Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
oChef » Hog Island Hoagie – Seattle
Hog Island Hoagie - Seattle
Photo from Hog Island Hoagie
Hog Island Hoagie at a glance
Seattle Fremont
- 🥪 Sandwich Shop
$$
Price per Person $11–$20
mentioned by 14 of the guests
#760 out of 858 places to eat in Seattle
#6 Sandwich Shop out of 23 in Seattle
Average
5.8 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
124
Reviews
51.6%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Sandwich quality
- Good ambiance
- Friendly staff
Frequently criticized
- High prices
- Poor service
- Bread issues
The restaurant, a vibrant sandwich shop in Seattle’s lively Fremont neighborhood, invites you to discover Hog Island Hoagie. You’ll find a casual atmosphere perfect for a quick bite, whether you’re grabbing lunch or dinner.
This spot is known for its diverse menu, including excellent vegan and vegetarian options, ensuring there’s something delicious for everyone to enjoy.
Overview: Introducting Hog Island Hoagie
Hog Island Hoagie often delivers on its core promise, with many customers finding the sandwiches to be truly memorable. The quality of the bread and the overall taste frequently earn high marks, making it a local favorite for some seeking a genuine hoagie experience.
However, the experience can be inconsistent. While the atmosphere is generally pleasant, some visitors encounter issues with the service and feel that the portions don’t quite match the price point, leading to mixed opinions on overall satisfaction.
Average
5.8
out of 10
124
Reviews
51.6%
Satisfaction
49
negative
11
neutral
64
positive
Overall, Hog Island Hoagie achieves an Restaurant Score of 5.8, placing it in the average category. Customer sentiment aligns with this, showing Customer Satisfaction at 51.6%, indicating a mixed reception.
These insights are drawn from 124 customer comments, comprising 64 positive remarks and 49 negative ones, highlighting a noticeable split in experiences. Delving into specifics, the Food (6.5) is generally well-regarded, often being the primary draw.
The Ambience (6.9) also contributes positively to the dining experience. However, Service (4.5) appears to be a consistent weak point, and Value (2.6) is a significant area of concern, considerably impacting the overall assessment.
What people like
- Exceptional sandwich taste
- Inviting atmosphere
- Attentive bartender
What people don't like
- Poor value for money
- Inconsistent service
- Inconsistent bread quality
Hog Island Hoagie offers a compelling core product, particularly if you’re seeking a standout hoagie in a comfortable setting. It’s a place that can truly satisfy a specific craving, but it comes with a few caveats that potential visitors should consider before committing.
With a Recommendation Score of 6.3, it suggests a cautious endorsement. While the food often shines, be prepared for potential inconsistencies in service and a price point that some find challenging.
It’s worth trying if your expectations are managed.
Similar Restaurants in Seattle
- Sandwich Shop
8.7
out of 10
out of 10
331
93.1%
- $$
- Lawton Park
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Sandwich Shop
8
out of 10
out of 10
281
79.7%
- $$
- Greenwood
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Sandwich Shop
7.4
out of 10
out of 10
310
70.3%
- $$
- Fremont
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Sandwich Shop
7
out of 10
out of 10
202
69.3%
- $$
- Wallingford
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Sandwich Shop
6.4
out of 10
out of 10
103
61.2%
- $$
- Maple Leaf
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Sandwich Shop
5.4
out of 10
out of 10
67
47.8%
- $$
- Magnolia Village
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Hog Island Hoagie
Food (6.5 out of 10)
mentioned by 94% of the guests
When it comes to the food, this spot offers a pretty solid experience overall, landing a 6.5 score. While customer satisfaction sits at a 63.5%, indicating a somewhat positive but mixed reception, many rave about the delicious sandwiches and hoagies. With 54 positive remarks out of 85 total comments, folks often highlight the quality ingredients and great flavor, especially in their Italian and tuna sandwiches.
However, there are some notable concerns, with 26 negative remarks. The bread seems to be a recurring issue, with some finding the new rolls too dense or tough, impacting the overall sandwich structure. A few experiences also mentioned ignored requests regarding ingredients and a perceived lack of deli meat, which can be a real bummer.
Food
85
Reviews
63%
Satisfaction
26
negative
5
neutral
54
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Delicious sandwiches
- Quality ingredients
- Great flavor
What people don't like
- Inconsistent bread quality
- Poor sandwich structure
- Ignored requests
Often praised
- sandwichI ate my sandwich about an hour ago and I'm still thinking about it, which is really good for a sandwich. The sandwich was so memorable that it's still on my mind hours later.
- sandwichesThe sandwiches here are the real deal
- foodthe food was very good
- Hog IslanderI ordered the Hog Islander via Uber Eats, and when I tell you that it was the best hoagie I've ever eaten, I really mean that, and that's after it traveled and was delivered. I can only imagine how good it'll be if I go down there and get it myself.
- Italian hoagiethe Italian hoagie was the best I've had
- breadgreat bread, nice kick to it, and the right kind of bread
- hoagienice hoagie for Seattle
- American Herothe American Hero was pretty good too
- Chicago pickleThey serve the best Italian sandwich (aside from JM) and one of the best cheesesteaks in town. It's the perfect hangover cure, especially if you don't skip the Chicago pickle. Yum!
- East Coast style subbest East Coast style sub I've had
Frequently criticized
- breadHowever, I gotta tell ya, this new bread isn’t it. It’s too dense, the outside is too hard, and overall has too much chew to it.
- rollMy experience at this restaurant was disappointing. The deli roll was poorly constructed, with only 1 slice of each deli item covering the roll, and it wasn't a good roll. For comparison, Wawa offers a shorty-10" roll with 3 slices of each deli item, and it's only $4.
- sandwichYeah OK, the sandwich was good. However, I paid $25 after all the taxes and fees for one small sandwich. Also, they forgot part of my order and had to make it after I got there.
- Sea Wolf hoagieThe Sea Wolf hoagie is really not a great match
- chips75 takeaway fee. I also thought the sandwich was supposed to come with chips, but there were none. While the sandwich itself was good, I don't believe any sandwich, other than a muffaletta in New Orleans, is worth $25.
- coleslawtheir coleslaw is actively bad
- crunchy crustI ordered takeout, and by the time I got home, I realized they didn't even bake my roll. It was just pale and sad all the way through, lacking a crunchy crust and a soft chewy interior. My experience with the food was extremely disappointing.
- deli item sliceonly 1 slice of each deli item covering the roll
- deli meatlack of deli meat is really disappointing
- hot peppersI ordered twice from this restaurant because I'm too far from other sandwich places for pick up or delivery. On both occasions, my requests to leave the sandwich whole and omit the hot peppers were ignored. This last order led to a bad night of intestinal illness, from both ends.
If you're craving a flavorful sandwich with quality ingredients, this place is definitely worth a try, especially for their hoagies. Just be aware that the bread quality can be a hit or miss, and it might be wise to double-check your order for any special requests.
Service (4.5 out of 10)
mentioned by 34% of the guests
When it comes to service, its a bit of a mixed bag, with a score of 4.5, placing it in the average range. However, customer satisfaction is quite low at just 17.6%, indicating significant room for improvement. On the bright side, some folks have praised the friendly and attentive bartender, and a few have highlighted smooth delivery experiences, noting theyve never had any issues.
These 3 positive remarks offer a glimmer of hope. However, the majority of feedback, with 8 negative opinions out of 17 total, points to some serious snags. Many customers faced frustratingly long wait times and indifferent staff.
Issues like ignored requests, a non-functional website's ordering system, and forgotten order items really soured the experience for others. It seems the overall service and customer treatment often fall short.
Service
17
Reviews
17%
Satisfaction
8
negative
6
neutral
3
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly bartender
- Reliable delivery
What people don't like
- Indifferent staff
- Ignored requests
- Long wait times
Often praised
- bartenderThe bartender is super friendly and attentive
- deliverybest hoagie I've ever eaten... after it traveled and was delivered
- issuesnever had any issues
Frequently criticized
- customer servicewith this customer service they won’t get many customers
- orderHowever, I paid $25 after all the taxes and fees for one small sandwich. Also, they forgot part of my order and had to make it after I got there. I could easily go to a place like Jersey Mike’s that has sandwiches that are, I think, just as good at half the price.
- requestsI ordered twice from this restaurant because I'm too far from other sandwich places for pick up or delivery. On both occasions, my requests to leave the sandwich whole and omit the hot peppers were ignored. This last order led to a bad night of intestinal illness, from both ends.
- serviceMy experience at the restaurant was disappointing. They were out of bread and could not serve us, which was surprising considering it was 1 PM on a Thursday. This lack of a basic item significantly impacted our ability to enjoy our meal.
- staffThe food was great, specifically the sandwich, which was fantastic. However, ordering in person was difficult due to the indifferent Bauhaus staff. I recommend ordering electronically, but unfortunately, the website's ordering function wasn't working.
- treatmenttreated me very bad
- wait timetook a long time for me to get my food
- website's ordering functionHowever, ordering in person was difficult due to the indifferent Bauhaus staff. I recommend ordering electronically, but unfortunately, the website's ordering function wasn't working. Despite the service issues, the sandwich itself was truly fantastic.
If youre lucky, you might encounter a friendly bartender or get a smooth delivery. However, be prepared for potential frustrations like long waits, indifferent staff, or issues with your order, as customer satisfaction is quite low. It might be worth trying if youre willing to overlook some service inconsistencies.
Ambience (6.9 out of 10)
mentioned by 22% of the guests
The ambiance here gets a pretty good nod from many, with a score of 6.9 indicating a generally positive reception. Customers frequently praised the atmosphere and even called it a hidden gem and a nice spot, especially if youre looking for a "Vikings bar" experience. While customer satisfaction sits at a 66.7% (a mixed bag), 6 out of 9 comments were positive, showing a solid appreciation for the setting.
However, not everyone was thrilled with the vibe. Some found the "atmosphere" to be a "Super ordinary sports bar vibe, " describing it as "dark and beer soaked. " Others felt the "bar" itself lacked character, and 3 negative comments highlighted these concerns, suggesting theres room for improvement for some patrons.
Ambience
9
Reviews
66%
Satisfaction
3
negative
0
neutral
6
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Fun game atmosphere
- Hidden gem spot
- Vikings bar vibe
What people don't like
- Ordinary sports bar
- Lacks character
- Dark, beer-soaked
Often praised
- atmospherethe atmosphere was great
- Vikings barit's a Vikings bar that shows the viles game
- ambianceVery nice ambiance and fun to watch games.
- hidden gemHidden gem in the heart of Ballard
- spotDelicious. The tator tots as a side were a great touch, and they had a nice spot. Can't believe I've never been here and I live a mile away.
Frequently criticized
- atmosphereSuper ordinary sports bar vibe. Dark and beer soaked.
- barThe bar itself is just a sports bar and one that doesn't seem to have much character
- photothe photo in the description is of something else
If youre seeking a casual sports bar, especially to catch a Vikings game, this spot could be a fun choice. However, if youre expecting a unique or upscale atmosphere, you might find it a bit ordinary. It's a solid pick for a laid-back game day, but perhaps not for a special occasion.
Value (2.6 out of 10)
mentioned by 25% of the guests
When it comes to value, a few folks found something to smile about, with one person noting the price was quite affordable for a good lunch. In fact, customer satisfaction for value sits at a respectable 77%, which is pretty good overall. It seems that for some, the cost aligned perfectly with their expectations.
However, the overall score for value is a rather poor 2.6, and its clear why, with 12 out of 13 comments expressing concern. Many felt the price for sandwiches was too high, especially given the portion size, leading to a perception of poor value. The added takeaway fee also didnt sit well with customers, making the cost feel even more unreasonable, creating a stark contrast with the otherwise good customer satisfaction.
Value
13
Reviews
7%
Satisfaction
12
negative
0
neutral
1
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Affordable lunch price
What people don't like
- High sandwich price
- Small portions
- Takeaway fees
Often praised
- priceThe food was excellent, and the atmosphere was great, both earning a perfect 5/5. I enjoyed it as a lunch, and the price was very affordable at $1–10 per person.
Frequently criticized
- priceWhile the overall flavor of the sandwich was good, the lack of deli meat was really disappointing. When you charge $15+ for a sandwich, you expect it to be full, but that wasn't the case. Additionally, the sandwich wasn't as long as an East Coast hoagie; it was more like half a hoagie.
- sandwich priceno sandwich other than a muffaletta in NoLa is worth $25
- fee for taking to goadded a fee for taking the sandwich to go which is ridiculous
- takeaway feeadded an $1.75 takeaway few
- valueit would be a good deal for $15 but because it's $30
If you're looking for a budget-friendly meal, this might not be your best bet, as many find the prices steep for what you get. While some appreciate the overall experience, be prepared for potentially high costs, especially for sandwiches and any extra fees.
How are the prices at Hog Island Hoagie?
You’re looking at roughly 20 per person – reported by 14 diners. That puts it in the $11–$20 category. For a Sandwich Shop, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
While the average is 20, most diners spend between $11–$20, with a good chunk also opting for slightly pricier options up to 30 $. So, there’s a nice mix of choices!
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 14 reviews.
How this sandwich shop’s value stacks up against similar spots in Seattle.
Overall, we think the pricing feels quite fair for a mid-range sandwich shop, especially considering the variety of options available. It’s a solid choice if you’re looking for quality without breaking the bank.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Hog Island Hoagie
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
9
Thank you for standing for values
I read about this restaurant in the news and I’d just like to say thank you for standing for what’s right. As Americans, it seems we as a society have been slowly losing our values, and I’m happy to hear this cafe has a clear understanding of what’s theirs. The atmosphere was rated a 5.
- atmosphere10
Price per Person
- $21–$30
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Takeout
3
Overpriced Sandwich, Lacking Sides
My experience at this restaurant was disappointing due to the high price and missing items. I found the $25 price for a sandwich to be insane. Additionally, there was an unexpected $1.
75 takeaway fee. I also thought the sandwich was supposed to come with chips, but there were none. While the sandwich itself was good, I don't believe any sandwich, other than a muffaletta in New Orleans, is worth $25.
- sandwich7
- sandwich price2
- takeaway fee3
- chips2
Price per Person
- $31–$40
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Group Size
- Solo
Service Type
- Takeout
Wait Time
- Long (31+ min.)
2
Overpriced Hoagie with Bad Coleslaw
My experience at this restaurant was disappointing due to the high cost and poor value. I ordered a single hoagie to go, and with a 20% tip, the total came to $30. To make matters worse, they added a fee for taking the sandwich to go, which I found ridiculous.
While the hoagie itself was good, the coleslaw was actively bad. For $30, I expected a much better deal; at $15, it might have been acceptable, but at this price, I will never return. Additionally, the wait time for my food felt long, especially since I was the only one ordering in the bar area.
The bar itself is just a generic sports bar with little character.
- hoagie7
- coleslaw2
- fee for taking to go1
- wait time3
Visit Type
- Delivery
Service Type
- Delivery
1
Ignored Requests, Illness Followed
I ordered twice from this restaurant because I'm too far from other sandwich places for pick up or delivery. On both occasions, my requests to leave the sandwich whole and omit the hot peppers were ignored. This last order led to a bad night of intestinal illness, from both ends.
I'll leave Hog Island Hoagie off my list of places to eat at or from.
- requests1
- hot peppers1
- intestinal illness1
Price per Person
- $21–$30
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Takeout
Meal Type
- Lunch
4
Good sandwich, high price
Yeah OK, the sandwich was good. However, I paid $25 after all the taxes and fees for one small sandwich. Also, they forgot part of my order and had to make it after I got there.
I could easily go to a place like Jersey Mike’s that has sandwiches that are, I think, just as good at half the price.
- sandwich7
- price2
- order3
What Hog Island Hoagie offers
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Vegan options
- Hard liquor
- Quick bite
- Wine
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Vegetarian options
- Alcohol
Dining options
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Catering
Service Options
- Dine-in
- Takeout
- Delivery
Atmosphere
- Casual
FAQs
What dining and drink options are available at Hog Island Hoagie?
At Hog Island Hoagie, you can enjoy lunch, dinner, and catering services. The menu features a variety of sandwiches, including both vegan and vegetarian options. You can also pair your meal with hard liquor, wine, beer, or cocktails.
What service options and accessibility features does Hog Island Hoagie provide?
Hog Island Hoagie offers convenient dine-in, takeout, and delivery services to fit your plans. For accessibility, the establishment features a wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring a welcoming experience for all guests.
What is the overall customer rating for Hog Island Hoagie?
Hog Island Hoagie has an average Restaurant Score of 5.8. While Food (6.5) and Ambience (6.9) are rated moderately well, Service (4.5) and Value (2.6) are areas needing improvement.
What do customers enjoy most about Hog Island Hoagie's food?
Many customers highly praise the Hog Islander and Italian hoagie, often describing them as some of the best they’ve experienced. The quality of the bread is also frequently highlighted as a positive aspect.
What are the main drawbacks or complaints about Hog Island Hoagie?
Key complaints revolve around the perceived poor value due to high prices for portions, and inconsistent service, including reports of indifferent staff and ignored special requests. Some also note issues with bread consistency.