Planning
- Accepts reservations
oChef » COI – San Francisco
COI - San Francisco
373 Broadway, 94133 San Francisco
7.5
von 10
von 10
Photo from COI
COI at a glance
San Francisco Telegraph Hill
- 🥂 Fine Dining Restaurant
€€€€€
Price per Person 101 € –
mentioned by 6 of the guests
#260 von 500 Lokalen in San Francisco
#3 Fine Dining Restaurant von 5 in San Francisco
Good
7.5 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
360
Reviews
71.9%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Inventive cuisine
- Wine pairings
- Attentive staff
Frequently criticized
- Expensive
- Sweet desserts
- Reservation rules
The restaurant COI, a fine dining establishment in San Francisco’s Telegraph Hill neighborhood, invites you to an exceptional culinary journey. Here, you discover a sophisticated atmosphere perfect for an unforgettable dinner.
You can enjoy a range of offerings, from exquisite wines and craft beers to carefully prepared vegetarian options, ensuring a delightful experience for every palate.
Overview: Introducting COI
COI presents a refined dining experience, often lauded for its exquisite food and thoughtfully curated wine pairings that elevate each dish. Guests frequently commend the elegant presentation and innovative approach to the tasting menu, making for a memorable culinary journey.
However, some diners have raised concerns regarding the overall value, finding the experience to be on the pricier side. While the atmosphere is generally described as intimate and chic, contributing to a comfortable evening, the cost can be a significant consideration for potential visitors.
Good
7.5 von 10
360
Reviews
71.9%
Satisfaction
74
negative
27
neutral
259
positive
The restaurant achieves a solid overall score of 7.5, reflecting a generally positive reception from its patrons. This aligns well with a good 71.9% customer satisfaction rate, indicating that most diners leave feeling content with their experience.
With 360 total opinions, including 259 positive and 74 negative remarks, the feedback leans favorably. Delving into specifics, the Food (7.9) stands out as a strong point, frequently described as inventive and beautifully presented.
The Ambience (7.8) also garners high praise for its chic and intimate setting, while Service (7.6) is often noted for its knowledgeable and efficient staff, though some experiences suggest occasional inconsistencies. The Value (3.7), however, is a clear area of concern.
What people like
- Exquisite, inventive food
- Thoughtful wine pairings
- Knowledgeable service
What people don't like
- High price point
- Desserts too sweet
- Strict reservation policy
COI offers a sophisticated dining experience, particularly for those seeking innovative cuisine and attentive service. While the Recommendation Score of 7.6 suggests a generally positive reception, be prepared for a significant investment.
It’s a strong contender for a special occasion, but guests should be aware of the premium pricing and strict reservation terms. If you prioritize culinary artistry and a refined atmosphere, COI could be a memorable choice.
Ähnliche Restaurants in San Francisco
- Fine Dining Restaurant
8.9
von 10
von 10
643
90.8%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Fine Dining Restaurant
7.7
von 10
von 10
150
76%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Fine Dining Restaurant
7
von 10
von 10
1029
65.3%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Fine Dining Restaurant
6.9
von 10
von 10
703
63.2%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on COI
Food (7.9 von 10)
mentioned by 90% of the guests
Alright, lets talk about the food! With a solid score of 7.9 and customer satisfaction sitting pretty at 77.6%, its clear that many diners are having a good time. Out of 223 total comments, a whopping 173 rave about the inventive cuisine, artful presentation, and the use of seasonal ingredients, often perfectly complemented by thoughtful wine pairings.
It sounds like a culinary adventure! However, not everyone is completely wowed. About 32 comments point to some areas for improvement, mentioning concerns like small portions, an occasional lack of flavor, dishes being over-salted, or some wine pairings feeling a bit off.
While generally positive, it seems there can be a few bumps in the road for some palates.
Food
223
Reviews
77%
Satisfcation
32
negative
18
neutral
173
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Inventive cuisine
- Artful presentation
- Seasonal ingredients
What people don't like
- Small portions
- Lack of flavor
- Over-salted dishes
Often praised
- foodMy experience at the restaurant was marked by exquisite and innovative food. The wine pairing was also interesting.
- wine pairingThe ambiance was intimate, making it an ideal spot for a date night with my fiancee. The 9-course tasting menu with wine pairing was exquisite. Coi truly deserves its 2 Michelin Stars.
- presentationpresentation on each dish were clean and elegant
- tasting menuexquisite. A refined tasting menu focussed on lightness and contrasts.
- wine pairingsWine pairings are thought provoking, with some real bright spots
- food presentationThe food was beautifully presented. Each dish was a work of art.
- mealMy experience at the restaurant was mostly positive, with an otherwise wonderful meal. However, the desserts were way too sweet, which was not a great way to end the meal.
- dishesThe dishes shine from sheer execution
- 11 courses11 courses, elegantly and exquistely prepared
- flavorsCame here for my birthday. This place was very professional and they knew their flavors. Pairing the food with wines were excellent.
Frequently criticized
- foodIt was not worth the price, and I believe there are many better Michelin stars in town. The food was not original, with the exception of the desserts.
- artfavoring art over function
- bassbass had little flavor to the dish other than parsley and celery
- chefthe chef is obsessed with the lemon/vinegar/anything sour.
- depthuppity with no real depth
- dessertsdesserts were way too sweet
- dishonly one dish stood out and everything else was very bland
- dishesevery dish was over salted
- drinksthe drinks did not arrive before the food
- duckIt was medium rare. That was fine but it was so hard!
If you're looking for an inventive and beautifully presented meal, especially with a good wine pairing, this place is definitely worth a try. Just be prepared for potentially smaller portions and a slight chance of an inconsistent flavor profile on some dishes.
Service (7.6 von 10)
mentioned by 62% of the guests
When it comes to service, this spot generally hits the mark! With a good score of 7.6 and a good customer satisfaction rating of 73.9%, many guests rave about the friendly and professional service. Out of 69 remarks, 51 were positive, often highlighting the impeccable team, welcoming staff, and the overall pursuit of perfection for a unique experience.
The sommelier and front-of-house service also received high praise. However, not every interaction was flawless. The 14 negative comments point to some inconsistencies, with concerns about excessively long breaks between courses and occasional lack of staff attention.
Some found the service staff not always professional or friendly, and a few even described the reservation policy as rude, leading to a less than ideal experience for some diners.
Service
69
Reviews
73%
Satisfcation
14
negative
4
neutral
51
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly, professional service
- Impeccable, knowledgeable staff
- Achieves guest perfection
What people don't like
- Long breaks between courses
- Inconsistent staff attention
- Rude reservation policy
Often praised
- serviceThe food was simply fabulous: extremely high quality, inventive, surprising, and delighting at every step. Unlike some restaurants of this caliber, Coi genuinely offers the real deal, not just white tablecloths and obsequious service. Whether you're celebrating something special or seeking a foodie treat, I cannot recommend this place highly enough; it is high art.
- staffthe entire staff to be friendly, knowledgeable and efficient
- experienceIt's getting better from one dose to onther
- sommeliernod to the sommelier
- teameach member of the team...took time to table-touch, educate us, and amaze us
- Back Waiter AlexBack Waiter, Alex...do a magnificent job
- Chef PattersonThe opening beet plate was to die for, and the subsequent dishes were all unique, flavorful, and nicely paired with amazing wines. Chef Patterson himself even came out and presented us with an extra dish to try after already 11 dishes! Overall, it was simply gorgeous.
- Executive Chef Erik AndersonExecutive Chef, Erik Anderson...do a magnificent job
- Front Waiter LiaFront Waiter, Lia...do a magnificent job
- General Manager DanielleGeneral Manager, Danielle...do a magnificent job
Frequently criticized
- staffthe staff is not as attentative as other places in the same category.
- anniversary acknowledgementthe restaurant not only didn't make a big deal, they didn't mention it.
- breaks between coursesexcessively long breaks between the courses
- dinner timemy dinner time total is 3 hr
- experiencevery underwhelming and disappointing
- food serversthe food servers too slow
- reservationWe had a reservation for 8: 30 PM the day before Valentine's Day. Upon arrival, about five minutes early, the staff seemed confused by our reservation, and we had to actively seek someone's attention to let them know we were present. The dining room was sparsely populated, with only two other couples and three open tables.
- reservation policyEverybody BE CAREFUL when you make your reservations! If one person doesn't show up, they still charge you for the number of people you listed on your reservation! HOW RUDE!
- rudeHOW RUDE!!!
- serviceservice at Coi, while attentive, is inconsistent and almost impersonal
The service here generally shines, with many guests praising the friendly and professional staff. While occasional inconsistencies like long waits or less attentive moments occur, the overall sentiment is very positive. It's worth trying if you prioritize excellent service, but be prepared for minor variations.
Ambience (7.8 von 10)
mentioned by 38% of the guests
When it comes to the vibe, this spot generally hits the mark! With a solid score of 7.8 and customer satisfaction at a strong 81.6%, the ambience here is definitely considered good. Out of 38 total remarks, a whopping 31 were positive, often praising the overall ambiance, decor, space, and the dining experience as an oasis of calm thats "beautiful and serene, " and "intimate" without being stuffy.
However, its not without a few minor hiccups, as 4 negative comments pointed out concerns with the ambience, dining space, and even the music choice. Some found it noisy, distracting or felt the long and narrow dining space wasn't ideal, with one even suggesting the music was in poor taste.
Ambience
38
Reviews
81%
Satisfcation
4
negative
3
neutral
31
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Calm atmosphere
- Intimate setting
- Elegant decor
What people don't like
- Noisy environment
- Narrow dining space
- Poor music choice
Often praised
- spaceThe space is very chic - it almost feels sci-fi
- ambiancethe ambiance is not stuffy
- decorDecor is minimal, but it is an oasis of calm
- dining experienceMy experience at the restaurant was a great, intimate dining experience. There were a couple of absolute standout dishes.
- atmospherecomfortable atmosphere
- Table #6Request Table #6 (cute L-shaped corner booth which allows you to sit next to, as opposed to across, from each other)
- Table #7Request Table #7 (We sat here & had an amazing time!)
- aestheticintriguing and intimate dark, moody aesthetic
- ambiencethe place is just quiet and cozy
- atmosphere and decorAtmosphere and decor made this place memorable
Frequently criticized
- ambienceit was noisy, distracting and even stressful
- dining experienceexperience felt really uninspired
- dining spacelong and narrow dining space
- music choiceI think the music choice was in poor taste.
If youre looking for a restaurant with a generally calm, intimate, and elegant atmosphere, this place is a strong contender. Just be aware that a few guests found it a bit noisy or narrow, and the music might not be to everyones taste. Overall, it's worth trying for a pleasant dining experience.
Value (3.7 von 10)
mentioned by 31% of the guests
Despite a generally poor perception of value, a few guests did find the price to be worth every penny for a special occasion meal, describing it as a 3 Star experience that was well worth it. These 4 positive remarks, though limited, highlight that for some, the unique experience justified the cost. However, the overall sentiment leans heavily negative, with a score of 3.7 and customer satisfaction at a poor 13.3%.
Many of the 24 negative comments focused on prices being outrageously expensive, with the price tag and bill frequently mentioned as not offering value for money.
Value
30
Reviews
13%
Satisfcation
24
negative
2
neutral
4
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Worth every penny
- Worth the experience
What people don't like
- Outrageously expensive
- Not worth price
- Sticker shock bill
Often praised
- priceThe price was a little bit higher but it was all worth it
- experienceDefinatly a 3 Star experience. Well worth it.
- special occasion mealits a great special occasion meal.
Frequently criticized
- price" The service was "impeccable, " and the "minimal" space provided an "oasis of calm. " While it is "outrageously expensive, " many recommend it for a "special occasion" or to "have your food mind blown. " Reservations are only available through a prepaid online ticketing system.
- billIt wasn't disappointing, but the expectation was for more. A key takeaway was articulated to a chef friend: "Daniel is epic, and art is fun, but when the form goes so far over function, that the beauty on the front end is tempered by the fact you are just eating fancy veggies, the bill gives you a sticker shock that makes you forget about the plating. " For multi-coursed meals, the reviewer might prefer something more traditional or artistic food that matches its exterior.
- price tagespecially with the price tag
- Michelin Star ratingOr was the Michelin Star rating system a sham?
- beveragesMy experience at this restaurant was marked by a very slow service, which significantly extended my dinner time to a total of 3 hours. The cost was $250 per person, and this did not include any beverages. Additionally, a 20% service charge was added to the bill.
- charging for no-showsHOW RUDE! My husband even called to ask if it would be okay to come if we were one person short, they said yes and still charged us! HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!
- dinner for twoWhile the food remains creative, it's no longer as tasty as it used to be. Additionally, the prices have doubled, so be prepared to spend $750+ for a dinner for two. I believe there are better ways to spend that money.
- mealDon't expect to pay under $200 for your meal
- moneyfor this much money, go somewhere else
- outrageously expensiveIt is outrageously expensive
If youre seeking an experience where cost is no object for a truly unique "special occasion meal, " you might find some justification. However, for most, the "outrageously expensive" "prices" mean its likely not worth the price, and you might find better value for money elsewhere.
Wie sind die Preise pro Gast bei COI?
On average, you’ll spend around 597 per person – from 6 guests. That puts the restaurant in the 101 € – category. For a Fine Dining Restaurant, that’s mid-range, maybe slightly above.
Looking at the price distribution, all 6 reported prices cluster in this higher bracket, indicating a consistent premium experience rather than a wide spread. With only 6 reviews, the data is limited, but it gives a good indication of what to expect.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 6 reviews. While the data is limited, it gives a good indication of spending patterns.
A comparison of this restaurant’s value for money against similar spots in San Francisco.
For a Fine Dining Restaurant in San Francisco, we think the pricing feels quite fair. It suggests a consistent, high-end experience, which is what youd expect at this price point. We recommend it if youre looking for a premium meal.
Customer Reviews: what people think about COI
Service Intent
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
9
Fond Memories of Fine Dining
I have such fond memories of this restaurant. It's sad to hear they closed. Back in 2016, COI was under different management, leading to a different experience compared to those who visited closer to its closure. This was actually my first “fine dining” experience, and it might still be one of the most artful presentation of courses I’ve ever seen.
- artful presentation of courses10
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
An Orchestrated Culinary Perfection
My experience at this restaurant was akin to witnessing an orchestra in perfect harmony. The team's seamless coordination created a legendary restaurant experience, ensuring perfection for each guest's unique dining journey.
- team10
- perfection10
- unique experience10
Price per Person
- 101 € -
Service Intent
- Food Exploration
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
2
Disappointing Experience at Coi
I am writing this review with significant disappointment, as I had been looking forward to visiting Coi for quite some time. My experience was particularly disheartening, and I wish I had visited under the previous executive chef. We had a reservation for 8: 30 PM the day before Valentine's Day. Upon arrival, about five minutes early, the staff seemed confused by our reservation, and we had to actively seek someone's attention to let them know we were present. The dining room was sparsely populated, with only two other couples and three open tables. Unfortunately, only one dish truly stood out; the rest were very bland. Despite Coi's history as a three-star restaurant, now demoted to two, I still held high expectations, even considering negative comments. The food presented was vastly different from what is showcased on their website and Instagram – it was very simple and basic, lacking any element that would suggest a Michelin star. We opted for the wine pairing, which was generous enough for two people to share one pairing if that were an option. We observed that tables around us received a thank-you gift of beet gummy bears and toffee, which we did not receive, adding to our disappointment. By the end of the night, our tasting menu totaled $1, 300. For the overall experience, it was definitively not worth the cost, and I would have preferred to spend that money at a different, better restaurant. Coi has been on my top list for a long time, but currently, it's not worth visiting until changes are made.
- wine pairing6
- reservation2
- staff attention2
- dish3
Service Intent
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Amazing Food and Exceptional Service
My experience at the restaurant was fantastic. I absolutely loved the food. The chef was incredibly amazing and quite humble. I had some dietary restrictions, and the chef changed a complete dish just for me, which I thought was a lovely touch. The staff were friendly and knowledgeable. Thanks for the lovely experience.
- food10
- chef10
- dietary restrictions9
Service Intent
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
2
Disappointing Experience, Not Worth the Price
My experience at this restaurant was very disappointing. It was not worth the price, and I believe there are many better Michelin stars in town. The food was not original, with the exception of the desserts.
- desserts7
- price2
- food3
Das erwartet dich bei COI
Loading map…
Payments
- Credit cards
Amenities
- Gender-neutral restroom
Offerings
- Wine
- Coffee
- Beer
- Vegetarian options
- Alcohol
Dining options
- Dinner
- Table service
- Dessert
FAQs
What dining options are available at COI?
At COI, you can enjoy a full dinner service with table service, perfect for a complete evening out. Dessert options are also available to conclude your meal.
Does COI accommodate specific dietary needs or offer amenities?
Yes, COI provides vegetarian options to cater to diverse preferences. Additionally, for your comfort, the restaurant features a gender-neutral restroom.
What is the overall verdict on COI?
COI holds an overall score of 7.5, with Food (7.9), Ambience (7.8), and Service (7.6) receiving good marks. However, Value (3.7) is a notable concern for many diners.
What are the culinary strengths of COI?
Diners frequently praise COI’s exquisite and innovative food, highlighting the elegant presentation, refined tasting menu, and thoughtful wine pairings.
Are there any significant drawbacks to dining at COI?
The primary concern for many is the high price point, with some finding the desserts overly sweet and the reservation policy quite strict regarding no-shows.