Big Mario's Pizza - Reviews

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic, particularly with the service. Amber went above and beyond, ensuring my order was prepared exactly as I wanted, even though it wasn't a standard menu item. The food is 100% authentic New York-style pizza, which I can attest to as an Italian who used to live in NY. While it's pricier than the $1 slices I'm used to, the flavor is definitely worth it. The salad was also a highlight – simple, yet incredibly fresh and crunchy, with no mushy tomatoes or wilted lettuce, which is a rare find these days. I would definitely recommend this place.

I was really excited to try a New York pizza, and I really hope this is not representative of that. Unfortunately, I'm stuck eating the rest of a 17-inch pizza because my wife will not eat anymore. The dough tasted like plain dry dough. Some of the onions were not edible. Maybe we got them on a bad night, but for that price, it's hard to try it again.

As a born and raised East Coaster who has lived in Seattle for over 20 years, I can confidently say Big Mario’s is the absolute best NY Style Pizza outside of New York State! The old standbys are magnificent, the original recipes are creative and eccentric, and the wide array of vegetarian options are both outstanding and deliciously original! It's the best legit authentically NY pizza on the west coast, period! Seattle’s best pizza, in the heart of my old neighborhood - beautiful White Center! 🤘

My experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing. We ordered two slices of salami and jalapeño pizza, but the quality was gross 🤮. We both regretted eating it. To make matters worse, it cost $16 for just two slices of what we considered gross pizza.

My experience at the restaurant was a mixed bag. The food was absolutely great, with a rating of 5/5. However, I was surprised and felt it was a bit much to be charged a 20% service fee for 7 take-out pies. While I understand this fee for large parties dining in, for take-out, it felt like I paid for 8. 5 pies and only received 7. The service and atmosphere both received a rating of 3/5.

My experience at this restaurant was a mixed bag. The crust was fantastic, and the sauce was unique and different. However, something was just a bit lacking in flavor for the price. On the positive side, the staff were awesome and friendly! I might give them another shot in the future.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I had the best NY style slice I’ve had in years. The pizza featured perfect punkrock pooled grease in crispy pepperoni, which was absolutely delicious. The staff was kind, and the atmosphere was great, with a hipster bar in the back. The food, service, and atmosphere all received a perfect score of 5.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The staff were incredibly friendly and the service was impressively fast. I found the pizza to be absolutely delicious. A great perk is that you can even hang out in the cool bar next door while waiting for your pizza to cook. They also usually have a really good selection of different pizza by the slice. In my opinion, this is the best pizza in Whitecenter.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The food was incredible, earning a perfect 5/5. The atmosphere was equally impressive, also rated 5/5. While the price per person was on the higher side at $100+, the overall experience made it worthwhile. The service, rated 1/5, was the only area that needs significant improvement.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic, especially for grabbing a pizza by the slice. The pizza was an absolute 10+. I loved that the crust was both crispy and chewy inside. The sauce, cheese, and pepperoni were incredibly tasty and fresh. It's definitely a place I'd recommend to visit!