oChef » Pied Piper – San Francisco » Pied Piper – San Francisco – Reviews

Pied Piper - Reviews

2 New Montgomery St, 94104 San Francisco
All reviews at a glance
316

Reviews

71.5%

Satisfaction

69

negative

21

neutral

226

positive

What people say about Pied Piper

Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Blake H.
Review date: 10/02/2025
7
Nice Venue, Decent Service with Rules
My experience at this restaurant was pleasant. The venue itself was nice, and the atmosphere was great, scoring a 5 out of 5. The food was also good, receiving a score of 4 out of 5. However, the service was a bit of a letdown, rated at 3 out of 5. This was primarily due to a peculiar rule of one drink per 30 minutes, with a maximum of four drinks. While we weren't planning on having more, the interaction felt a bit strange.
  • venue9
  • service5
  • atmosphere10
  • drink rule3
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Pat F.
Review date: 09/24/2025
8
Beautiful Room, Pricey Drinks, Eager to Return
What a beautiful room to have a pre-dinner glass of Champagne. The drinks were pricey, but I look forward to returning for a dinner. Happy Birthday Palace Hotel!
  • beautiful room9
  • drinks4
  • pricey4
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Service Type
  • Dine-in
R J.
Review date: 07/03/2025
7
Charming Atmosphere, Mixed Food Experience
My experience at this restaurant was a blend of the old and the new. The old school atmosphere truly gives the place charm and makes up for some of the food inconsistencies. While the oysters were delicious, the grilled cheese and tomato sandwich was not so great. On the other hand, I had the best "Old Fashion" I've had in a long time, and I'm not even a big whiskey drinker. The service was great and attentive. The bar area is a highlight, with amazing art and a decorative bar. Don't miss the historical items in the hallway and the glass atrium.
  • oysters9
  • Old Fashion10
  • old school atmosphere9
  • grilled cheese and tomato3
Price per Person
  • $71–$80
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Louise B.
Review date: 06/30/2025
8
Cozy Atmosphere, Friendly Service, Good Food
My experience at this restaurant was quite pleasant. The atmosphere is described as a cozy, enclosed bar/restaurant vibe, with no windows to look outside. They offer comfortable padded seats and high chairs at high tables, creating a nice, small, cozy feel. There's also a bar with a TV. The food quality is good, though some portions, particularly the mac and cheese balls, could be a bit bigger. The drinks are good, and the staff are very friendly, providing good service. It's important to note that there is inside only seating, with no outside seating available.
  • atmosphere9
  • food quality8
  • portions6
Visit Type
  • Food Exploration
Group Type
  • Couple
Group Size
  • Couple
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Loretta R.
Review date: 04/27/2025
9
Delish Cocktails and Wonderful Service!
My experience at the restaurant was fantastic! We enjoyed delish cocktails and tasty snacks. Our server, Nikki, was the best and provided such a wonderful partnership to our evening. We would come back just for her!
  • cocktails9
  • snacks8
  • Nikki10
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Jonathan G.
Review date: 04/01/2025
7
Service issues overshadow great food
My experience at this restaurant was a mix of excellent food and a very concerning service incident. While the food and atmosphere were rated a perfect 5, the service experience was quite negative. I put my drink down to go to the bathroom, which is directly across the hall, and the server ran after me demanding a credit card. I had no intention of leaving without paying, and this approach to customer service was not appreciated.
  • food10
  • atmosphere10
  • service2
  • server1
  • customer service1
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Meal Type
  • Dinner
Anthony M.
Review date: 01/09/2025
9
Excellent Bar and Food Experience
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic. The bar was beautiful, and the staff were excellent and always on hand. I thoroughly enjoyed the cocktails, which were excellent. We also had food here one evening and really enjoyed anything that we ordered.
  • bar9
  • staff10
  • cocktails9
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Francesco R.
Review date: 12/22/2024
1
Worst Service, Overpriced, Won't Return
My experience at this restaurant was marked by ambiance that was just okay, but the service was the worst I've encountered in my 3 decades in the Bay Area. It was also horribly overpriced. I am not planning to ever return.
  • ambiance4
  • service1
  • price1
Visit Type
  • Casual Outing
Group Type
  • Couple
Group Size
  • Couple
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Bruce D.
Review date: 11/18/2024
9
The Pied Piper: A Wonderful Time in the 90s
My experience at The Pied Piper was truly a wonderful time. It was THE place to be in the 90s. The Happy Hour on Friday was amazing, with great food and a $3 martini. They also had live music, and it was a popular spot for single workers. I even met my wife there!
  • Happy Hour9
  • martini8
  • live music8
Price per Person
  • $41–$50
Visit Type
  • Quick Meal
Service Type
  • Dine-in
Wait Time
  • Long (31+ min.)
Grace W.
Review date: 10/13/2024
2
Slow Service and Poor Food Quality
My experience at this restaurant was largely negative due to significant issues with service and food quality. Initially, we were seated at the bar for five minutes without even receiving drink menus or water, and our first waiter was rude and lazy. We moved to a table where the second waiter was better, but the service of food was still quite slow. The wait was so long that we ended up getting our entree to go. Unfortunately, the quality of the long overdue food was bad, and it was way overpriced relative to the quality.
  • waiter2
  • drink menus1
  • water1

Top Restaurants in

Lou's
9.6
out of 10

12

100%

Supra Dinner Society
9.6
out of 10

150

100%

1904 Street Dogs
9.6
out of 10

73

100%

Taste of India
9.4
out of 10

307

100%