Stevie's - Reviews

My experience at this restaurant was a mix of delicious pizza and a very frustrating ordering process. The pizza itself was very tasty! However, the ordering system needs improvement. Online orders automatically place you at the back of the queue, resulting in a one-hour wait, with no option to come in earlier. Calling in an order was also difficult, as I was on hold for an extremely long time before I decided to try another method. It seems like it might be faster to just show up and order directly. I was also disappointed that the Normie pizza is no longer available as a standard option. It was previously $35, and now the base is $33. Adding the Burrata and Hot Honey to make it a Normie costs an additional $9. 50, which feels like a significant price increase for customization.

As someone born in Chicago with a high standard for pizza, I can confidently say this place is a 10/10. The ingredients were fresh and the pizza was absolutely perfect. It had the ideal crunch without being too crunchy, and was soft without being too soft – truly PERFECT. My experience was outstanding, with top marks for food, service, and atmosphere.

My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! I ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and a veggie pizza for my wife. The pepperoni cups on the slices were perfect. While the first slice was a bit too hot, the second slice was even better as it cooled down, allowing the flavors to really open up. We also tried the Caesar salad, and it was exactly the Caesar salad you want and need. The spot has a cool rock and roll vibe, and I'm looking forward to returning to enjoy some live music while having a slice or two.

As a New Yorker, I can confidently say that the pizza here is awesome. I highly recommend trying the hot honey burrata. The food was rated a 5, and the atmosphere was also a 5. The service was excellent, contributing to a great overall experience.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I had the solid New York style slices, and they were truly exceptional. The little pepperonis transformed into lovely crispy cups, and the crust had the perfect combo of chew vs crunch. The food quality was a perfect 5/5, and the service was equally impressive at 5/5. The atmosphere was also great, rated at 4/5. I highly recommend this place, especially for vegetarians!

My experience at this restaurant was marked by rude service and a significant wait time for a to-go order. I was initially told it would be 25 minutes, but when I inquired after seeing others who ordered later receive their food, I was informed my order had "just come up" 20 minutes past the quoted time. The server was extremely rude and attempted to gaslight me, which was particularly frustrating given the use of a buzzer system. Despite living only two blocks away, I will never return. Furthermore, the pizza wasn't even that good.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I tried the Normie pizza and it was awesome. If you visit when it's busy, be prepared for a wait for your pizza, so I recommend grabbing a slice and trying something fun while you wait. The ranch dressing was also very good. I'll definitely be coming back.

My experience with the delivery service was extremely negative. The delivery service took over 2 hours and was delayed multiple times. I believe these folks shouldn't over-promise delivery times on their website if it's going to be this slow. Alternatively, they should at least warn customers about potential delays when they are checking out.

My experience at Stevie's was exceptional, particularly the pie, which was so good it felt like it should be reported to the police! The food was outstanding, and I'd also recommend calling the fire department because it was that amazing. The service and atmosphere were also top-notch, contributing to a fantastic overall dining experience.

Went here for the first time last week. I loved the style of pizza and will definitely be back!