Tony’s Coal Fired Pizza & Slice House - Reviews

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I found the slices to be delicious and incredibly huge. The variety was also impressive, and overall, the food was on point. If you're craving a slice, you really can't go wrong here. It offers great value and quality for the buck.

My experience at this restaurant was TERRIBLE due to the service. It took them an astonishing 40 MINUTES to prepare a simple pepperoni pizza. When we inquired about the status, we were told they had to use another oven and it would take an additional 10 minutes. If the order was forgotten, it would have been better to admit the pizza was lost rather than LIE about the situation.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! It's a very small place with only four tables outside, but it has a lot of charm, especially being in the heart of the Italian Quarter. The pizza was absolutely delicious, with a super crispy crust and spectacular flavor. I also loved that they served an ice-cold Modelo beer, which is a rarity these days. The price was reasonable; two slices of pizza and a beer cost $20. If you're in the Italian Quarter and craving good pizza, I highly recommend visiting this spot – it's definitely worth it.

My experience was with the takeout pizza by the slice portion of the business. The service was very friendly, and there were tons of options available. The pizza was delicious. I highly recommend!

I ordered Tonys via Doordash, as I had never eaten there before. I was craving fettuccine Alfredo and chose this spot. I ordered the Alfredo and a Cesar salad. To be honest, it was the best meal I'd had in a long time. The Alfredo was extremely delicious, and the Cesar dressing was the best I've ever had. I will definitely order from them again. Everything I had was a 9/10.

My experience at this restaurant was disappointing. We specifically came for the vodka sauce, but when we inquired, the waiter, after checking with the chef, informed us that our marinara was actually a vodka cream sauce. Beyond this misunderstanding, the plate was pretty bland.

My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! I had the pizza, which was so good. The service was pretty quick, and we enjoyed eating at the outdoor tables. It was a great lunch experience.

Absolutely delicious! If you're dining alone, I highly recommend eating here. They serve slices, which is faster than dining in at the restaurant. Without a doubt, some of the best in San Francisco!

On our way back to Sacramento, we stopped by for a classic Chicago style sandwich. The sandwich was excellent, even when enjoyed parked on the side of the road in my car. Parking was difficult in the area, so I dropped off the wife and waited around the corner with the hazards on. The food and atmosphere were rated a 5, and the service also received a 5.

My experience at this restaurant was centered around their pizza. I particularly loved the coal fired option. It's worth noting that only whole pies are coal-fired, not the slices, though they occasionally make coal slices available. Overall, the food was rated a 4, service a 5, and atmosphere a 3.