oChef » Pauly’s at Earl’s – Seattle » Pauly’s at Earl’s – Seattle – Reviews

Pauly's at Earl's - Reviews

4333 University Wy NE, 98015 Seattle
All reviews at a glance
117

Reviews

69.2%

Satisfaction

24

negative

12

neutral

81

positive

What people say about Pauly's at Earl's

Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Jose P.
Review date: 12/13/2025
2
No Greeting, Poor Service
My experience at this restaurant was disappointing from the start. Upon arrival, there was no greeting of any kind, which was particularly off-putting as it was my first visit. I was also not informed that I needed to come to the bar to order. The overall service and atmosphere received a low rating of 1.
  • greeting1
  • order process1
Price per Person
  • $1–$10
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Broek D.
Review date: 11/29/2025
9
Comfortable, Excellent Food, Great Value
My experience at this restaurant was very positive. The setting was comfortable, and the food was excellent, especially considering the price point. I highly recommend it for a lowkey night out.
  • comfortable setting10
  • excellent food10
  • price point9
Visit Type
  • Delivery
Group Size
  • Solo
Service Type
  • Takeout
Wait Time
  • Immediate (0–5 min.)
Kev M.
Review date: 11/15/2025
6
Great food, terrible service
I came in for a takeout order and was immediately interrogated by the staff asking for my ID. Even after I provided it, the employee kept asking why I was there, as if I needed a reason. To make matters worse, the supervisor accused me of not paying for an online order. While I usually don't want to bring up race, I was the only Black person in the establishment. The food was great and cheap, but I won't be returning due to the service experience.
  • food5
  • cheap5
  • takeout order2
  • interrogated1
  • supervisor accused1
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Solo Dinner
Group Size
  • Solo
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Lunch
Wait Time
  • Immediate (0–5 min.)
Owen T.
Review date: 09/12/2025
8
Great Deep Fried Drunchies at Pauly's
Pauly's, located in the back corner of Earl's, is a reputable spot for fine deep fried drunchies. My selection included a mini combo of onion rings, mozzarella sticks, and jalapeño poppers, all served with waffle fries. It was surprisingly accompanied by four different dipping sauces. Don't be put off by the metal dog bowl it's served in; the food itself is excellent. I'd recommend pairing this experience with a Coors Light and a Mariner's win.
  • deep fried drunchies9
  • onion rings9
  • mozzarella sticks9
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Online R.
Review date: 08/10/2025
9
Cheesy and Crispy Mac and Cheese Grilled Cheese
My experience at the restaurant was great! I had the macaroni and cheese grilled cheese, and it was perfectly cheesy and crispy. The waffle fries were also good.
  • macaroni and cheese grilled cheese9
  • waffle fries8
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Friends
Group Size
  • Small Group
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Wait Time
  • Immediate (0–5 min.)
Noise Level
  • Loud
Derric L.
Review date: 03/01/2025
8
College Bar: Cheap Drinks & Fun Crowd
My experience at this bar on the college strip was quite interesting. Before 10 pm, the atmosphere was easy & accessible. However, after 10 pm, the college crowd arrives to enjoy their youth. If their energy is an issue for you, I'd advise you to stay away. But if you're looking for a good time with cheap drinks and $1 pool tables, regardless of the crowd, this is your spot. The food, service, and atmosphere were all rated a 5, and the noise level was loud but still allowed for conversation.
  • cheap drinks9
  • pool tables8
  • college crowd6
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Couple
Group Size
  • Couple
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Wait Time
  • Long (31+ min.)
Jessica C.
Review date: 09/30/2024
2
Disappointing Wait for Food
We went for drinks and wings while watching the football games. The online information stated that the food side was open from noon to 2 am on weekends. However, upon arrival, we were told it opened at 4 pm. At 4 pm, we were then informed it would be 4: 30 pm. When 4: 30 pm arrived, the staff mentioned needing another 15 minutes. This place was recommended to us as we are from out of town. Unfortunately, we had other plans and had to leave before we could try their food. We would have loved to try their food.
  • food1
  • food side2
  • waiting time1
Price per Person
  • $1–$10
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Size
  • Solo
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Wait Time
  • Immediate (0–5 min.)
Noise Level
  • Quiet
Dinesh K.
Review date: 05/22/2024
5
Empty Bar with Pool Tables
My experience at this restaurant was limited as I only had a beer and didn't try the food. The place is spacious and features two pool tables. I visited on a Sunday evening and was surprised to find the bar in the U-District empty.
  • beer6
  • spacious8
  • pool tables8
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Friends
Group Size
  • Small Group
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Kathy S.
Review date: 04/20/2024
9
Awesome Bartenders and Fun Atmosphere!
My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! The bartenders were awesome, and the door person was also awesome! It's a great spot with college kids and a mixture of peeps. Playing pool was fun, and they have 3 tables 😉🎵🎶💖. The Loaded Nachos were a highlight, and the overall service, atmosphere, and food were top-notch.
  • bartenders10
  • door person10
  • pool8
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Friends
Group Size
  • Small Group
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Wait Time
  • Long (31+ min.)
Brian M. D.
Review date: 03/12/2024
6
Solid Sports Bar with Service Lags
My experience at this college/sports bar was a solid 3-star. The service was friendly, but unfortunately, it was slow. The food was okay; while the fish was freshly fried and hot, the chips/fries were not. I wouldn't go back specifically for the food. The atmosphere offers pool tables and plenty of screens to watch sports, and they serve bar food late.
  • food5
  • fish8
  • pool tables7
  • service4
  • chips/fries3

Top Restaurants in

Lou's
9.6
out of 10

12

100%

Supra Dinner Society
9.6
out of 10

150

100%

1904 Street Dogs
9.6
out of 10

73

100%

Taste of India
9.4
out of 10

307

100%