oChef » Mike’s Giant New York Pizza – San Diego » Mike’s Giant New York Pizza – San Diego – Reviews

Mike's Giant New York Pizza - Reviews

2357 Reo Dr, 92139 San Diego
All reviews at a glance
315

Reviews

79.4%

Satisfaction

58

negative

7

neutral

250

positive

What people say about Mike's Giant New York Pizza

Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Family Dinner
Group Type
  • Family
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Dawn P.
Review date: 12/14/2025
10
Amazing Pizza, Friendly Staff!
My family and I absolutely love this place! When family visits from out of town, they specifically ask to come here. The crust is AH-mazing, and they are generous with the real cheese and plentiful toppings. Mike and the staff truly care about the quality and the overall experience. It's a place with friendly service, good prices, and superior pizza.
  • crust10
  • real cheese9
  • toppings9
Price per Person
  • $31–$40
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Family
Group Size
  • Large Group
Service Type
  • Takeout
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Wait Time
  • Moderate (16–30 min.)
Noise Level
  • Quiet
Irene P.
Review date: 11/19/2025
9
Delicious Pizza and Great Greek Salad!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic, especially with their Greek salad and, of course, their pizza. While I haven't tried anything else, their pizza is significantly better than what you'd find at Little Caesars or Pizza Hut. The giant pizza was perfect for a get-together with kids. The staff was friendly, and even though we usually call for pickup, it never takes longer than 20 minutes. There's plenty of parking available, and the atmosphere was very quiet.
  • Greek salad9
  • pizza10
  • giant pizza9
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Vinsent R.
Review date: 09/11/2025
2
Unpleasant Service, Good Food
My first time here, I noticed all the food options but no drink prices. I paid with card and cash for the pizza. Afterward, I got a drink because I didn't want to go elsewhere. The staff member then became upset because I didn't have cash for the soda and only told me the price when my food was ready, refusing to talk to me otherwise. I felt he was being racist because when a white woman's pizza was ready, he said, "Ma'am, your pizza is ready, do you need cheese and peppers? " When he called me, he just said, "Ready, " and I had to ask for cheese and peppers myself; he didn't even offer. There was no one else there, and he wasn't busy. He was eating while making my food and I never saw him wash his hands after putting food in his mouth.
  • food options8
  • drink prices2
  • staff member1
  • staff communication1
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Patricia C.
Review date: 08/15/2025
10
Live Mikes Pizza: Outstanding Food and Service!
My experience at Live Mikes Pizza was absolutely outstanding! I had their pizza, which is hands down the best around. I also tried their manicotti, and it was incredible. The guys working there are great and incredibly welcoming.
  • pizza10
  • manicotti10
  • guys10
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Lunch
Noise Level
  • Moderate
David N.
Review date: 06/20/2025
1
Disappointing Experience, Avoid This Place
My experience at this restaurant was extremely negative. I was shocked by the poor treatment and would advise others to be wary. The service was terrible, and the atmosphere was equally unpleasant. I cannot recommend this establishment.
  • service1
  • atmosphere1
Price per Person
  • $61–$70
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Lunch
Wait Time
  • Immediate (0–5 min.)
Noise Level
  • Quiet
Gale M.
Review date: 05/21/2025
2
Waste of Money Hamburger
My experience at this restaurant was a complete waste of money. I ordered the $15. 99 Hamburger, which came with fries and a salad. The portion of fries was so small I could count them. Given the price and the minuscule portion of fries, I felt this was a terrible value. I would advise others to stay far and away from this place.
  • Hamburger1
  • fries1
  • waste of money1
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Lunch
Houston E. N. I.
Review date: 04/16/2025
9
A Taste of Tradition and Nostalgia
My experience at this restaurant was a delightful journey through time. The atmosphere was enhanced by a rich sense of tradition, boasting 37 years of history. This was complemented by a side serving of nostalgia. Bon Appétit!
  • atmosphere10
  • tradition10
  • nostalgia10
Price per Person
  • $1–$10
Visit Type
  • Regular Visit
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Cody B.
Review date: 04/13/2025
9
Best Crust and Amazing Sauce!
I've been a regular here for about a year, visiting at least once a month. My experience has been consistently excellent. The crust is hands down the best in the area, and the sauce is amazing. The customer service is outstanding, and the pricing for what they offer is totally fair. We usually get the XL pepperoni, and it's always a great choice.
  • crust10
  • sauce9
  • customer service10
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Dale B.
Review date: 04/13/2025
9
Best Fries and Sandwiches!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic. The fries were consistently hot and crispy, and the salad was absolutely amazing. I also thoroughly enjoyed the meatball sandwich, which was delicious. Everything I've tried here has been great.
  • fries9
  • salad10
  • meatball sandwich9
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Rick R.
Review date: 03/19/2025
9
Amazing Pizza, Worth the Splurge
My experience at this restaurant was straight fire! I had one of the best pizzas I've had in a while. The sauce was so flavorful, the bread perfectly crunchy and soft, and the cheese was delicious. While the ranch was a little too expensive, it was really good too. The food and atmosphere were rated a 5, and the service was also a 5. I enjoyed it for dinner and the price per person was $10–20.
  • pizza10
  • sauce9
  • bread10
  • ranch price4

Top Restaurants in

Lou's
9.6
out of 10

12

100%

Supra Dinner Society
9.6
out of 10

150

100%

1904 Street Dogs
9.6
out of 10

73

100%

Taste of India
9.4
out of 10

307

100%