I LOVE NY PIZZA - Reviews

I must say this spot definitely gives you that New York vibes. The food was great, especially the pizza 🍕 and the salads. The service was excellent, and the atmosphere was also top-notch.

My experience with this restaurant's delivery service was extremely negative. The driver claimed the order wasn't fully packed, but the manager insisted it was. This led to a situation where no one was accountable, and I was charged for food I didn't receive. To make matters worse, the manager was rude. I would not recommend ordering for delivery from here.

I drove 40 minutes with my family to be here, and then they said it’s closed. Please change the hourly hours; this place is closed at 8: 30.

The place is cute, and the booths reminded me of certain NY pizza spots. The slices were decent in size, and I appreciated being able to order them by the slice. My wife and I enjoyed the pizzas. I also ordered a regular spaghetti with marinara, which came with 2 garlic knots. Based on other reviews, I asked for extra sauce, but personally, I still felt it needed more; that’s just me 🤷‍♀️. The sauce lacked flavor and tasted generic. The garlic knots looked different from what we're used to, and I wished they had more garlic taste. Overall, it wasn't bad, but it's not NYC. I recommend taking your receipt to double-check; we trusted that our full order was heard, but a slice was missed 🙄.

YES AND YES AND YES! I love NY Pizza has nailed it! They serve the BEST NY pizza around in the Entire state! They even have a fantastic deal: two slices and a drink for $8. 99! It was a slam dunk, home run all the way!

I’ve tried all the pizza spots in the area, and this one by far is the best! My experience was excellent across the board, with top-notch food, outstanding service, and a great atmosphere.

My experience was incredibly disappointing. I ordered pizza, and as someone from NYC, I can confidently say this was the freaking worst pizza I've ever had. The cheese didn't even stick to the dough; it slid right off. I ended up throwing the whole pie in the garbage.

My favorite pizza place in Florida, hands down. The people are nice and the service is fast. As someone from NYC, I know pizza 🍕. My only negative is that the AC could be more comfortable for guests. Other than that, it's a nice place to eat, especially for takeout!

I have to say I’m highly disappointed with the owner and quite surprised as he is usually what seems to be a stand-up guy. My wife found a hair in the pizza. When bringing it to attention, he asked if I wanted another one made. After declining, he condescendingly asked me, “Well, what do you want me to do? ” I said, “Well, a partial refund since I paid for two lunch specials. ” He sarcastically said, “Just give him his $4 back, ” and the girl in the front handed the $4 all spread out with an attitude as if this is petty. While walking out, the owner cracks a joke and says, “Well, you know the hair didn’t come from me because I have no hair, hahaha. ” Are you kidding me? Excuse me, last I checked, customers are the reason why you even have a business and your lifestyle going. I highly suggest this man and employee at the front humble themselves. If not, Almighty God will do it for you. Pride brings destruction, and they seriously need Jesus Christ. You just lost a customer. There’s nothing funny, and I doubt he nor his daughter would eat food with someone’s hair in it. Certainly nothing to crack jokes about. Life will work you out though. You can lose it all in an instant with that attitude. Highly disappointed.

As an electrician who travels extensively throughout Central Florida, I've made it a point to try pizza from various shops. Inspired by Dave Portnoy's reviews, I started exploring Orlando's pizza scene during my work lunch breaks. This place, hands down, blew everyone else away! I tried the cheese Sicilian and the Lasagna slice, and they were absolutely incredible. This is hands down the absolute best slice and lunch combo, all at a great price. I will definitely be stopping by here for lunch every chance I get!