Haystack pizza - Reviews

My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! The pizza was great! The lady providing the service was very cordial, nice, and hospitable. The atmosphere was very quiet.

My experience at this restaurant involved a long wait of an hour for a salad and pizza. Despite the restaurant not being crowded, the waiters provided little attention. The food itself was decent, but the overall experience was marred by the poor service and extended waiting time.

My experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing. We ordered a Caesar salad and a pizza. It took roughly an hour for us to get our food, and the restaurant wasn’t even crowded. There was also no acknowledgement from the waitstaff about the lengthy wait. The pizza was $36 and sadly tasted very similar to a frozen pizza you’d get at the grocery store. We were really excited to try this place, but it ended up just being disappointing.

My experience at this restaurant was unfortunately below average. The food quality was a major letdown. The pizza tasted like a frozen meal, and the calamari was overwhelmingly breaded, with very little actual calamari. It felt like all the ingredients, from the cheese to the pepperoni and crust, were of low quality. On the positive side, the service was average, and the atmosphere was pleasant. I was hoping for an authentic family-owned pizzeria experience, but this place sadly missed the mark.

I ordered from this restaurant via DoorDash for delivery to my home. I placed two orders for Chicken Parmesan, but they sent everything together, seemingly as one portion. Honestly, the portion size was very small for the nearly $30 paid for each dish! Additionally, the Alfredo pasta tasted strange; I suspect the cream or whatever they use was expired. I have been to this place and ordered on some occasions, and the quality of time here is very bad.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I customized my own pizza with salami and bacon, and it was OMG so good. The secret truly is in the sauce, which was delicious and enhanced all the ingredients. I also appreciated the ability to customize the thickness of the pizza; I requested thin crust, and that's exactly what I received. Delicious! The veal was exceptional – I haven't had better beef, and I'm quite picky. We also loved the garlic bread. I'm now obsessed with their sauce and will definitely return to try the pasta. Both waitresses who assisted us were super nice and kind. This is our new favorite place for pizza!

I sent this place an email for a group booking, but I did not get back to me. I guess they don't need the business?

My experience at this restaurant has been disappointing. On two separate occasions, my orders were incorrect. The first time, I ordered pepperoni and mushroom pizza but received sausage and mushroom. We removed the sausage and ate it. Today, I ordered the same pizza, and upon opening the box, I discovered it had mushroom but no pepperoni. When I pointed out the error, the staff claimed it was a computer mistake, despite the receipt clearly stating pepperoni and mushroom. They then took the pizza back, simply threw pepperoni on top, and briefly reheated it. This was a lazy and unprofessional response. I will not be returning for a third visit.

My experience at the restaurant was wonderful! The service was warm and friendly, which I absolutely loved. My pizza was great! I'm already planning my next visit and will be getting extra sauce because it was so yum. I also have a suggestion for a future menu item: a pizza with wax peppers would be fantastic!

After being a patron for over 40 years, last night's dinner service was the absolute worst I had. Two hours and 15 minutes after ordering my food, our meal finally came. The waitress, Tina, explained that the order paper fell to the ground and the cooks didn't see it. Initially, there was no compensation offered. Tina stated that if we didn't want the food anymore, she would give it to the owner. She didn't offer us anything while my friends enjoyed their meals. This waitress needs to be fired.