Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
oChef » Mustafio’s Pizza – San Francisco
Mustafio's Pizza - San Francisco
Photo from Mustafio’s Pizza
Mustafio's Pizza at a glance
San Francisco Polk Gulch
- 🍕 Pizzeria
$$
Price per Person $11–$20
mentioned by 51 of the guests
#101 out of 2403 places to eat in San Francisco
#4 Pizzeria out of 115 in San Francisco
Excellent
8.8 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
263
Reviews
88.6%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Quality pizza
- Warm service
- Good value
Frequently criticized
- Delivery issues
- Parking woes
- Interior upkeep
The pizzeria Mustafio’s Pizza in San Francisco’s vibrant Polk Gulch neighborhood invites you to discover a menu crafted for every craving. You’ll find delicious options whether you’re seeking a quick bite or a satisfying late-night meal.
This casual spot is perfect for enjoying a variety of pizzas and more, making it a go-to for locals and visitors alike. You can easily grab a slice or settle in for a relaxed dining experience.
Overview: Introducting Mustafio's Pizza
Mustafio’s Pizza offers a generally positive experience, with many customers praising the delicious pizza and the genuinely kind owner. You’ll often find the staff to be friendly, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere that makes dining here a pleasant affair.
However, some visitors have noted occasional issues, particularly concerning delivery reliability which can sometimes lead to long waits. There are also mentions of inconsistent quality with some old pizza slices, suggesting it’s best to ensure your order is fresh.
Excellent
8.8
out of 10
263
Reviews
88.6%
Satisfaction
20
negative
10
neutral
233
positive
Mustafio’s Pizza earns a strong overall 8.8 score, reflecting a largely positive customer sentiment. With 88.6% customer satisfaction, it’s clear most patrons leave content.
This positive outlook is built on a solid foundation of 233 positive remarks against just 20 negative ones, out of 263 total comments. Digging deeper, the Food (8.8) and Service (8.8) are standout aspects, both rated highly by diners.
The Ambience (8.7) also contributes significantly to the experience, while the Value (8.6) is consistently seen as good, offering a well-rounded package for visitors.
What people like
- Delicious pizza
- Friendly service
- Great value
What people don't like
- Delivery reliability
- Parking difficulty
- Dated interior
Mustafio’s Pizza presents a compelling option for those seeking a satisfying meal, backed by a solid 8.7 recommendation score. It’s a place where the strengths in food, service, and value often shine through, making for a generally enjoyable visit.
If you prioritize a friendly atmosphere and good pizza at a fair price, this spot is worth considering. Just be mindful of potential delivery hiccups and parking challenges, and perhaps opt for a fresh slice to ensure the best experience.
Similar Restaurants in San Francisco
- Pizzeria
9.3
out of 10
out of 10
34
100%
- $$
- Cow Hollow
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
9.1
out of 10
out of 10
186
96.2%
- $$
- Mission District
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.9
out of 10
out of 10
498
95.6%
- $$
- Russian Hill
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.5
out of 10
out of 10
549
88.3%
- $$
- Transbay
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.4
out of 10
out of 10
164
84.8%
- $$
- Silver Terrace
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.3
out of 10
out of 10
321
86%
- $$
- Sunset District
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Mustafio's Pizza
Food (8.8 out of 10)
mentioned by 95% of the guests
When it comes to the food, customers are clearly loving whats on offer! With an excellent score of 8.8 and a good customer satisfaction of 89.5%, its no surprise that 119 out of 133 comments rave about the delicious pizza, especially the pesto chicken pizza. Many appreciate the quality ingredients and crispy crust, making for a memorable meal.
However, a few of the 11 negative comments point out some areas for improvement. Concerns were raised about the cheese being gross and the crust being bad. Some also mentioned issues with marinara drying up or being watered down, and a few felt they received old pizza or burnt pieces.
Food
133
Reviews
89%
Satisfaction
11
negative
3
neutral
119
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Excellent pizza quality
- Delicious pesto chicken
- Generous, huge slices
What people don't like
- Old/burnt pizza
- Watered-down marinara
- Gross cheese
Often praised
- pizzaMy experience at this restaurant has been consistently positive. I go there all the time because the staff is friendly and the pizza is tasty. The slices are huge, and my favorites are the pepperoni and chicken pesto.
- foodI absolutely loved the food
- slicesI go there all the time because the staff is friendly and the pizza is tasty. The slices are huge, and my favorites are the pepperoni and chicken pesto. They also conveniently accept EBT.
- FoodEvery bite was a treat, showcasing fresh ingredients and expert preparation. Overall, I'd give Mustfio’s a solid 5-star rating. If you're in the mood for delicious pizza paired with exceptional service, this is the place to be.
- chicken pestoalso the chicken pesto
- crustI had the best slice in San Francisco, made by an amazing Indian guy. It was soo good, with a super cheesy topping and a crispy crust. The service and atmosphere were both rated a perfect 5, and the food was also a 5.
- qualityMy experience at this restaurant was absolutely amazing! The pizza was so delicious and of good quality. The crisp and flavor hit my palate in the best way.
- chicken pesto pizzaTheir chicken pesto pizza is so great.
- doughThe dough is the best
- flavorIt was bursting with flavor
Frequently criticized
- pizzaif you order the dry pizza in the window, you'll want to order it crispy, or it'll be cold on top
- burnt corner piecesgetting the burnt corner pieces of the OLD pizza
- cheeseThe cheese was gross.
- crustCrust is pretty bad.
- heat lamp burnt middle pieceleft with a heat lamp burnt middle piece
- marinarathe marinara is watered down and only a quarter full
- marinara sidesthe marinara (sides) @ $.75 or $.50, pending who is working, used to be thick and filled to the top
- old pizzaburnt corner pieces of the OLD pizza
- pizza qualityVery mediocre pizza quality, tastes like something you would throw in the microwave
- quality pizzaif you want a quality pizza, get a slice right out of the oven
If you're craving some seriously good pizza, this spot is definitely worth a try, especially for their popular pesto chicken. Just be mindful of ordering fresh slices to avoid any potential issues with dried-out or older offerings.
Service (8.8 out of 10)
mentioned by 83% of the guests
When it comes to service, this spot truly shines, boasting a good score of 8.8 and an impressive good customer satisfaction of 89.5%. With 68 positive remarks out of 76 total, guests frequently rave about the friendly employees and fast service. Many appreciate the great service and the convenience of being open late.
However, its not entirely without its hiccups, with 7 negative comments. Some experiences point to issues with pickup time and delivery problems, particularly when notification about changes was lacking. A few customers also mentioned concerns regarding the owners actions, like refusing conversation about delivery issues.
Service
76
Reviews
89%
Satisfaction
7
negative
1
neutral
68
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly, attentive staff
- Fast, efficient service
- Convenient late hours
What people don't like
- Delivery issues
- Poor pickup notification
- Refused conversation
Often praised
- serviceservice and atmosphere were also rated a perfect 5
- ownerMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic. The owner is incredibly kind, and the pizza is sincerely great. It's a decent place to hang out, and I consider it the best pizza spot in the neighborhood.
- staffMy experience at Mustfio’s on February 13, 2025, was outstanding! From the moment I walked in, the service was impeccable, earning a 10/10 for their attentive and friendly staff. The highlight was the Chicken Pesto Pizza, which was bursting with flavor.
- wait timeWhile parking can be somewhat difficult to find, the overall experience was fantastic. It's a very upbeat and kid-friendly spot with indoor dining and no wait time. The price is also very affordable, ranging from $1–10 per person.
- ServiceService:5
- customer serviceabove and beyond customer service.
- Indian guymade by an amazing Indian guy
- MohsinMohsin was friendly, attentive and quick.
- MustafaMustafa is always friendly and vibing
- Mustafio himselfMustafio himself is super nice!
Frequently criticized
- consistent customerHe just lost a consistent customer
- conversationI ordered 8 large pizzas, and after 4 hours, there was still no delivery. They claimed it was delivered, but refused to engage in any conversation. Unfortunately, I cannot give 0 stars.
- delivery4 hours still no delivery
- notificationwasn’t notified in the change of time
- ownerowner will blatantly pick out the worst piece
- pickup timepickup was for 7:20. I arrive and I’m told it would be an hour or more
- receiptAlways check your receipt when you order, as you may find out he charges you for a togo box
Overall, the service here is a major plus, with a friendly and efficient team, especially for those needing open late options. While most experiences are great, be aware of potential communication hiccups with pickup time or delivery. For a generally pleasant and quick visit, it's definitely worth checking out.
Ambience (8.7 out of 10)
mentioned by 40% of the guests
When it comes to ambience, this spot really shines! With a solid score of 8.7 and customer satisfaction at 83.3%, its clear most folks love the vibe. Many of the 30 positive comments highlight the great atmosphere, music, and overall environment.
Guests appreciate the clean and safe setting, cozy feel, and even its kid-friendliness and wheelchair accessibility, making it a truly welcoming place. However, its not entirely without its quirks. A couple of the 2 negative remarks mention that the place isn't particularly fancy or well-maintained, and finding parking can be a bit of a challenge.
But honestly, these minor points are often overshadowed by the overall positive experience, especially given the high praise for everything else.
Ambience
36
Reviews
83%
Satisfaction
2
negative
4
neutral
30
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Great atmosphere
- Clean and safe
- Kid-friendly environment
What people don't like
- Parking can be tricky
- Not a fancy place
Often praised
- atmosphereThe service was exceptional, with Mustafa being consistently friendly and vibing with us at any time of the day or night. The atmosphere was also great, contributing to a very positive dining experience.
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- placeThe owner is incredibly kind, and the pizza is sincerely great. It's a decent place to hang out, and I consider it the best pizza spot in the neighborhood.
- Good timeGood time near the TL!
- TVMy experience at this restaurant was excellent. I particularly enjoyed dining inside, as there was more room and a TV to watch absolutely anything. The pizza was great, and the overall experience was highly positive, with top scores for service, atmosphere, and food.
- Wheelchair accessibilityRestaurant seems to be ADA compliant with no obstacles for entry.
- clean and safeclean and safe!
- companygreat company
- environmentbest environment
- great placeGreat place for even late night
Frequently criticized
- parkingparking can be somewhat difficult to find
- placeThe server was really sweet, and the prices were great for the quality and portion size. The place itself isn’t fancy and isn’t very well maintained since it’s a small spot, but the pizza completely makes up for it. Plus, they stay open late, which made it the perfect end to our concert night.
If youre looking for a place with a great, welcoming atmosphere, good music, and a clean, safe environment, this spot is definitely worth checking out. Just be prepared that it might not be the fanciest joint, and you might need a little patience to find parking. But for a cozy, kid-friendly vibe, its a solid choice.
Value (8.6 out of 10)
mentioned by 25% of the guests
When it comes to getting bang for your buck, this spot truly shines! With a fantastic score of 8.6 and a customer satisfaction rate of 88.9%, its clear that guests feel theyre getting a good deal. Based on 16 positive remarks out of 18 total, people consistently praise the price per person, affordable slice, and good price, often highlighting EBT acceptance as a huge plus.
Whats even more impressive is the complete absence of negative feedback regarding value. There were 0 negative opinions among the 18 total, suggesting that customers universally appreciate the pricing and feel its fair, if not exceptional. It seems there's simply nothing to complain about when it comes to cost here.
Value
18
Reviews
88%
Satisfaction
0
negative
2
neutral
16
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Affordable prices
- Great quality for price
- EBT accepted
What people don't like
Often praised
- priceMy experience at the restaurant was fantastic! I found the pizza to be delicious, and it was also not at all expensive. I would especially recommend the pesto chicken pizza.
- pricesthe prices were great for the quality and portion size
- EBTThey accept EBT
- EBT acceptanceMy first time here and I wish I had known about this place sooner! I was really impressed by the quality of pizza and the fact that they accept EBT is great. The service was clean and friendly, which is always a huge plus, especially so late at night!
- affordable sliceMost affordable slice I've had in the city so far.
- good pricegood quality for a good price
- price per personPrice per person:$1–10
- reasonably pricedThe ingredients were fresh, and the taste was memorable. It was also reasonably priced. The atmosphere and service were both rated a perfect 5, and the food also received a 5-star rating.
- seven dollarsfor just seven dollars
- valuegreat value compared to a lot of other pizza in town
Frequently criticized
No complaints so far.
If youre looking for a place where your money goes a long way without sacrificing quality, this is definitely worth checking out. Youll find the prices incredibly fair, making it a smart choice for an affordable and satisfying meal.
How are the prices at Mustafio's Pizza?
You’re looking at roughly 11 per person – reported by 51 diners. That puts it in the $11–$20 category. For a Pizzeria in San Francisco, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
What’s cool is that while the average hovers around 11$, a good number of guests actually spend less, often in the $1–$10 range, making it quite an accessible spot for a delicious pizza.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 51 reviews.
See how this Pizzeria stacks up against similar spots in San Francisco when it comes to value for money.
Overall, we think the pricing here feels pretty fair for a Pizzeria, especially considering it’s San Francisco. It offers good value for a casual meal.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Mustafio's Pizza
Price per Person
- $1–$10
Visit Type
- Casual Outing
Group Type
- Friends
Group Size
- Small Group
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
9
Amazing Halal Pizza Spot!
My experience at this restaurant was amazing, especially for halal pizza. We ordered the pepperoni and chicken pesto pizzas and honestly couldn’t decide which one we liked more. Both were so good, and I know this will be our go-to pizza spot from now on.
The server was really sweet, and the prices were great for the quality and portion size. The place itself isn’t fancy and isn’t very well maintained since it’s a small spot, but the pizza completely makes up for it. Plus, they stay open late, which made it the perfect end to our concert night.
Loved it!
- pepperoni pizza10
- chicken pesto pizzas10
- server9
- place4
Visit Type
- Regular Visit
Service Type
- Dine-in
9
Great Pizza and Service!
I have had nothing but good experiences here at the pizza place. Thanks for the great pizza, keep up the good work.
- pizza9
- experiences9
Price per Person
- $1–$10
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
10
Fire Pizza, Late Nights & EBT!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The pizza was absolutely fire! I was also impressed that they accept 'ebt hot food' and are open late late night.
The service was a perfect 5/5, the atmosphere was a 5/5, and the food was a 5/5. It's also very affordable, with a price per person of $1–10, and there was no wait time.
- pizza10
- ebt hot food9
- late night9
Price per Person
- $21–$30
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Dine-in
9
Incredible Calzone, Couldn't Stop Eating!
I ordered the 14-inch calzone with chicken, bacon, and onion, and it was "crazy plugged. " The staff member mentioned I could save the rest for work the next day, but I ended up eating the whole thing myself. It was that good!
- 14-inch calzone10
- chicken bacon and onion10
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
9
Great Quality and Value!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The pepperoni and chicken pesto slices were my absolute favorite. I found the food to be cheaper and of overall better quality compared to other places in the area.
The service and atmosphere were also rated a perfect 5 out of 5, making for a truly enjoyable visit.
- pepperoni and chicken pesto slices10
- food quality9
- price9
What Mustafio's Pizza offers
Crowd
- Transgender safespace
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Family-friendly
- Groups
- College students
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Amenities
- Restroom
Offerings
- Late-night food
- Vegan options
- Salad bar
- Small plates
- Organic dishes
- Halal food
- Vegetarian options
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Catering
- Dessert
- Dinner
- Seating
- Lunch
Service Options
- No-contact delivery
- Takeout
- Curbside pickup
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Parking
- Free street parking
- Paid street parking
Atmosphere
- Casual
FAQs
What kind of dietary options can you find at Mustafio's Pizza?
At Mustafio’s Pizza, you’ll discover a diverse menu catering to various preferences. You can enjoy delicious vegan options, vegetarian options, and even halal food. They also offer organic dishes and a fresh salad bar, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
What service and dining options are available at Mustafio's Pizza in Polk Gulch?
Mustafio’s Pizza provides flexible service options including no-contact delivery, takeout, curbside pickup, and dine-in. You can enjoy lunch, dinner, or dessert, and seating is available. They also offer catering services, making it convenient for any occasion.
How does Mustafio's Pizza generally perform?
Mustafio’s Pizza holds a strong overall score of 8.8 with 88.6% customer satisfaction. Its Food (8.8), Service (8.8), Ambience (8.7), and Value (8.6) are all rated highly by customers.
What do customers appreciate most about Mustafio's Pizza?
Customers frequently praise the delicious pizza, the kind owner, and the friendly staff. Many also highlight the great value, noting the affordable prices and the acceptance of EBT.
Are there any common issues or drawbacks at Mustafio's Pizza?
Some customers have reported difficulties with delivery reliability and finding parking. There are also occasional mentions of inconsistent pizza quality, particularly with slices that may have been sitting out.