Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
oChef » Mike’s Giant New York Pizza – San Diego
Mike's Giant New York Pizza - San Diego
Photo from Mike’s Giant New York Pizza
Mike's Giant New York Pizza at a glance
San Diego Paradise Hills
- 🍕 Pizzeria
$$
Price per Person $11–$20
mentioned by 28 of the guests
#291 out of 755 places to eat in San Diego
#22 Pizzeria out of 68 in San Diego
Good
7.7 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
315
Reviews
79.4%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Delicious pizza
- Great service
Frequently criticized
- Rude staff
- Dated interior
The restaurant Mike’s Giant New York Pizza is a welcoming pizzeria located in the vibrant Paradise Hills neighborhood of San Diego. You’ll find a cozy and casual atmosphere perfect for enjoying a delicious meal.
Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a full dinner, this spot offers a relaxed setting where you can unwind and savor authentic flavors. It’s a great choice for both lunch and dinner.
Overview: Introducting Mike's Giant New York Pizza
Mike’s Giant New York Pizza generally delivers on its promise of satisfying meals, with many patrons consistently praising the quality of their offerings. You’ll often find comments highlighting the worth the price aspect of their pizza and the consistently great service provided by the team.
However, some experiences suggest a mixed bag regarding the overall atmosphere and certain interactions. While the food often shines, a few customers have noted instances of rude behavior and a need for remodeling in the dining area, which might temper expectations for a perfect visit.
Good
7.7
out of 10
315
Reviews
79.4%
Satisfaction
58
negative
7
neutral
250
positive
Mike’s Giant New York Pizza holds a respectable overall score of 7.7, indicating a good dining experience, complemented by a strong customer satisfaction rate of 79.4%. This suggests that most visitors leave content, a sentiment echoed across 315 customer observations, with 250 positive remarks outweighing 58 negative ones.
The food is clearly a standout, earning an impressive Food score of (8.5), making it the highest-rated aspect. Both Service (6.9) and Ambience (6.9) are rated as average, suggesting they meet expectations without necessarily exceeding them.
The Value (5.8) score, however, indicates some customers find pricing a bit steep, despite others appreciating the deals.
What people like
- Delicious, tasty pizza
- Outstanding customer service
- Good deals available
What people don't like
- Rude owner/staff
- Dated interior needs remodeling
- Some items overpriced
With a solid recommendation score of 8, Mike’s Giant New York Pizza is certainly worth considering, especially if your priority is a satisfying meal. The consistent quality of their pizza and other dishes, coupled with generally attentive service, makes it a reliable choice for a casual meal.
However, if a polished dining environment or strict budget is a primary concern, you might find some aspects less appealing. It’s a place that excels where it counts most—the food—but has areas for improvement that could enhance the overall customer experience.
Similar Restaurants in San Diego
- Pizzeria
9.1
out of 10
out of 10
423
93.6%
- $$
- Otay Mesa West
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.9
out of 10
out of 10
561
93.2%
- $$
- Normal Heights
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.9
out of 10
out of 10
464
92%
- $$
- Tierrasanta
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.8
out of 10
out of 10
454
94.9%
- $$
- Kearny Mesa
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.8
out of 10
out of 10
525
93.3%
- $$
- Kearny Mesa
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.5
out of 10
out of 10
252
88.5%
- $$
- Mira Mesa
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Mike's Giant New York Pizza
Food (8.5 out of 10)
mentioned by 94% of the guests
The food here truly shines, earning a good score of 8.5 and a good customer satisfaction of 89.4%. With 161 positive remarks out of 180 total comments, guests consistently rave about the stellar pizza, delicious crust, quality ingredients, and impressive giant pies. Its clear the culinary experience is a major hit!
However, a few of the 15 critical observations mention meh wings and burnt fries, with some even calling it the worst place' for pizza. While these are isolated incidents, they suggest some inconsistencies in certain menu items, so keep that in mind.
Food
180
Reviews
89%
Satisfaction
15
negative
4
neutral
161
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Stellar pizza
- Quality ingredients
- Giant portions
What people don't like
- Bad wings
- Burnt fries
Often praised
- pizzaThis is a review for a pizza place located on Reo Drive in Paradise Hills. The reviewer mentions a "biggest mother pizza with your topping put in. " The reviewer recounts a past experience where they couldn't visit the restaurant with their girlfriend, Lyn, and son due to a doctor's appointment for the son.
- foodMy family and I have been in love with the food for over 20 years. The food is one of the best in San Diego. If you have not tried it, you are missing out.
- giant pizzatried their giant pizza, and it was truly a delight
- saucesauce that has that tang and just enough saltiness
- Greek saladthe pizza, greek sald and the philly Steak combo are delicious
- crustAbsolutely the best crust in the area
- cheesethe cheese was gooey, it wasn’t greasy or soggy
- doughMy experience at Mike's has been consistently positive. They always perform the requests I want with my order, such as a large pepperoni and cheese pizza with not too thick of dough. They truly come through with delicious and tasty pizza that is worth the price.
- friesThe fries were really good. Salted just right.
- wingsMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic! They always listen when I ask them to make the wings crispy, and the pizza is outstanding. I truly love these guys.
Frequently criticized
- pizzaVisiting from out of town, I called for delivery and was told they were trying to clean and get out. I would never buy pizza from a place not serving pies, no matter the time, just to close down quickly. This experience was disappointing.
- friesI can count the amount of fries in this container.
- wingswings were all choppy. Smell and taste like throwup.
- 28" pizzaDon't get the 28" unless you have a bunch of people!! It is so much larger than you think!
- HamburgerHamburger, fries, and a salad.
- beerThe beer is too cold
- cheese and peppershad to ask for cheese and peppers my self
- hamburger comboI had ordered the hamburger combo which I told the guy that answered that I was allergic to yellow cheese
- meatballsMeatballs could use a little work
- pizza placeWorst pizza place in the area!
If you're craving fantastic pizza with quality ingredients and generous portions, this spot is definitely worth a visit. Just be mindful that some side items like wings or fries might be a bit hit-or-miss, but the main event is a winner.
Service (6.9 out of 10)
mentioned by 65% of the guests
Many customers have found the service here to be quite pleasant, with 58 positive remarks out of 83 total. People frequently commend the friendly place and welcoming staff, highlighting excellent customer service and personal service from the owners like Mike and Louie. It seems many leave feeling well-cared for, especially with speedy pick-up and accommodating requests.
However, the service isnt without its bumps, reflected in a score of 6.9 and a customer satisfaction of 69.9%, placing it in the average to mixed range. With 25 negative comments, some customers reported the owner was rude, feeling ignored, or experiencing worst customer service and bad manners, including instances where staff hung up on me. ' This suggests a noticeable inconsistency in service quality.
Service
83
Reviews
69%
Satisfaction
25
negative
0
neutral
58
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly, welcoming staff
- Outstanding customer service
- Speedy, accommodating service
What people don't like
- Rude owner/staff
- Poor communication
- Customers felt ignored
Often praised
- serviceGreat service. Awesome every time.
- customer serviceMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic! We always receive amazing customer service. The pizza is hands down the best in SD.
- staffthe staff always want to give me smiles and jokes
- ownerthe owner is a very nice man who goes out of his way to please
- guysThe guys are great.
- take outgreat place for take out
- FriendlyFriendly, good prices
- Louimake sure to ask for Loui
- MikeMike really goes out of his way for his customers
- Mike, Louie, & LuigiMike, Louie, & Luigi are the best
Frequently criticized
- serviceRude! Rude! Rude! Disrespectful customer service
- ownerHowever, the service totally sucked. As a business owner myself, I would never dream of treating my customers like the owner does. He literally hung up on me when I was asking questions because he was in a hurry to close in 20 minutes.
- customer serviceThe crust was nice and crispy and it had a good flavor. Prices are a little steep for me though and customer service is serious and to the point. I feel if you don't care about your customers you don't deserve their business, shame.
- acknowledgmentnever aknowledge me after he hanged up
- businessnot really interested in business
- deliveryCalled for delivery and said they were trying to clean and get out
- greetingNo greeting when we walked up
- hung up on meAs a business owner myself, I would never dream of treating my customers like the owner does. He literally hung up on me when I was asking questions because he was in a hurry to close in 20 minutes. When I called back and asked why he hung up, he confirmed that was the reason.
- ignored usThere was no greeting when we walked up to the counter. They pretty much ignored us and stared until we said we were picking up. It's definitely not worth going back to if the owner/employees are going to treat customers like that.
- mannersBad Manners
If youre looking for a place with potentially warm and personal interactions, you might be pleasantly surprised. However, be aware that service can be inconsistent, with some customers encountering rudeness or poor communication. Its a bit of a gamble, but many find the positive experiences outweigh the occasional negative ones.
Ambience (6.9 out of 10)
mentioned by 21% of the guests
When it comes to the vibe, this spot generally hits the mark, scoring a 6.9 which is pretty good! Many of the 26 customer remarks highlight a friendly environment and a great local place with a rich tradition and a side serving of nostalgia. Customers appreciate the old pizza house feel and the convenience of parking, making it a pleasant dine-in experience.
However, the customer satisfaction is a bit more mixed at 65.4%, suggesting there's room for improvement. Some of the 7 negative comments point to an unpleasant atmosphere and a need for remodeling, specifically mentioning the interior and booths covered with duct tape. This indicates that while many enjoy the traditional feel, others find the current state a bit dated.
Ambience
26
Reviews
65%
Satisfaction
7
negative
2
neutral
17
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly local atmosphere
- Rich tradition, nostalgia
- Ample parking available
What people don't like
- Dated interior
- Worn booths
Often praised
- atmosphereGreat atmosphere mixed with a big dose of rich tradition
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- ParkingParking available.
- community goodnessNice, wholesome community goodness!
- dine-inGreat place for dine-in
- dining areaClean dining area
- experiencecare about the experience here
- friendly environmentfriendly environment
- local placeGreat local place
- nostalgiaside serving of nostalgia
Frequently criticized
- atmospherethe atmosphere was equally unpleasant
- boothsThe only aspect that detracted from my experience was the interior of this place, which definitely needs some new remodeling. Some booths are covered with duct tape.
- experienceHorrible, embarrassing experience
- hand washingnever seen him wash his hands
- interiorThe only thing I didn't like was the interior of this place
- mom and pops businessas a mom and pops business he treats people this way
- remodelingit definitely needs some new remodeling.
If youre looking for a casual spot with a nostalgic, traditional pizza house vibe and dont mind a slightly dated interior, this place could be a good fit. It offers a friendly, local atmosphere, but those seeking a modern or pristine dining area might be a bit disappointed.
Value (5.8 out of 10)
mentioned by 26% of the guests
When it comes to value, many customers find this spot offers some solid perks, with 14 positive remarks highlighting great deals and getting a bang for your buck. Folks often feel the food is worth it and at a reasonable price, contributing to a generally fair experience. The score for value sits at an average 5.8, suggesting its seen as decent.
However, not everyone is thrilled, with 11 negative comments pointing to concerns like inflation and feeling overcharged, especially regarding delivery charges. Some even felt it was a waste of money. This mixed sentiment is reflected in the customer satisfaction of 53.8%, indicating theres room for improvement in consistency.
Value
26
Reviews
53%
Satisfaction
11
negative
1
neutral
14
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Great deals offered
- Good value for money
- Reasonable prices found
What people don't like
- Delivery charges high
- Items feel overpriced
- Customers feel overcharged
Often praised
- priceThey always perform the requests I want with my order, such as a large pepperoni and cheese pizza with not too thick of dough. They truly come through with delicious and tasty pizza that is worth the price. I love Mike's.
- dealsBest pizza and deals!
- $5 bucksFor $5 bucks this pizza slice was worth the wait
- bang for your buckget your "bang for your buck"
- good pricesgood prices, and superior pizza
- great dealsGreat deals going on all the time
- local pricesCan't beat local prices
- pricesReasonable prices.
- pricingtotally fair pricing on what they produce
- reasonable priceat a reasonable price
Frequently criticized
- InflationInflation you can notice that it's hitting every business
- PricesThe crust was nice and crispy and it had a good flavor. Prices are a little steep for me though and customer service is serious and to the point. I feel if you don't care about your customers you don't deserve their business, shame.
- delivery chargeman said no charge. Gave me a total of $35 even... Then delivery man gets here and wants to charge me $43!!!
- delivery pricingdelivery pricing felt like a scam
- drink pricesno drinks prices
- itemsItems are a little over priced
- overcharged99. So we definitely got overcharged. There was no greeting when we walked up to the counter.
- pricesprices are a joke!
- ranch priceRanch is a little too expensive
- time and moneyWaste of time and money.
This place offers a mixed bag on value. While you might snag some great deals and feel its worth the price, be wary of potential extra costs like delivery or certain items. Its worth a try if you're looking for bargains, but keep an eye on the final bill.
How are the prices at Mike's Giant New York Pizza?
You’re looking at roughly 20 per person – reported by 28 diners. That puts it in the $11–$20 category. For a Pizzeria, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
Looking at what people spend, most guests are happily paying in this $11–$20 sweet spot, though there are a few who opt for slightly cheaper or more premium options.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 28 reviews.
How this Pizzeria’s value stacks up against similar spots in San Diego.
Overall, we think the pricing feels pretty fair for a Pizzeria, especially considering the variety in what people choose to spend. It hits a good balance for most.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Mike's Giant New York Pizza
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Family Dinner
Group Type
- Family
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Amazing Pizza, Friendly Staff!
My family and I absolutely love this place! When family visits from out of town, they specifically ask to come here. The crust is AH-mazing, and they are generous with the real cheese and plentiful toppings.
Mike and the staff truly care about the quality and the overall experience. It's a place with friendly service, good prices, and superior pizza.
- crust10
- real cheese9
- toppings9
Price per Person
- $31–$40
Visit Type
- Casual Outing
Group Type
- Family
Group Size
- Large Group
Service Type
- Takeout
Meal Type
- Dinner
Wait Time
- Moderate (16–30 min.)
Noise Level
- Quiet
9
Delicious Pizza and Great Greek Salad!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic, especially with their Greek salad and, of course, their pizza. While I haven't tried anything else, their pizza is significantly better than what you'd find at Little Caesars or Pizza Hut. The giant pizza was perfect for a get-together with kids.
The staff was friendly, and even though we usually call for pickup, it never takes longer than 20 minutes. There's plenty of parking available, and the atmosphere was very quiet.
- Greek salad9
- pizza10
- giant pizza9
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
2
Unpleasant Service, Good Food
My first time here, I noticed all the food options but no drink prices. I paid with card and cash for the pizza. Afterward, I got a drink because I didn't want to go elsewhere.
The staff member then became upset because I didn't have cash for the soda and only told me the price when my food was ready, refusing to talk to me otherwise. I felt he was being racist because when a white woman's pizza was ready, he said, "Ma'am, your pizza is ready, do you need cheese and peppers? " When he called me, he just said, "Ready, " and I had to ask for cheese and peppers myself; he didn't even offer.
There was no one else there, and he wasn't busy. He was eating while making my food and I never saw him wash his hands after putting food in his mouth.
- food options8
- drink prices2
- staff member1
- staff communication1
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Live Mikes Pizza: Outstanding Food and Service!
My experience at Live Mikes Pizza was absolutely outstanding! I had their pizza, which is hands down the best around. I also tried their manicotti, and it was incredible.
The guys working there are great and incredibly welcoming.
- pizza10
- manicotti10
- guys10
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Lunch
Noise Level
- Moderate
1
Disappointing Experience, Avoid This Place
My experience at this restaurant was extremely negative. I was shocked by the poor treatment and would advise others to be wary. The service was terrible, and the atmosphere was equally unpleasant.
I cannot recommend this establishment.
- service1
- atmosphere1
What Mike's Giant New York Pizza offers
Crowd
- Tourists
- Groups
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Small plates
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Dessert
Service Options
- Dine-in
- Takeout
- Delivery
Parking
- Free street parking
- Free parking lot
- Usually plenty of parking
Atmosphere
- Cozy
- Casual
FAQs
What parking options are available when you visit Mike's Giant New York Pizza?
When you plan your visit to Mike’s Giant New York Pizza, you’ll be pleased to know that parking is convenient. You can find free street parking as well as a free parking lot. Usually, there’s plenty of parking available, making your arrival hassle-free.
Is Mike's Giant New York Pizza accessible and suitable for families?
Yes, Mike’s Giant New York Pizza is designed to be accessible for everyone, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, and seating. It’s also considered good for kids, making it an ideal spot for family lunches or dinners where everyone can feel comfortable.
What is the overall customer sentiment for Mike's Giant New York Pizza?
Mike’s Giant New York Pizza has a good overall Restaurant Score of 7.7 and a Customer Satisfaction rate of 79.4%. The Food (8.5) is highly praised, while Service (6.9) and Ambience (6.9) are average, and Value (5.8) is considered average.
What do customers like most about the food at Mike's Giant New York Pizza?
Customers frequently praise the delicious and tasty pizza, noting the quality of the crust, cheese, and sauce. Other popular items include the Greek salad, Philly steak combo, and crispy wings.
How is the customer service at Mike's Giant New York Pizza?
Many customers report outstanding and friendly service, with staff often going out of their way to please. However, some experiences mention rude interactions, particularly concerning the owner and occasional lack of acknowledgment.