Alexi's - Reviews

I've been coming here for years and I finally decided to make sure this place gets the recognition it deserves! George has been here for years providing consistent delicious Greek foods. The wait time is always reasonable and food is made to order! Thanks for the years of great service!

My wife and I stumbled upon Alexis Greek restaurant, located at 3863 5th Avenue up town, while searching for new places to try. We ordered a Greek salad and two Gyros for lunch. The food is prepared by two men who have been running the establishment for 28 years. We've never needed reservations, and I doubt they even take them. It's an older building that has remained largely unchanged over the years. The service is fast, the food is excellent, and while the staff are usually busy, they are very friendly. I hesitate to share this diamond in the rough, but fairness dictates it. Everyone who discovers it, like we did 8 years ago, keeps returning, just as we do.

I was looking for a home-cooked meal that was also affordable, and this local spot delivered! If you love Greek food, this is definitely the place to try. They offer generous portions at extremely affordable prices. Alexi deserves so much more recognition for the quality of food served, especially in this economy. It's truly deserving of accolades. 🙏🏽🇬🇷💜

I've been a loyal customer at Alexi's for nearly a decade, and my recent visit last night confirmed why. Everything was just as I remembered. The owner is extremely friendly, and the food is classic Greek cafe/diner fare. My friend and I enjoyed a gyro pita sandwich, a small Greek salad, and a chicken kabob with tzatziki. The meats were seasoned and flavorful, the salad was super fresh, and the tzatziki was incredibly well-crafted. This is a low-key, no-frills Greek joint that truly holds its own. While the interior won't impress, it offers a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel at home. I definitely recommend trying their items, especially the really good baklava.

I was drawn in by the mysterious blue lights, and I’m so glad I walked in! The owner was so sweet, and the food was delicious and really affordable. It’s amazing that they’re able to keep such great prices. Highly recommended!

My experience at this restaurant was truly wonderful. It's a gem amidst the expensive dining scene, offering great food and great service. The food here is exceptional, regardless of price, but the affordable pricing makes the meal even more special. They offer lunch specials that make dining out accessible. The experience is consistently great, always served with a smile. Thank you for feeding us! 😀

My experience at the restaurant was incredibly positive. I found the salad to be incredibly delicious, and the gyro plate was delicious as well. The atmosphere was cozy, and the service was excellent. It's located across from Buffalo Exchange, which is also worth a visit. Overall, a great experience!

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! It's a rare gem that truly combines quality with affordability. The service was also incredibly quick and friendly. It has become my favorite local spot for lunch!

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I found it to be tremendous value for a three-course meal, with consistently high quality food. The owner is kind and hard-working, contributing to a great atmosphere. It's also a dog-friendly establishment.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I had a Gyro for $8 flat, which was an unbeatable deal. The service was exceptional; the guy was super nice, making it a real pleasure to eat there. The food, service, and atmosphere were all rated a perfect 5 out of 5.