oChef » Scuderie Italia – San Diego » Scuderie Italia – San Diego – Reviews

Scuderie Italia - Reviews

1525 Garnet Ave, 92109 San Diego
All reviews at a glance
440

Reviews

67.3%

Satisfaction

128

negative

16

neutral

296

positive

What people say about Scuderie Italia

Visit Type
  • Family Dinner
Group Type
  • Family
Group Size
  • Large Group
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Brian B.
Review date: 12/23/2025
9
Amazing Family Dinner at Scuderie Italia
My experience at Scuderie Italia was truly amazing. We had a memorable dinner with our daughter, her husband, and the grandkids. Arriving early allowed us to interact with the staff, who were all welcoming and professional. Our server, Gui, was exceptional, attending to our every need throughout the meal. The pizzas were delicious with perfectly cooked and tasty crusts. We also shared a cannoli, which was creamy perfection. It was a wonderful family evening.
  • pizzas9
  • crusts9
  • cannoli10
Price per Person
  • $101+
Visit Type
  • Delivery
Service Type
  • Delivery
Stephen W.
Review date: 12/13/2025
1
Wrong Order, Terrible Food
My experience at this restaurant was quite negative. I ordered some stuff and received the wrong items. It was a struggle to get anyone to acknowledge their mistake, as I had to argue to prove they messed up. To make matters worse, the items they sent in error were absolute trash. I give it a 0/10 and do not recommend.
  • wrong stuff1
  • argue to prove1
  • things they sent1
Price per Person
  • $21–$30
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Takeout
Caitlin B.
Review date: 12/06/2025
3
Pasta Caused Stomach Issues, But Staff Was Friendly
My experience at this restaurant was mixed. While the staff was friendly and the spot is cute, the pasta I had completely messed up my stomach, leading to a really bad reaction. I can’t remember the last time I had a reaction like that.
  • staff8
  • spot7
  • pasta1
  • stomach1
Price per Person
  • $61–$70
Visit Type
  • Family Dinner
Group Type
  • Family
Group Size
  • Large Group
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Noise Level
  • Loud
JdR
Review date: 11/22/2025
2
Freezing cold and disappointing pizza
This is a little neighborhood Italian restaurant where families are welcome! Unfortunately, the sound carries from concrete floors to the walls, the glass, and up to the unmuted ceiling where it bounces right back to guests. Calm and quiet it is not. So if there are a lot of guests and screaming kids, forget about any decent dinner conversation. And it's FREEZING inside. Omgoodness. So cold I sat on my hands and then of course the pizza 🍕 got cold. Fast. And speaking of the pizza, we ordered the Scuderie Italia Margherita pizza. The places on the pizza that had sauce were good, but there wasn't much sauce on that pie. The wine was bitter, salad croutons were stale, and the service was average - the best part of the experience. So if you're thinking Italian at a little local pizzeria. Scuderie on down the road.
  • sauce on pizza5
  • service5
  • sound carries2
  • FREEZING inside1
  • pizza2
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Group Size
  • Solo
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Wait Time
  • Immediate (0–5 min.)
Noise Level
  • Moderate
Emiliana D.
Review date: 11/05/2025
9
Amazing Pizza and Good Service
My experience at this restaurant was very positive. The pizza was amazing, and I would totally recommend the diavola. The service was also pretty good.
  • pizza10
  • diavola10
  • service8
Price per Person
  • $101+
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Noise Level
  • Moderate
MARIA C.
Review date: 11/01/2025
5
Pizza Good, Staff Out of This World
My experience at this restaurant was a mixed bag. The pizza was good, but the appetizers were mediocre. The most striking aspect of my visit was the staff; they seemed to be high as a kite, completely out of touch, as if they were on another planet.
  • pizza7
  • apps3
  • Staff1
Price per Person
  • $21–$30
Visit Type
  • Family Dinner
Group Type
  • Family
Group Size
  • Small Group
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Noise Level
  • Quiet
Matt W.
Review date: 11/01/2025
7
Mixed Feelings on Food, Great Service
My family loved the food, but I thought it was just ok. We tried the chicken parmesan, rigatoni with bolognese, rigatoni with mushroom sauce, and the chicken and pesto. The puccia bread was amazing. We also took a pizza to go, but wouldn’t order it again. The service was great and we would go again.
  • chicken parmesan5
  • rigatoni with bolognese5
  • rigatoni with mushroom sauce5
  • pizza3
Price per Person
  • $31–$40
Visit Type
  • Tourist Experience
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Noise Level
  • Quiet
Kathrin
Review date: 10/26/2025
10
Authentic Italian Gem in San Diego!
My experience at this Italian restaurant while traveling in San Diego was truly exceptional. The food was amazing and authentically Italian. We enjoyed both the Pasta and Pizza, which were both delicious. I highly recommend trying the tiramisu – it's a dream! The staff was also incredibly friendly, making for a wonderful dining experience. We will definitely be returning when we are next in San Diego!
  • food10
  • Pasta9
  • Pizza9
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Mayck E. V.
Review date: 10/23/2025
10
Excellent Italian Food and Service!
My experience at the restaurant was excellent. The service was outstanding 👏👌, and the restaurant itself is excellent. The pasta was a delight, very delicious 🤤. I love Italian food ❤️.
  • service10
  • pasta10
  • Italian food10
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Regular Visit
Group Type
  • Couple
Group Size
  • Couple
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Noise Level
  • Quiet
Jeneane F.
Review date: 10/15/2025
10
Weekly Favorite: Pizza & Truffle Fries!
My boyfriend and I are here every week, and we absolutely love the pizza and truffle fries. The waiters and staff are super sweet and will remember you!
  • pizza9
  • truffle fries9
  • waiters and staff10

Top Restaurants in

Lou's
9.6
out of 10

12

100%

Supra Dinner Society
9.6
out of 10

150

100%

1904 Street Dogs
9.6
out of 10

73

100%

Taste of India
9.4
out of 10

307

100%