best NY style pizza in the area, but I've noticed a decline in quality over the past few years. It seems like they're rushing orders, leading to sloppy preparation. While I enjoy garlic, I don't appreciate chunks the size of teeth; more finely chopped garlic would be appreciated.
Additionally, the pizza hasn't been finishing properly in the oven lately, resulting in soft, undercooked dough and barely melted cheese.
- NY style pizza8
- quality3
- preparation3
- garlic4
Price per Person
- $1–$10
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Dine-in
Noise Level
- Loud
8
Great Value Pizza and Lively Atmosphere
My experience at Supreme was a great value for pizza by the slice when I just wanted a snack. The restaurant has an old-school dive bar feel, with friendly staff and a lively atmosphere. There are a few TVs for sports, making it a fun place to catch a game.
While the atmosphere and service were top-notch (rated 5/5), it's important to note that this restaurant is 21+. Parking can be somewhat difficult to find, and it's a paid parking lot. The price per person is very affordable, ranging from $1–$10.
- pizza by the slice8
- old-school dive bar feel8
- friendly staff10
- Parking space3
What Supreme offers
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
- Groups
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Amenities
- Restroom
- Free Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
- Bar onsite
Offerings
- Late-night food
- Hard liquor
- Happy hour drinks
- Quick bite
- Wine
- Beer
- Happy hour food
- Cocktails
- Alcohol
Dining options
- Table service
- Dessert
- Dinner
- Seating
- Lunch
Service Options
- Dine-in
- Takeout
- Delivery
Parking
- Paid parking lot
- Free street parking
- Paid street parking
Atmosphere
- Cozy
- Casual
- Trendy
FAQs
What service options are available at Supreme in Seattle's Alaska Junction?
At Supreme, you have several convenient service options to choose from. You can enjoy a relaxed meal with dine-in service, grab your order to go with takeout, or have your favorite pizza delivered right to your door. They also offer late-night food options.
What kind of atmosphere and beverage options can you expect at Supreme?
Supreme offers a cozy, casual, and trendy atmosphere, making it a great spot for any occasion. You can enjoy a wide selection of beverages, including hard liquor, wine, beer, and cocktails. Don’t miss their happy hour drinks and food specials for an even better experience.
What is Supreme's overall rating and what do customers think about its key aspects?
Supreme holds an overall Restaurant Score of 6.4, with customer satisfaction at 60.3%. Customers generally appreciate the Food (6.6) and Ambience (7.8), while Service (5.6) and Value (5.1) receive more mixed feedback.
What do customers appreciate most about Supreme?
Customers frequently praise Supreme for its high quality pizza slices, often highlighting the delicious taste and variety. The friendly staff and the fun, lively atmosphere are also commonly mentioned as positive aspects of their experience.
Are there any common complaints about Supreme?
Some customers have noted that the service can be slow or inconsistent at times. There are also opinions suggesting that the pricing can be high, leading to a perception of less value. Additionally, the atmosphere can be loud and crowded, which might not appeal to everyone.