Mustafio's Pizza - Reviews

My experience at this restaurant was amazing, especially for halal pizza. We ordered the pepperoni and chicken pesto pizzas and honestly couldn’t decide which one we liked more. Both were so good, and I know this will be our go-to pizza spot from now on. The server was really sweet, and the prices were great for the quality and portion size. The place itself isn’t fancy and isn’t very well maintained since it’s a small spot, but the pizza completely makes up for it. Plus, they stay open late, which made it the perfect end to our concert night. Loved it!

I have had nothing but good experiences here at the pizza place. Thanks for the great pizza, keep up the good work.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The pizza was absolutely fire! I was also impressed that they accept 'ebt hot food' and are open late late night. The service was a perfect 5/5, the atmosphere was a 5/5, and the food was a 5/5. It's also very affordable, with a price per person of $1–10, and there was no wait time.

I ordered the 14-inch calzone with chicken, bacon, and onion, and it was "crazy plugged. " The staff member mentioned I could save the rest for work the next day, but I ended up eating the whole thing myself. It was that good!

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! The pepperoni and chicken pesto slices were my absolute favorite. I found the food to be cheaper and of overall better quality compared to other places in the area. The service and atmosphere were also rated a perfect 5 out of 5, making for a truly enjoyable visit.

My experience at this restaurant has been consistently positive. I go there all the time because the staff is friendly and the pizza is tasty. The slices are huge, and my favorites are the pepperoni and chicken pesto. They also conveniently accept EBT.

My experience at this hole in the wall pizza corner was excellent. I enjoyed an individual sized pizza, specifically the chicken pesto pizza. The ingredients were fresh, and the taste was memorable. It was also reasonably priced. The atmosphere and service were both rated a perfect 5, and the food also received a 5-star rating. I had no wait time and dined solo.

Outstanding! I'm from outta town and this is by far the best place to eat on a late night. The food was a perfect 5/5, and the service was equally impressive at 5/5. The atmosphere also received a top score of 5. While parking can be somewhat difficult to find, the overall experience was fantastic. It's a very upbeat and kid-friendly spot with indoor dining and no wait time. The price is also very affordable, ranging from $1–10 per person.

I placed an online order for pickup at 7: 20 PM. Upon arrival, I was informed that the food would take an hour or more. The employee stated they couldn't cancel the order, but the owner, who was arriving an hour later, could. I am disappointed that I made the trip and was not notified about the change in pickup time. Edit: Upped it to 3 stars because I received the refund.

My experience at this restaurant was fantastic. The owner is incredibly kind, and the pizza is sincerely great. It's a decent place to hang out, and I consider it the best pizza spot in the neighborhood.