Planning
- Accepts reservations
oChef » Paranormal Pie – Seattle
Paranormal Pie - Seattle
Photo from Paranormal Pie
Paranormal Pie at a glance
Seattle Rainier Beach
- 🍕 Pizzeria
$$
Price per Person $21–$30
mentioned by 31 of the guests
#227 out of 858 places to eat in Seattle
#11 Pizzeria out of 43 in Seattle
Good
8 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
431
Reviews
83.3%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Delicious pizza
- Friendly service
- Good value
Frequently criticized
- Uncomfortable seating
- Order issues
- Specific sides
The restaurant Paranormal Pie, a delightful pizzeria in Seattle’s vibrant Rainier Beach neighborhood, invites you to discover its cozy and casual atmosphere. You’ll find a welcoming spot perfect for a quick bite or a relaxed dinner, offering a unique selection of small plates and satisfying vegetarian options.
It’s a place where you can truly unwind and enjoy quality food.
Overview: Introducting Paranormal Pie
Paranormal Pie offers a compelling experience, particularly for those prioritizing delicious food and attentive service. Many appreciate the family-run feel and the consistently good quality of their main offerings, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.
However, it’s worth noting that the dining environment might not be its strongest suit, with some finding the seating less comfortable or the overall atmosphere a bit understated. While the core experience shines, these aspects could be improved for a more rounded visit.
Good
8
out of 10
431
Reviews
83.3%
Satisfaction
58
negative
14
neutral
359
positive
Paranormal Pie achieves a good overall Restaurant Score of 8, complemented by a strong Customer Satisfaction rate of 83.3%. This positive reception is largely driven by its excellent Food (8.3) and very good Service (7.9), which consistently earn high marks from patrons.
Looking closer, Value (7) is also rated as good, indicating that customers feel they receive fair pricing for their meals. The Ambience (6.6), while not poor, sits in the average range.
These insights are drawn from a substantial 431 customer comments, with 359 positive remarks outweighing 58 negative ones.
What people like
- Delicious pizza
- Friendly, attentive service
- Good value
What people don't like
- Uncomfortable seating
- Occasional order issues
- Disappointing specific sides
If you’re seeking a straightforward, quality meal with friendly interactions, Paranormal Pie is certainly worth considering. Its strong performance in food and service, reflected in a solid Recommendation Score of 8.1, suggests a high likelihood of a positive dining experience.
However, if a polished dining room or a perfect delivery experience are top priorities, you might find some minor drawbacks. For delicious pizza and reliable service, this spot delivers, making it a good choice for a casual, satisfying meal.
Similar Restaurants in Seattle
- Pizzeria
9.2
out of 10
out of 10
93
94.6%
- $$
- Ballard
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
9
out of 10
out of 10
414
92.3%
- $$
- South Lake Union
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.6
out of 10
out of 10
228
89%
- $$
- Fremont
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.6
out of 10
out of 10
237
92.8%
- $$
- Portage Bay
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.4
out of 10
out of 10
587
84.8%
- $$
- Queen Anne
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.4
out of 10
out of 10
417
87.1%
- $$
- Uptown
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Paranormal Pie
Food (8.3 out of 10)
mentioned by 94% of the guests
When it comes to the food, guests are generally thrilled! With a strong score of 8.3 and customer satisfaction at a fantastic 86.8%, it's clear the kitchen is doing something right. Many rave about the delicious pizzas, especially the halal meat choices, praising the excellent crust and fresh ingredients.
Out of 265 comments, a whopping 230 were positive, highlighting a truly enjoyable dining experience. However, not every dish hits the mark, with 24 negative remarks. Some found the sauce tasteless or the crust not quite right.
There were also mentions of bland breadsticks and even soggy spaghetti, suggesting a few items might need a little more attention to detail.
Food
265
Reviews
86%
Satisfaction
24
negative
11
neutral
230
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Delicious halal pizza
- Fresh ingredients
- Excellent crust
What people don't like
- Tasteless sauce
- Soggy spaghetti
- Bland breadsticks
Often praised
- pizzaMy experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I love getting my pizza here because it's always made fast and the people are friendly when I pick up. I personally love the tiramisu cake for dessert as well!
- foodI recently moved to the area and decided to try this restaurant. Since then, I've been coming back multiple times a week because the food is great and the people working here are so friendly. I've become a regular and everything I try is delicious.
- crustThe crust is really good. It’s thin, soft, and the crust is perfectly crunchy.
- pizzaspizzas were a highlight, loaded with fresh, high-quality ingredients
- cheeseplenty of cheese. Absolutely delicious!
- calzonesThe food is consistently great, and they offer so many good vegetarian options, along with fun pizzas like chicken pesto or zataar pie. The calzones are great too! We often pick up a few pizzas from here for get-togethers, and they are always a big hit.
- wingsthe wings and chicken pesto rolls, they were delicious
- baklavaGet some baklava for desert!
- Hawaiian pizzaWe came back like 3 times in one week. We had the deep dish pizza with meat toppings, Hawaiian pizza, Hawaiian with chicken, meat lovers, pepperoni, and chicken pesto. All so good Alhamdulillah.
- deep dishIf you get a pizza make it deep dish
Frequently criticized
- pizzaThe lady who served me was nice, though her English wasn't very good. I found the pizza to be okay, but it was very small, and I felt the price of $12. 95 was too much for it.
- Greek saladGreek salad- pretty disappointing and boring
- Gyro wrapstwo Gyro wrap and it’s really bad
- Tzatziki sauceTzatziki sauce- possibly the worst I have ever had. Very very bad.
- Zaatar pieZaatar pie, which is a spiced cheese pizza that I will pass on
- breadsticksThe breadsticks looked great but were actually pretty bland
- chicken alfredo fettuccinithere was no chicken in there
- crustCould be more crisp and less floppy
- deep dish pieMy experience with this "deep dish" pie was disappointing. While there was plenty of cheese, the sauce was tasteless and the bits of sausage were hard to find.
- gyroordered a gyro, didnt taste fresh
If you're looking for a place with delicious halal pizza and fresh ingredients, this spot is definitely worth a try. Just be aware that some side dishes or non-pizza items might be a bit inconsistent, so stick to their strengths for the best experience.
Service (7.9 out of 10)
mentioned by 73% of the guests
When it comes to service, this spot generally hits the mark! With a 7.9 score, its clear that most diners had a good experience, and a solid 82.3% customer satisfaction backs that up. Based on 93 positive remarks out of 113 total, many praised the "friendly staff, " "fast service, " and overall "kindness" of the team, often noting "attentive service" and quick meal preparation.
However, its not entirely without its bumps. A smaller number of 20 comments pointed to some ordering issues, occasional language barrier challenges, and a few frustrating refund problems. While these instances are less frequent, they suggest that customer service isn't always perfectly smooth for everyone.
Service
113
Reviews
82%
Satisfaction
20
negative
0
neutral
93
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly staff
- Fast service
- Attentive service
What people don't like
- Ordering issues
- Refund problems
- Language barrier
Often praised
- serviceI particularly enjoyed the crispy crust, melty cheese, and generous toppings. The service was exceptional; the staff was friendly, attentive, and always willing to accommodate special requests. For anyone seeking great halal food in a welcoming environment, this place is a must-visit.
- staffI particularly enjoyed the crispy crust, melty cheese, and generous toppings. The service was exceptional; the staff was friendly, attentive, and always willing to accommodate special requests. For anyone seeking great halal food in a welcoming environment, this place is a must-visit.
- ownersI agree the owners are nice. The sauce could be a little more zesty and fresh tasting.
- peoplethe people are courteous and nice
- ServiceService:5
- customer serviceExcellent customer service
- deliveryTake out or delivery via the many food delivery apps
- ownerThe owner kindly set up and cleaned a table for us
- take outTake out or delivery via the many food delivery apps
- 15 minutesready in 15 minutes
Frequently criticized
- customer serviceMy experience at the restaurant was marked by very unprofessional and poor customer service. The lady at the front desk did not seem like a good fit for her role.
- orderorder was not only picked up by a random person
- EnglishHer English wasnt so good
- GrubhubGrubhub, who engages in deceptive business practices
- Orderherothey are refusing to give a refund based on the owner's preference
- businessreporting your business with the department of public health for violating mask laws
- deliveryRegarding delivery, beware of Grubhub
- lady front desklady front desk doesn’t seems to be a good fit
- order deliveryMy experience was that they will cheat you out of your order and not deliver it. Then they will keep your money and tell you that there's no order on your name.
- order on nameMy experience was that they will cheat you out of your order and not deliver it. Then they will keep your money and tell you that there's no order on your name.
Overall, if youre looking for a place with generally friendly and efficient service, youll likely be pleased. Just be aware that a small number of guests have encountered minor hiccups with ordering or specific issues, so keep that in mind.
Ambience (6.6 out of 10)
mentioned by 23% of the guests
When it comes to the vibe, this spot has a bit of a split personality! Many folks really appreciate the welcoming environment and the charm of a family-run place, often describing it as a pleasant hole in the wall with a clean interior. With 17 positive remarks out of 28 total, there's definitely a warm feeling for many, contributing to an average score of 6.6.
However, not everyone is completely won over, as customer satisfaction sits at a mixed 60.7%. Some found the building a bit old, with concerns about the signage and limited, sometimes uncomfortable, seating. These 9 negative observations suggest that while the interior might be welcoming, the exterior and practical aspects could use a little sprucing up.
Ambience
28
Reviews
60%
Satisfaction
9
negative
2
neutral
17
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Welcoming environment
- Family-run charm
- Clean interior
What people don't like
- Limited seating
- Dated exterior
- Poor signage
Often praised
- atmospherevery at home atmosphere
- restaurantClean restaurant and excellent ventilation.
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:4
- PlacePlace is clean
- dining areaThe dining area was clean
- family run pizzeriaA hole-in-the-wall family run pizzeria
- family-ownednice family owned
- family-run placeIt’s a little family-run place
- health ratingExcellent health rating
- hole in the wallSurprising little hole in the wall
Frequently criticized
- seatingNo comfortable seat. A couple of chairs infrastructure of a birdcage facing the window.
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:1
- buildingthe building a bit old
- clean and attractive environmentthis is very important to have a clean and attractive environment
- eating ineating in was not planned
- mask wearingno one inside preparing food or otherwise was wearing a mask
- signageIt's a family-owned pizza place on Rainer Ave S. While the exterior might look a little funky and the signage is not great, don't let that deter you. The Greek style pizza was very good, and the prices are reasonable.
If youre seeking a cozy, unpretentious, family-run spot and dont mind a slightly dated exterior or limited seating, you'll likely feel right at home. However, if modern aesthetics and spacious comfort are high on your list, you might find the ambience a bit of a mixed bag.
Value (7 out of 10)
mentioned by 23% of the guests
When it comes to value, this spot generally hits the mark, earning a 7 score and a solid 76% customer satisfaction. Many folks appreciate the affordable and reasonably priced options, often finding good prices for their meals. With 19 positive remarks out of 25 total, customers frequently praise the value, sometimes even snagging a discount on their first visit.
However, not everyone feels the same, with 5 negative comments highlighting some concerns. A few customers felt the prices could rip you off, especially when trying to build your own custom orders, where costs can quickly escalate. There were also isolated issues regarding orders not being delivered and money kept, which is definitely a red flag.
Value
25
Reviews
76%
Satisfaction
5
negative
1
neutral
19
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Affordable prices
- Great value
- First-visit discounts
What people don't like
- Custom order costs
- Price escalation
- Order fulfillment issues
Often praised
- priceMy experience at this restaurant was quite positive. I enjoyed some pretty good pizza at a very reasonable price. The lady and gentleman who run the place were also very kind.
- pricesgreat prices
- PricesThe Caesar salad is also ultra fresh and good. Prices are right, and I will be back soon. I highly recommend it.
- affordableand affordable!
- cheapI've had real deep dish pizza in Chicago, and this has no resemblance. The only reason it received two stars was because it was fast and relatively cheap. I won't be ordering from here again.
- cheap pricesIt's my favorite pizza place in Seattle. The establishment is a little family-run place with friendly service and relatively cheap prices. The food is consistently great, and they offer so many good vegetarian options, along with fun pizzas like chicken pesto or zataar pie.
- discountgave a discount for the first time visit
- established combosThe sauce could be a little more zesty and fresh tasting. While the price on the established combos is decent, if you build your own, the price will runaway quickly. Stick to the premade choices, as they don't put enough ingredients on to justify $2 per ingredient for a medium.
- good pricesMy experience at Paranormal Pie was fantastic. They serve delicious pizza with good prices. The five star service was exceptional, and my takeout orders were consistently ready in 15 minutes.
- reasonable pricedresonable priced pizza place
Frequently criticized
- build your ownif you build your own the price will runaway quickly
- money keptMy experience was that they will cheat you out of your order and not deliver it. Then they will keep your money and tell you that there's no order on your name.
- pizza12.95 was too much for the pizza
- priceI spent over $46 on just those two items
- rip you offThey will technically rip you off
If youre looking for a good deal, this place often delivers, especially if you stick to their established menu items. Be cautious with custom orders, as the price can jump quickly. Its worth a try for affordable eats, but keep an eye on your bill.
How are the prices at Paranormal Pie?
You’re looking at roughly 21 per person – reported by 31 diners. That puts it in the $21–$30 category. For a Pizzeria, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
While the average lands at 21 $, it’s interesting to see that many diners actually spend a bit less, with a good chunk falling into the $11–$20 bracket. This suggests a nice mix of budget-friendly options and some slightly higher-priced choices.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 31 reviews.
How this Pizzeria stacks up against similar spots in Seattle when it comes to value for money.
Overall, we think the pricing here feels pretty fair for a Pizzeria in Seattle. Youve got options whether youre looking for a quick, affordable slice or something a bit more substantial.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Paranormal Pie
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Quick Meal
Service Type
- Dine-in
9
Great Pizza, Kind Service
My experience at this restaurant was quite positive. I enjoyed some pretty good pizza at a very reasonable price. The lady and gentleman who run the place were also very kind.
- pizza8
- price9
- lady and gentleman9
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
1
Shocking Service and No Halal Info
I contacted the restaurant to inquire about halal options, as this information was not available on their sign or menu. When I asked, the staff member responded with, "what do you like halal or haram" and then abruptly hung up on me. Thankfully, I did not end up eating here.
It was a very surprising and negative experience.
- halal information1
- staff response1
- service1
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
9
Delicious Pizza and Friendly Staff!
My experience at this restaurant was very positive. The staff was incredibly friendly and accommodating. I enjoyed watching them prepare the pizza and breadsticks, which were absolutely delicious!
While the seating is limited, the interior is pleasant and welcoming. I will definitely come again!
- staff10
- pizza and breadsticks10
- interior8
- seating6
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
9
Favorite Pizza Place with Great Options!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I absolutely love the pizza here, and it's great that there are so many other options to choose from as well. The owners are very friendly, which adds to the overall positive atmosphere.
- pizza10
- other options9
- owners10
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
Noise Level
- Quiet
9
Hidden Gem Pizza with Great Value
My experience at this favorite hidden gem pizza spot was exceptional. The bread/crust was outstanding, and the cheese had a perfect melt & chew. The sauce was also very tasty.
I also felt the value was great, which is increasingly important these days.
- bread/crust9
- cheese9
- sauce8
What Paranormal Pie offers
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Crowd
- Family-friendly
- Groups
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Small plates
- Vegetarian options
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Catering
- Dessert
- Dinner
- Seating
- Lunch
Service Options
- No-contact delivery
- Takeout
- Curbside pickup
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Parking
- Free street parking
- Usually plenty of parking
Atmosphere
- Cozy
- Casual
FAQs
Is Paranormal Pie a good choice for families and those needing accessibility?
Absolutely! Paranormal Pie is designed to be good for kids, offering high chairs for your little ones. Additionally, you will find a wheelchair accessible entrance and seating, ensuring a comfortable experience for everyone.
What convenient service and parking options does Paranormal Pie provide?
Paranormal Pie offers a range of flexible service options including no-contact delivery, takeout, curbside pickup, and dine-in. When you visit, you’ll usually find plenty of free street parking available right outside.
How does Paranormal Pie generally rate?
Paranormal Pie receives a good overall score of 8, with customer satisfaction at 83.3%. Its strengths lie in Food (8.3) and Service (7.9), while Value (7) is also good, and Ambience (6.6) is considered average.
What do customers enjoy most about Paranormal Pie's food?
Customers frequently praise the pizza for its crispy crust, generous toppings, and fresh ingredients. Many also appreciate the variety of options, including vegetarian choices and desserts like tiramisu and baklava.
Are there any common complaints about Paranormal Pie?
Some customers have noted issues with the ambience, describing it as less comfortable or dated. There have also been occasional concerns regarding order accuracy or specific side dishes like Greek salad or Tzatziki sauce.