Newkirk's - Reviews

I really enjoyed my experience here, especially the Hash Brown sandwich. The bread was nice. I'm looking forward to trying the BEC and cheesesteak next time. I love the green sauce flavour here.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic, particularly for breakfast. I found the best breakfast sandwiches in the city, with a special mention for those served on the poppy Kaiser roll. My personal favorite is the PEC (pastrami egg cheese). The bread was incredibly soft and fresh, the eggs were perfectly cooked, and the proteins were done well. I was also impressed that they ferment their own hot sauces. I highly recommend this place!

My experience at this restaurant was disappointing. The price was higher than advertised, as I paid $20 for a sandwich that was listed at $15. I also encountered microaggressions throughout my visit. The manager, standing behind the counter, completely ignored me and continued their conversation as if I were invisible, despite me being a paying customer. This lack of acknowledgment and the overpricing made for a very negative experience.

My experience at this kaiser roll and sandwich shop was fantastic! The rolls were perfectly baked, offering a delightful contrast of crispy exterior and a soft, airy interior. Each sandwich felt like it was handcrafted with care, using quality ingredients. The standout element was undoubtedly their fermented hot sauce, which provided a unique, tangy heat that truly elevated every bite. The depth of flavor from the fermentation was remarkable and unlike anything I've tasted before. This spot consistently delivers on flavor, freshness, and creativity, making it a great choice for lunch or any sandwich craving.

I truly hope this place survives. It's rare to find a genuine East Coast deli, and this establishment excels at everything. Keep up the fantastic work!

As someone from Long Island, I was really impressed by this place. If you're looking for something that’s close to NY breakfast sandwiches, this is it. I visited San Francisco for the week and found this gem.

My experience at this restaurant was a mixed bag. The food was excellent, earning a perfect score. However, the service was very slow, which was a significant drawback. Whether ordering online for pickup or dining in, there was a considerable wait in line. This is an area that could definitely be improved.

Newkirk's is hands down the best sandwich spot in the city. I visit here at least once a week, and it never disappoints. I proudly wear my Newkirk's shirt and recommend it to everyone. I absolutely LOVE the Hash Brown Sandwich and the Cheesesteak. I also recently tried the Chicken Schug, and it was incredible. Honestly, everything is amazing. I highly recommend trying a breakfast sandwich first. The house-made hot sauces are also awesome.

Growing up around NY and eating breakfast sandwiches, I can confidently say this place totally nails it. I find myself coming back every week because everything on the menu is amazing. The horse on the roof, pastrami egg and cheese, and hash brown egg and cheese are all phenomena. They are always flavorful and juicy. The vibe inside is great, and I highly recommend grabbing some sauces!

My experience at the restaurant was okay. The sandwich I received was just alright. I'm willing to try a different sandwich to decide if I'd return for a 3rd visit. The service and atmosphere were rated a 5, and the food also received a 5.