Planning
- Accepts reservations
oChef » Black Magic Pizza – Orlando
Black Magic Pizza - Orlando
Photo from Black Magic Pizza
Black Magic Pizza at a glance
Orlando East Central Park
- 🍕 Pizzeria
$$
Price per Person $21–$30
mentioned by 116 of the guests
#9 out of 163 places to eat in Orlando
#2 Pizzeria out of 14 in Orlando
Excellent
8.8 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
679
Reviews
89.4%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Exceptional pizza
- Great service
- Unique menu
Frequently criticized
- High price
- Service issues
- Parking difficulty
The restaurant Black Magic Pizza is a popular pizzeria nestled in the vibrant East Central Park neighborhood of Orlando. You’ll find a casual and trendy atmosphere perfect for a quick bite, whether you’re planning for dinner or looking for a dessert.
This spot is also good for kids, making it a great choice for family outings. You can easily grab your order to go, as takeout is a convenient service option available here.
Overview: Introducting Black Magic Pizza
Black Magic Pizza offers a compelling experience, primarily driven by its exceptional culinary offerings. Patrons frequently highlight the outstanding quality of their pizza and other unique menu items, often noting the friendly and efficient `staff` who ensure a smooth visit.
It’s a spot where the food truly shines, making it a memorable stop for many. However, some aspects might give you pause.
While the `service` is generally well-regarded, there have been occasional reports of inconsistencies, particularly concerning order accuracy and resolution. The unique `atmosphere` of its location, while charming to some, may not appeal to everyone, and `parking` can sometimes be a challenge.
Excellent
8.8
out of 10
679
Reviews
89.4%
Satisfaction
50
negative
22
neutral
607
positive
Black Magic Pizza earns a solid overall score of `8.8`, reflecting a generally positive customer sentiment. This is further supported by a `89.4%` customer satisfaction rate, indicating that most visitors leave pleased with their experience.
These figures are drawn from a substantial pool of 679 customer remarks, with 607 positive and 50 negative observations. Delving into specifics, the `Food` (9) is clearly a standout, consistently receiving high praise.
`Service` (8.9) also performs exceptionally well, with many appreciating the attentive and quick interactions. The `Ambience` (8.1) is rated as good, though it’s worth noting some mixed opinions on its unique setting.
The primary area for improvement appears to be `Value` (5.5), which falls into the average range, suggesting that some customers find the pricing a bit steep for the portions.
What people like
- Exceptional pizza quality
- Friendly, efficient service
- Unique menu offerings
What people don't like
- Higher price point
- Inconsistent service recovery
- Challenging parking/location
If you prioritize exceptional pizza and a generally positive service experience, Black Magic Pizza is certainly worth considering. The culinary quality is a consistent draw, and the overall customer satisfaction is high, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.
The `Recommendation Score` of `9.1` further reinforces its appeal. However, be mindful of the pricing, as some find it on the higher side for what you receive.
While the unique setting has its charm, it might not be for everyone, and parking can sometimes require a bit of patience. Go for the food, but manage expectations regarding cost and the casual environment.
Similar Restaurants in Orlando
- Pizzeria
9.2
out of 10
out of 10
97
93.8%
- $$
- Lake Nona
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
8.2
out of 10
out of 10
287
82.2%
- $$
- Florida Center
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
6.9
out of 10
out of 10
295
66.8%
- $$
- Wadeview Park
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
6.8
out of 10
out of 10
442
62.9%
- $$
- College Park
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
6.8
out of 10
out of 10
450
63.6%
- $$
- Florida Center
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Pizzeria
6.5
out of 10
out of 10
182
61%
- $$
- Metro West
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Black Magic Pizza
Food (9 out of 10)
mentioned by 98% of the guests
When it comes to the food, youre in for a treat! With an excellent score of 9 and an outstanding customer satisfaction of 92.2%, its clear the culinary experience here is a huge hit. Out of 446 remarks, a whopping 411 praise the delicious pizza, garlic knots, crust, and quality ingredients, making every bite a delight.
However, a small number of 23 comments did mention some areas for improvement. A few found the dough to be soggy or bland, and some noted the food could be greasy or that portions were small for the price. These seem to be isolated incidents rather than a widespread issue.
Food
446
Reviews
92%
Satisfaction
23
negative
12
neutral
411
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Best pizza
- Amazing garlic knots
- High quality ingredients
What people don't like
- Soggy dough
- Bland taste
- Greasy food
Often praised
- pizzaBlack Magic is our favorite pizza place in Orlando! We've gotten something different each time and we're always blown away. When we ordered this past Saturday, the man at the window let us know that he didn't think our pizza looked the best when it came out of the oven, so he prioritized getting us a new one right away and then offered us drinks while we waited.
- foodMy experience at this restaurant has been consistently positive. I often order here for friends or family, and they always love it. The wings are great as well!
- garlic knotsMy girlfriend will tell you that these are the BEST buffalo wings that she has ever had, and my garlic parmesan are so beyond consistent that I never have to worry about being disappointed. Garlic knots are killer, although if you don't have another to share with, I suggest you opt for the "leftovers tomorrow" route, something I struggle with. Four to six garlic knots and a full order of garlic parm wings tends to leave the tummy a bit upset, of course.
- Foodthe mozzarella sticks, buffalo wings and pepperoni pizza were fantastic!
- crustWe stopped by on a Saturday afternoon and grabbed a Jack the Tripper pie and two OG cannolis, and we absolutely devoured them. It was a 100/10 experience; the best Neapolitan pizza I’ve ever had, and the crunch on the crust is just insane. It was so damn good, and we will definitely be back.
- poutinePOUTINE. There are two places to get poutine in central Florida: 1. the cheese curds truck at Fringe that's here for only two weeks a year 2. BLACK MAGIC PIZZA It is the real deal.
- Dr. Pepperonithe Dr. Pepperoni and the Tuscan Leather, and both pizzas were delicious
- sauceThe sauce reminded us of home... smooth, slighty acidic with not too much sweetness
- wingsthese are the BEST buffalo wings that she has ever had
- Hornets Nestthe Hornets Nest and the Dr. Pepperoni and we’re both outstanding
Frequently criticized
- pizzapizza kind of small for the price tag
- FoodFood:2
- cheesethe cheese was very odd. It was almost rubbery
- daily pizza and side specialsmissing their awesome daily pizza and side specials
- doughthe dough was very soggy and soft
- fries on the poutineI wish the fries on the poutine were not seasoned fries.
- garlic knotsThe garlic knots could have used more garlic or the garlic butter spread on the top
- greasyit is very greasy
- hot honey pizzaThere are very few foods that upset my stomach or make me feel ill, but Black Magic's food just does not sit right with me. Their hot honey pizza, I think, is a particular offender: lots of grease mixed with honey and marinara. My girlfriend, however, has never gotten an upset stomach after eating, so this could just be a 'me' problem.
- pepperoni and sausage pizzapizza was extremely spicy with hot peppers
If youre looking for truly exceptional pizza and sides, this place is definitely worth a visit. The overwhelming positive feedback suggests youll likely leave very satisfied, despite a few minor critiques.
Service (8.9 out of 10)
mentioned by 64% of the guests
When it comes to service, this spot truly shines! With an impressive score of 8.9 and a stellar customer satisfaction of 92.9%, its clear guests are consistently delighted. Based on 130 positive remarks, patrons frequently praise the friendly and accommodating staff, highlighting their amazing service and quick service that really takes care of customers.
However, out of 140 total comments, a few experiences (9 to be exact) mention some hiccups. Some guests noted issues with wait times, particularly when placing an order in person, and a default tipping 30% on the app was a point of contention. A couple of instances also mentioned a lack of manager call back' for resolving issues.
Service
140
Reviews
92%
Satisfaction
9
negative
1
neutral
130
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Friendly, amazing staff
- Quick, efficient service
- Accommodating customer care
What people don't like
- Long wait times
- In-person ordering issues
- Manager follow-up lacking
Often praised
- serviceI'm eagerly anticipating their return with regular hours. The pizza is unmatched in Orlando, and the staff were very nice, providing quick service at reasonable prices. I would definitely recommend this place to a friend or any foodie looking for something truly unique in Orlando.
- staffThe pizza was amazing. We tried the Dr Pepperoni and Jack the Tripper, which were recommended by the staff. We also indulged in their OG cannoli and the limited edition cookie butter cannoli.
- ServiceService:5
- peopleOverall, I've never had a bad item on the menu. Service: Cool, nice people. Being a pick-up window, there isn't too much opportunity for conversation, but everyone we've talked to was super chill 👍🏼.
- customer serviceI also want to mention that they had messed up on one of our special requests and noticed the mistake before we got there to pick up. They had already remade it when we arrived and let us take both, which was fantastic customer service! They are only to-go, with a walk-up window and a couple of high-top tables with bar stools.
- ownersBlack Magic owners are nice and considerate.
- online orderingA bonus is that if you're at Whiskey Lou's next door, you can easily pick up your pizza and enjoy it with your drinks. While they are closed on Mondays and Tuesdays, their online ordering is really easy for pickup. They do have a few tables and seats if you prefer to enjoy your pizza on the spot – which is always worth it – but it remains delicious even after traveling.
- TravisTravis did an amazing job
- everyoneI was in town for two nights and it was so good the first night that I went back and ate there for dinner again the next night. Everyone there is super friendly, and the food is always great. Do yourself a favor and go.
- wait timeWait time:Up to 10 min
Frequently criticized
- ServiceService:2
- employeeIt was so spicy that my partner and I couldn’t eat it. When I called back, the employee explained that the pizza had chilies on it and laughed it off, saying, “Well, it’s a free pizza, what do you expect? ” So the first order was wrong, the replacement was wrong, and instead of making it right, I was dismissed.
- managerSave your money and ask for a refund if there’s a mistake, because here’s what happened to me: Back in February, I ordered a pizza and it was missing sausage. I spoke with the manager, Travis, who told me the next pizza would be on them. Last night, I finally used that offer and asked for a simple pepperoni and sausage pizza with regular sauce.
- manager call back” So the first order was wrong, the replacement was wrong, and instead of making it right, I was dismissed. I also asked for a call back from the manager but never received one. Very disappointing experience.
- opening hoursIt's a better option than the chicken place that used to be there. *** update 11/16: Tried to go at 2 pm but they don’t open until 4 pm.
- placing an order in personI'd say it's some of the best pizza I've had in Orlando. While the food was exceptional, I do recommend online ordering as placing an order in person took about 35 minutes. Highly recommend.
- serviceguy says we just sold out of pizza gives me a coupon then tells me have a good night and closed the window
- tipping 30%tipping 30% on the app you order from as a default
- wait30min wait at the window
Overall, the service here is a major highlight, with staff often going above and beyond. While a few minor snags like wait times for in-person orders can occur, the overwhelmingly positive experiences make it well worth a visit. You can generally expect friendly, quick, and attentive care.
Ambience (8.1 out of 10)
mentioned by 37% of the guests
When it comes to the atmosphere, this spot truly shines, boasting a good score of 8.1 and a strong 80.6% customer satisfaction. Patrons consistently praise the vibe and atmosphere, often calling it a great place with a casual, down-home mood. Many love the unique location within Whiskey Lou's, the dough tossing visual, and the great energy that makes for a fun environment, highlighted across 58 positive remarks.
However, a few concerns pop up among the 7 negative opinions. While the overall atmosphere is loved, some find the adjacent bar a bit divey. The main sticking point seems to be parking, which is often described as sparse, limited, or difficult to find.
There are also mentions of the walk-up window being problematic during heavy rain, suggesting a need for better shelter.
Ambience
72
Reviews
80%
Satisfaction
7
negative
7
neutral
58
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Great vibe
- Unique location
- Fun environment
What people don't like
- Limited parking
- Rainy walk-up window
Often praised
- atmosphereIt is located inside of Whiskey Lou's, which is a great dive for cheap, stiff drinks. Personally, I love the atmosphere, but it might not be for everyone. On the other hand, there are a couple of things keeping Black Magic from being my #1 pizza spot.
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- placeI would give it infinite stars, a 10000000/10, and I never want to eat pizza from another restaurant again. God bless the kind souls that created this place.
- locationthe location is good
- parkingParking options:Free parking lot
- vibeLoved the vibe of everyone working the night that we went
- vibesThe white iverson was insane, I'd want it as my death row meal. The service was also great, with Max being so kind and having the greatest vibes. The food, service, and atmosphere all received a perfect 5/5 rating.
- Milkhouse next doorYou could even grab a drink there (Foxtail Coffee is always a hit) or even some ice cream for dessert. I already liked the pick-up window for some reason (maybe I'm more antisocial than I always thought) but having the Milkhouse right next door is perfect for everyone involved. All the businesses in the district get more business by working together here, and it's great to see it work out so well.
- Whiskey Lou'sI cannot think of a single greater place to grab pizza, beer, and wings. It is located inside of Whiskey Lou's, which is a great dive for cheap, stiff drinks. Personally, I love the atmosphere, but it might not be for everyone.
- barthe bar next door has billiards and darts
Frequently criticized
- parkingparking is so limited that you have to slug through ankle high water
- atmospheresituated next to a bar that's kind of a dive
- find parkingSomewhat difficult to find parking
- walk-up windowunfortunately the walk-up window is terrible when it's pouring rain
If youre looking for a lively, unique spot with a great vibe and dont mind a bit of a hunt for parking, this place is definitely worth checking out. The casual atmosphere and fun energy make it a memorable experience, especially if you appreciate its distinct Milk District charm.
Value (5.5 out of 10)
mentioned by 10% of the guests
While the overall score for value is an average 5.5 and customer satisfaction is a poor 38.1%, there are bright spots! Out of 21 opinions, 8 positive ones highlight the fantastic $1 Wing Wednesday as a major win. Many also feel the general prices are fair for the quality, believing its "worth the price" to support this "small business" thats getting recognized.
However, with 11 negative opinions, many customers find the value disappointing. Concerns frequently arise around items being overpriced or small for the price tag, especially for specialty pizzas. Some feel the pricing is pricey and even exploitative, with issues like default high tips contributing to a high total bill that doesn't always feel justified.
Value
21
Reviews
38%
Satisfaction
11
negative
2
neutral
8
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Enjoy Wing Wednesday
- Fair general prices
- Support local business
What people don't like
- Specialty pizzas pricey
- Small portions
- High default tips
Often praised
- pricesI'm eagerly anticipating their return with regular hours. The pizza is unmatched in Orlando, and the staff were very nice, providing quick service at reasonable prices. I would definitely recommend this place to a friend or any foodie looking for something truly unique in Orlando.
- $1 Wing Wednesdaythey do $1 wing Wednesday and it saved me
- Wing WednesdayWe have only had the pizza two times, but loved every slice. As two young adults we try to save our money the best we can, so Wing Wednesday tends to take precedent over the pizza. Overall, I've never had a bad item on the menu.
- hypeIf you love pizza, you've got to try this place. It's worth the price and the hype. We never have any leftovers, and we usually order an extra pizza or two per person.
- priceit’s worth the price
- pricingconsidering that the ingredients were fresh, tasty, and I could see them preparing the cooked toppings from the order window, I think the pricing is fair
- small businessSmall business trying to make it BIG
Frequently criticized
- priceThe pizza was absolutely phenomenal, and the garlic knots were to die for. However, it's definitely on the pricier side, and the portions aren't the biggest for the price. It's located in a small cut-out section of the front of Whiskey Lou's Bar.
- specialty pizzasThe second trouble comes with the prices. I'm contented to pay $20 for a medium-sized pie if it's of superb quality, which is true for Black Magic; however, their specialty pizzas are way, way over-priced. They have inventive and exciting weekly offerings such as the Crab Rangoon pizza, but I'm unwilling to spend upwards of $30 on something that might be bad.
- Milk District demographicMy experience was that the pizza was kind of small for the price tag. It felt like they’re exploiting the Milk District demographic. Additionally, the default 30% tip on the app is concerning and could lead to lost customers.
- business practicesIt felt like black magic pricing, and Dominos would be voodoo in comparison. The only thing that set it apart from another pizza place was the dubious business practices. I'd suggest supporting local businesses instead.
- price tagMy experience was that the pizza was kind of small for the price tag. It felt like they’re exploiting the Milk District demographic.
- priceyI loved that they use sourdough, which made the dough super pillowy soft yet light and crispy. While it does get pretty pricey, you truly are paying for quality and freshness. I'm happy to see that they are getting the recognition and following they deserve.
- single person piepay a 25$ single person pie
- total billOverall, we don't know that it was worth $75.
If youre looking for a great deal, definitely check out their "$1 Wing Wednesday" – its a clear highlight for many. However, be cautious with specialty pizzas and overall pricing, as many find them overpriced and not worth the price tag for the portion size. Its a mixed bag, so choose wisely based on what youre ordering.
How are the prices at Black Magic Pizza?
You’re looking at roughly 22 per person – reported by 116 diners. That puts it in the $21–$30 category. For a Pizzeria, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
While the average is 22, its interesting to see that many guests actually spend a bit less, with the biggest group spending between $11–$20. So, theres a good mix of options!
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 116 reviews.
How this Pizzeria’s value stacks up against similar spots in Orlando.
Overall, we think the pricing feels pretty fair for a Pizzeria, especially with options available across different price points. Its a good spot if youre looking for quality without breaking the bank.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Black Magic Pizza
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Best Pizza in Florida!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I had the Tuscan leather, which was absolutely delicious. This is hands down the best Pizza I've found in Florida so far, rivaling the best NY pizza.
The Service, Atmosphere, and Food all received a perfect 5/5 rating.
- Tuscan leather10
- Pizza10
- NY pizza9
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
10
Unforgettable Pizza Across the Country
Even after moving across the country, I still think about the pizza I’ve had from Black Magic. They’re so good!
- pizza10
Price per Person
- $11–$20
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
Wait Time
- Short (6–15 min.)
9
Best Pizza in a While!
My experience at this restaurant was fantastic! I had the best pizza I've had in awhile. The crust was cooked perfectly, just the way I like it.
The food and atmosphere were both rated a 5 out of 5, and the service was rated a 4. The price per person was between $10–20, and the wait time was up to 10 minutes.
- pizza10
- crust10
- food10
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Absolutely fantastic pizzas!
My experience at the restaurant was absolutely fantastic! We're not sure what it was, but these pizzas have some special ingredients that make them so tasteful. The salami pizza was the best I've ever had!
- pizzas10
- special ingredients10
- salami pizza10
Visit Type
- Regular Visit
9
Consistently Great Pizza!
My experience at this restaurant has been consistently positive. It's the only pizza place I come to on this side of town. The food is always good and always fresh.
I definitely recommend this place to try!
- pizza place9
- food10
- fresh10
What Black Magic Pizza offers
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
Popular for
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Offerings
- Quick bite
Dining options
- Dinner
- Dessert
Service Options
- Takeout
Parking
- Usually somewhat difficult to find a space
- Free street parking
- Free parking lot
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Trendy
FAQs
What parking options are available when you visit Black Magic Pizza?
When you visit Black Magic Pizza, you’ll find several parking options. While it can sometimes be somewhat difficult to find a space, you have access to free street parking and a free parking lot. This makes it convenient for you to stop by.
Is Black Magic Pizza accessible for everyone, and can you make reservations?
Yes, Black Magic Pizza is designed to be accessible, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance and a wheelchair accessible parking lot. Additionally, if you’re planning your visit, you’ll be pleased to know that the restaurant accepts reservations.
What are the standout features of Black Magic Pizza?
Customers consistently praise the exceptional quality of the pizza and other menu items, such as the wings and poutine. The friendly and efficient staff also contribute significantly to a positive dining experience.
Are there any common concerns or drawbacks when visiting Black Magic Pizza?
Some patrons have noted that the pricing can be on the higher side for the portion sizes. Additionally, while the atmosphere is unique, parking can sometimes be limited, and there have been isolated instances of service inconsistencies regarding order accuracy.
How do customers generally rate Black Magic Pizza?
Black Magic Pizza receives a strong overall score of `8.8` with `89.4%` customer satisfaction. The `Food` (9) and `Service` (8.9) are highly rated, while `Ambience` (8.1) is good, and `Value` (5.5) is considered average.