Goodfellas - Reviews

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic. I had some of the best pizza I’ve ever tasted, and you could truly taste the freshness of the ingredients. The staff were so nice, and the location and vibes were top tier. It was a truly enjoyable lunch.

My experience at the restaurant was that the pizza was just OK. For the price, I was expecting better, but I guess I need to lower my expectations when I’m in California. The guy working there was pretty nice.

We were sightseeing down at Pier 39 and wanted a pizza to bring back to our hotel. We did a quick Google search and found this place. We are very happy we found it. The food was good, the owner was super friendly and the atmosphere was nice. If we were locals, we would definitely be back.

This is a simple place without high expectations. Since we had been traveling for three weeks and had an "irresistible" craving for "Italian food", we decided to test it out and were not disappointed. The service was fast and simple, and the prices were honest. Recommended!

My experience at Goodfellas Pizzeria was outstanding! I found it to be one of the best pizza spots in San Francisco. The crust was perfect, the toppings were fresh, and the flavors were spot on. The staff was super friendly, and the whole place had a welcoming vibe. I'll definitely be back for more!

My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! The pizza tasted incredible, and the service was great. Although they advertise the DON pizza as being for 5-6 people, we found that three hungry individuals could easily finish it. Despite this, it was worth the price.

Our experience at Goodfella Pizzeria was terrible from start to finish. We arrived around 9: 30 PM and were told we could dine in, but our food was served in takeout boxes. The staff, excluding the front person, were shockingly rude and made it obvious they wanted us out before 10 PM, showing unfriendly looks and zero hospitality. Despite having a crying baby and a distant car in the drizzle, they pushed us to leave. Our food arrived at 9: 52 PM, leaving little time before closing. To make matters worse, the food was not good at all; I threw the fettuccine in the garbage. Anyone arriving between 9: 00–9: 30 PM should expect to be rushed out. Their behavior also felt biased toward certain customers, making us uncomfortable. Overall, poor service, mediocre food, and an unwelcoming atmosphere. We will not be returning. I would give 0 stars if I could.

We were on holiday and so happy to find this halal, Muslim-owned restaurant! On our first visit, we tried the hotdog, burger, and pasta — all were fresh, flavourful, and generously portioned. Everything was so good that we had to come back the very next day just for the pizza, which did not disappoint! The service was friendly, the space was clean, and the food was delicious — highly recommend to anyone looking for great halal options.

My experience at the restaurant was centered around the food, which was very tasty. However, the waiting time was a bit delayed. I observed that only older individuals were working, which might explain the delay. Despite this, the food itself was good, and I would return.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I absolutely loved the pizza crust, which was perfectly crunchy and thin, but not too thin. The staff were incredibly friendly, adding to the overall positive atmosphere. I enjoyed it during lunch and found the price to be reasonable at $10–20 per person. The atmosphere was also a highlight, rated at 5 out of 5. The food, in general, was great, receiving a score of 4 out of 5.