oChef » Mythic Pizza – San Francisco » Mythic Pizza – San Francisco – Reviews

Mythic Pizza - Reviews

551 Haight St, 94143 San Francisco
All reviews at a glance
252

Reviews

70.2%

Satisfaction

57

negative

18

neutral

177

positive

What people say about Mythic Pizza

Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Delivery
Mermaid
Review date: 10/27/2025
9
Mythic Slice is Super Tasty!
My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! I tried the mythic slice and it was super tasty. The price for the size of the slice was also great. The delivery was super fast. I will definitely be coming back!
  • mythic slice9
  • price for size8
  • delivery10
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Aditya M.
Review date: 09/03/2025
9
Thin Crust Perfection with a Beer
I used to write this place off, but they’ve changed their firing process, and it now hits near perfect thin crust slices. It's best enjoyed with a beer from Toro next door.
  • firing process9
  • thin crust slices10
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
A C.
Review date: 05/18/2025
2
Terrible Pizza, Not Authentic NY Style
My experience at this restaurant was quite disappointing, primarily due to the food quality. The pizza was terrible. The crust was poorly made, and on a previous visit, a slice fell apart the moment I picked it up. When I inquired about the sloppy presentation, the staff member claimed it was 'NY Style Pizza. ' However, having lived in New York, I know this was not authentic. It was simply badly made. Consequently, I never returned and would not recommend this place. I suggest trying Seniore's Pizza instead, which is located just down the road.
  • pizza1
  • crust1
  • slice1
Price per Person
  • $21–$30
Visit Type
  • Delivery
Service Type
  • Delivery
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Andy E.
Review date: 04/29/2025
9
Reliable Delivery Pizza & Great Salads
My experience at this restaurant has been consistently positive, especially for delivery pizza. It's some of the best and most reliable in the city, and it has saved me on many late nights. I also found their salads to be great.
  • delivery pizza9
  • salads8
Price per Person
  • $1–$10
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Bryce T.
Review date: 02/10/2025
10
Top-tier food and secret sauce!
My experience at the restaurant was amazing. The food is top-tier, and there's a secret ingredient in the sauce that nobody knows about. The service was rated a 5, and the food was also rated a 5. The atmosphere received a 4. It was a dinner meal with a price per person between $1–10.
  • food10
  • sauce10
  • Service10
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
brookefromearth
Review date: 02/08/2025
9
Late Night Pizza Perfection!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic. I loved that it was open late, which is a huge plus. The food was tasty as can be, and I can honestly say it was some of the best pizza by the slice I've ever had.
  • pizza by the slice10
  • food9
  • open late8
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
B
Review date: 01/18/2025
3
Mediocre Slices, Open Late
My experience at this restaurant was quite mediocre. The slices were priced at $5-$6 each, which I found to be quite expensive for the quality. The only positive aspect of this place is that it is open late.
  • open late7
  • slices2
  • price3
Price per Person
  • $21–$30
Visit Type
  • Regular Visit
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Wait Time
  • Moderate (16–30 min.)
M
Review date: 09/10/2024
9
New Favorite Pizza Spot!
I ordered a half and half XL pizza from here yesterday and it's become my new go-to spot. The pizza took about 25 minutes to make and was perfectly cooked. I'm not typically a pepperoni person, but I was impressed with it on this pizza. I also appreciated that the crust and cheese did not have a sour or play dough flavor, which I often find. An updated photo for the menu would be helpful as the prices have changed; the XL pizza is now $33.
  • pizza9
  • pepperoni8
  • crust and cheese8
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Gavy A.
Review date: 09/04/2024
1
Attempted to scam me!
My experience at this restaurant was that they tried to scam me by charging me the wrong price, seemingly because they thought I was drunk. The service, atmosphere, and food were all rated as 1 out of 5.
  • wrong price1
  • Service1
  • Atmosphere1
Price per Person
  • $11–$20
Visit Type
  • Regular Visit
Group Type
  • Friends
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Lunch
Joshua B.
Review date: 08/12/2024
9
New Favorite Pizza Joint!
Wow! This is my new favorite pizza joint! The slices of pizza are piled high with fresh-quality ingredients. It's a great place for a late-night bite and also offers great AA fellowship on Wednesday nights after meetings at the Peacock Lounge across the street. The service was good and the facility was clean.
  • fresh-quality ingredients10
  • service9
  • facility9

Top Restaurants in

Lou's
9.6
out of 10

12

100%

Supra Dinner Society
9.6
out of 10

150

100%

1904 Street Dogs
9.6
out of 10

73

100%

Taste of India
9.4
out of 10

307

100%