Highlights
- Great dessert
- Great wine list
oChef » Osteria Cotto e Mangiato – San Diego
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato - San Diego
Photo from Osteria Cotto e Mangiato
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato at a glance
San Diego Banker’s Hill
- 🍝 Italian Restaurant
$$
Price per Person $41–$50
mentioned by 96 of the guests
#155 out of 755 places to eat in San Diego
#9 Italian Restaurant out of 19 in San Diego
Excellent
8.2 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
704
Reviews
83.4%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Genuine service
- Authentic food
Frequently criticized
- High prices
- Rushed experience
The restaurant, Osteria Cotto e Mangiato, is an inviting Italian Restaurant nestled in San Diego’s charming Banker’s Hill neighborhood. You’ll discover a truly authentic dining experience here, where every meal feels like a warm embrace.
Patrons consistently rave about the great dessert, making it a must-try after your delicious main course. Whether you’re seeking a cozy dinner or a casual lunch, this spot promises a memorable visit with its delightful ambiance and culinary delights.
Overview: Introducting Osteria Cotto e Mangiato
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato generally offers a pleasant dining experience, often praised for its warm and genuine service and a cozy environment that makes guests feel welcome. Many appreciate the overall atmosphere, making it a comfortable spot for a meal.
While the delicious food is a frequent highlight, some guests have noted concerns regarding expensive prices for certain items and occasionally a rather rushed dining experience, suggesting a need for more consistent pacing.
Excellent
8.2
out of 10
704
Reviews
83.4%
Satisfaction
104
negative
13
neutral
587
positive
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato earns a commendable overall score of 8.2, reflecting a generally positive reception from diners. This is further supported by a strong customer satisfaction rate of 83.4%, indicating that most guests leave content with their visit.
Based on 704 customer comments, with 587 positive remarks against 104 negative ones, the inviting Ambience (8.6) and attentive Service (8.3) stand out. The Food (8.2) also receives high marks, though the Value (5.7) aspect is perceived as more moderate, suggesting some mixed feelings about the price-to-portion ratio.
What people like
- Warm, genuine service
- Cozy, inviting atmosphere
- Delicious, authentic food
What people don't like
- High price point
- Rushed dining experience
- Inconsistent food quality
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato presents a compelling option for those seeking a pleasant Italian meal. With a solid recommendation score of 8.3, it generally delivers on its promise of a welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff.
If you prioritize a charming setting and reliable service, this spot is worth considering. Just be mindful of the pricing, as some find it a bit steep, and specific dishes might not always hit the mark.
Similar Restaurants in San Diego
- Italian Restaurant
9.3
out of 10
out of 10
224
98.7%
- $$
- Point Loma
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
9.2
out of 10
out of 10
449
96.4%
- $$
- Ocean Beach
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
9.1
out of 10
out of 10
118
96.6%
- $$
- Hillcrest
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.7
out of 10
out of 10
749
87.7%
- $$
- Little Italy
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.5
out of 10
out of 10
724
84.5%
- $$
- Normal Heights
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.3
out of 10
out of 10
765
84.2%
- $$
- Banker's Hill
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Osteria Cotto e Mangiato
Food (8.2 out of 10)
mentioned by 97% of the guests
When it comes to the food, this spot generally hits the mark! With a solid score of 8.2 and a customer satisfaction rate of 82.7%, it's clear many diners are leaving happy. Out of 393 comments, 325 rave about the authentic Italian cuisine, homemade pasta, delicious meal, and generous portions.
Expect a flavorful and satisfying experience! However, not every dish is a home run, with 60 comments noting some areas for improvement. Some found certain items bland or lukewarm, suggesting issues with food preparation and a lack of authenticity in a few offerings.
It seems consistency might be a minor challenge, but overall, the positives heavily outweigh the negatives.
Food
393
Reviews
82%
Satisfaction
60
negative
8
neutral
325
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Authentic Italian food
- Homemade pasta
- Generous portions
What people don't like
- Bland, unseasoned food
- Lukewarm dishes
- Lack of authenticity
Often praised
- foodI discovered this gem while walking through downtown San Diego. My experience was fantastic, starting with the amazing food and service. I opted for the 3-course meal deal, which offered incredible value for the taste and portion size.
- tiramisuWe tried a variety of dishes, and my favorites were the tortellini Emiliani, eggplant roll alla palermitana, and Artichokes Alla Romana. The desserts, including cannoli, tiramisu, and limoncello cake, were also a highlight. We also enjoyed the meat lovers flatbread and garlic bread.
- Italian foodpersonally am very picky when it comes to Italian food, it is really really good
- pastaAlthough I don't typically love Italian food or pasta because I enjoy making it at home, we decided to try it since it was right across the street from our hotel. I am so happy we did because the Cacio e Pepe was some of the best pasta I have ever had – it was creamy, flavorful, and the portion sizes were great. We also had the garlic bread and I would highly recommend it; it was delicious.
- FoodFood:5
- lasagnaAnd the atmosphere was calm and fresh, perfect for today's weather. We ordered the dishes shown: crispy shrimp, lasagna in a rich tomato sauce, and desserts that were soft and very precise in flavor, not overly sweet for my personal taste. I highly recommend you visit and form your own opinion.
- wineBrianna really know her wine and help me find the perfect one
- Caesar saladThe salad came with satisfyingly large shavings of savoury parmesan
- dessertsdesserts that were soft and very precise in flavor, not overly sweet
- garlic breadI am so happy we did because the Cacio e Pepe was some of the best pasta I have ever had – it was creamy, flavorful, and the portion sizes were great. We also had the garlic bread and I would highly recommend it; it was delicious. Aside from the outstanding food, our server, Isa, was lovely.
Frequently criticized
- Carbonarawe have chicken alfredo and carbonara ordered and both was the same sauce.
- carbonarathe carbonara is pasta with alfredo sauce, an egg yolk, and bacon bits -- even worse is that it came out cold
- focacciathe focaccia isn't actually focaccia but seems to be cut up ciabatta, which was disappointing
- foodOn the positive side, the service and atmosphere were excellent, both receiving a 5/5 rating. However, the food was not up to par, and the way my leftovers were handled was frankly crazy.
- lasagnaThe lasagna and fettuccine Alfredo was served 3 minutes after ordering, so it was clearly pre-prepared and just warmed up, as it was lukewarm upon arrival.
- Chicken Alfredowe have chicken alfredo and carbonara ordered and both was the same sauce.
- Chicken MarsalaThe chicken Marsala had way too much cream
- Fetacine AlfredoThe pasta tasted like it came straight out of a bargain Walmart container—completely flavorless and lacking any authenticity. Don't order the Pasta Primavera or the Fetacine Alfredo, both were void of flavor or any kind of seasoning. For the prices they charge, I expected something far superior.
- FoodThe food was bad!
- Italian foodFrom Italian food this is very far away.
If youre craving authentic Italian flavors and generous servings, this place is definitely worth a visit. While a few dishes might miss the mark, the overall consensus points to a delicious and satisfying meal that youll likely enjoy.
Service (8.3 out of 10)
mentioned by 88% of the guests
When it comes to service, this spot generally hits the mark with a good score of 8.3 and a good customer satisfaction rating of 82.7%. Many guests, 158 out of 191 remarks, rave about the attentive and friendly staff, quick service, and amazing service from specific servers like Isa and Felix, often highlighting their recommendations and overall hospitality. However, not every experience is perfect, with 30 negative comments pointing to some slow service and long wait times for seating or paying.
A few guests also mentioned less positive owner interactions or feeling rushed during their dining experience, suggesting some inconsistencies.
Service
191
Reviews
82%
Satisfaction
30
negative
3
neutral
158
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Attentive, friendly staff
- Quick, efficient service
- Helpful recommendations
What people don't like
- Long wait times
- Rushed by owner
- Inconsistent service
Often praised
- serviceWe savored the Frittura Mista, which was perfectly crispy, the Fettuccine Alfredo e Pollo with its perfectly creamy sauce, and a delicious flatbread topped with prosciutto and assorted meats. The service was warm and genuine, the ambiance was relaxed yet elegant, and the flavors were truly authentic. A big thank you to Andrea Provino and the team for a memorable experience.
- staffIf you're up for dessert, the Limoncello was my favorite! The staff are very helpful as well.
- ServiceService & atmosphere was good
- ownerAndrea the owner for making each of our visits truly memorable
- IsaIsa was so wonderful. Her sweet personality made the whole dining experience amazing.
- experienceCouldn’t have asked for a better experience
- great serviceIsa took care of us at the last minute and provided great service. We had a delicious meal in a cute spot!
- recommendationsHe was unbelievably attentive, managing the entire floor as the sole server for the night. Felix struck the perfect balance of being present without hovering, and his recommendations were spot on. He made us feel welcome and well taken care of from start to finish.
- serverParking was great and there was no wait, nor was it crowded. We were seated quickly and the server was so kind. He recommended the Prosciutto Bruschetta as an appetizer, which was so good.
- wait timeWe experienced no wait time
Frequently criticized
- serviceThe service was abrupt without follow up.
- owner95, representing a 43% price difference. The owner refused to refund the difference and directed me to contact Toast, despite the restaurant making the substitution themselves. This experience was not just poor service; it felt like dishonesty.
- wait timeover 40min between time of ordering and our food being delivered
- closing timeShe said they closed at 9:00 PM
- consistent serviceand consistent service
- dining experienceFrom the moment we were seated, the waiter seemed more interested in turning tables quickly than giving us a pleasant dining experience. Orders were rushed, and there was no sense of hospitality. The food was the biggest disappointment.
- dishonestyit’s dishonesty
- employeesThe employees ignored me
- experienceI didn’t argue with her about their times posted online and at the entrance of the restaurant. I live on Cortez Hill, and I’m disappointed by the experience. I ended up eating at home.
- guestsWhat would have been an overall really nice dining experience turned into a total disappointment. Can’t believe an owner thinks that’s a good idea to usher out his guests like that. But again, shoutout our server Lydia!
Overall, the service here is largely a strong point, making it worth a visit if you value attentive and friendly staff. Just be prepared for the possibility of occasional wait times or less consistent experiences, especially during busy periods.
Ambience (8.6 out of 10)
mentioned by 57% of the guests
The ambience here is truly a standout, scoring a 8.6 and boasting an excellent customer satisfaction of 93.1%. With 94 positive comments out of 101, guests consistently praise the cozy atmosphere, outdoor seating, and Italian music, often noting its "dog friendly" and feels like an authentic Italian experience. Its a charming, welcoming spot perfect for a relaxing meal.
However, a few of the 5 negative comments mention parking can be somewhat difficult to find. There was also an instance where a customer felt rushed to give up their table, which can certainly detract from an otherwise pleasant dining experience.
Ambience
101
Reviews
93%
Satisfaction
5
negative
2
neutral
94
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Cozy, welcoming vibe
- Lovely outdoor seating
- Authentic Italian music
What people don't like
- Parking can be tricky
- Rushed table turnover
Often praised
- atmosphereFirst time here from Arizona and all I have to say is: Best atmosphere! Best service and the food is DELICIOUS!
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- ambiancethe food, and the ambiance were all amazing
- patioamazing dinner out on the patio
- vibesIf Emiru and ExtraEmily say it’s delicious, it is! I highly recommend coming here for the great vibes and wonderful service.
- environmentThe environment is so cute and cozy
- locationThe Italian food was authentic and absolutely delicious; every dish tasted homemade with real care. The atmosphere of the restaurant is warm and inviting, and the location is perfect. I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a genuine Italian dining experience!
- musicThe dinner was very well done and served very quickly by a nice and helpful staff member named Isa. I really enjoyed the climate there, with the Italian discretely player music and the overall atmosphere. Thank you!
- outdoor seatingthe outdoor seating is lovely
- restaurantThis is a gem of a restaurant
Frequently criticized
- conceptmakes the concept confusing
- dishessome of the dishes were dirty
- parkingsomewhat difficult to find parking
- reviewsThe reviews here are overrated
- tableAt this point, we had only been at the restaurant for an hour. He then proceeded to tell us that if we didn’t want anything else, then he would bring us the check because he had a lot of people waiting that didn’t want to sit outside, so he needed our table (and he wasn’t exactly nice about telling us that either). Um, what?
If you're looking for a restaurant with a fantastic, welcoming atmosphere, this place is definitely worth trying. The charming decor, lovely outdoor spaces, and authentic music create a truly enjoyable dining experience, though you might want to plan ahead for parking.
Value (5.7 out of 10)
mentioned by 12% of the guests
When it comes to value, this place offers some compelling reasons to visit, with 10 positive remarks out of 19 total. Many diners rave about the rewards program, 3 course meal deal, and finding a good deal on the full menu, often citing excellent value for money for the portions. The overall score for value is an average 5.7, suggesting a decent, if not outstanding, offering.
However, its not without its drawbacks, as 9 negative comments highlight. Some guests found the experience expensive, noting a significant price difference and even feeling taken advantage of when presented with the bill. Customer satisfaction for value stands at a mixed 52.6%, indicating that while some find great deals, others feel the prices dont quite match up.
Value
19
Reviews
52%
Satisfaction
9
negative
0
neutral
10
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Rewards program benefits
- Meal deal value
- Generous portions
What people don't like
- Can be expensive
- Price discrepancies
- Rushed billing process
Often praised
- pricesThe prices are well worth the portion size
- 3 course meal dealwhat a value for the taste and portion size
- Great dealGreat deal
- full menuThe full menu at 40$ is a really good deal
- good dealA special thank you to Isa, my waitress, who was incredibly kind and efficient. The full menu for $40 is a really good deal because the food is both delicious and copious. Bravo!
- price pointGreat price point for the portions and quality
- rewards programAlso has great rewards program!
- street parkingplenty of metered street parking. We were there on a Sunday, so there was no charge.
- value for moneyNo complaints for value
Frequently criticized
- billOur bill was $46 for two glasses of an unknown red blend and two tiny pieces of bruschetta.
- pricesDon't order the Pasta Primavera or the Fetacine Alfredo, both were void of flavor or any kind of seasoning. For the prices they charge, I expected something far superior. The cocktails were another miss.
- checkAt this point, we had only been at the restaurant for an hour. He then proceeded to tell us that if we didn’t want anything else, then he would bring us the check because he had a lot of people waiting that didn’t want to sit outside, so he needed our table (and he wasn’t exactly nice about telling us that either). Um, what?
- expensivethe place is expensive
- full priceworked fine to charge us full price
- price differencea 43% price difference
- taken advantage offelt like we were taken advantage of
If youre after specific deals or their rewards program, youll likely find good value here. However, be aware that regular menu prices can feel steep, and some guests have had less-than-ideal billing experiences. It's a mixed bag, so consider your choices carefully.
How are the prices at Osteria Cotto e Mangiato?
On average, you’ll spend around $45 per person – from 96 guests. That puts the restaurant in the $41–$50 category. For an Italian Restaurant, that’s comfortably mid-range, maybe a touch above.
Looking at what people actually spend, we see a nice mix. While the average is $45, a good number of diners find options in the $21–$30 range, and there’s also a solid group spending in the $41–$50 bracket. So, prices are spread out, offering choices for different budgets.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 96 reviews.
How this Italian Restaurant’s value stacks up against similar spots in San Diego.
Overall, we think the pricing feels pretty fair for an Italian Restaurant, offering a good range of options for different budgets.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Osteria Cotto e Mangiato
Price per Person
- $21–$30
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Lunch
Wait Time
- Long (31+ min.)
2
Confusing Concept, Slow Service, Poor Food
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato, located just a block from my residence, has undergone several name changes over the past four years, shifting from Italian to Mexican and now back to Italian. Curiously, the brunch menu still heavily features Mexican dishes, creating a confusing concept. While the waiter was kind, the service was exceptionally slow, requiring significant patience.
It took approximately 20 minutes for a single cappuccino and about 30 minutes for our food, a meatball sandwich and mole enchiladas. We later discovered from the waitress that our order had been forgotten, despite being the only customers at noon. The cappuccino itself was quite good, but unfortunately, everything else was disappointing.
The meatballs seemed microwaved, with inconsistent temperatures. The mole enchiladas were unimpressive, tasting like a pre-made sauce on a chicken tortilla. The accompanying potatoes were undercooked, and the water had a strange, dusty aftertaste, suggesting a filter would be beneficial.
Despite giving this location multiple chances with each rebranding, it consistently struggles with fresh food and reliable service. Each visit presents the same issues: microwaved or undercooked food and extremely slow service. Hopefully, future iterations of this establishment will improve the food and execution.
- waiter7
- cappuccino8
- concept2
- service1
- patience2
Visit Type
- Regular Visit
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Amazing Food and Service!
My experience at this restaurant was truly amazing! The food was incredible, and we will definitely eat here whenever we're in town. The waitress was so sweet and attentive, contributing to a wonderful overall experience.
We really enjoyed everything about our time here.
- food10
- waitress10
- experience10
Price per Person
- $61–$70
Visit Type
- Special Occasion
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
10
Amazing Christmas Dinner with Excellent Service
My experience at this restaurant for Christmas dinner was absolutely amazing. We were greeted instantly by our server, Diego, who was incredible throughout our entire meal. The holiday prefix menu did not disappoint, with the bruschetta and meatballs as appetizers being fabulous.
For our main courses, we enjoyed the lobster and shrimp ravioli and the crab-stuffed salmon, both of which are highly recommended. We will definitely return on our next visit to the city.
- Diego10
- prefix menu9
- bruschetta and meatballs9
Price per Person
- $31–$40
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
10
Authentic Italian Food and Wonderful Service
My experience at this restaurant was absolutely amazing! The food tasted just like authentic dishes from Italy, and the service was wonderful. I highly recommend this restaurant.
- food10
- service10
Visit Type
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Absolutely Delectable Experience!
Oh my goodness. Every single bite was delectable. I cannot say enough good things about this place.
I highly recommend the zucchini blossoms, gnocchi, lasagna, tiramisu, and the crème brûlée. Do your tastebuds a favor and eat here.
- zucchini blossoms10
- gnocchi10
- lasagna10
What Osteria Cotto e Mangiato offers
Planning
- Accepts reservations
- Dinner reservations recommended
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
Crowd
- Transgender safespace
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Family-friendly
- Groups
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
Popular for
- Dinner
- Lunch
- Solo dining
Amenities
- Restroom
Offerings
- Happy hour drinks
- Wine
- Coffee
- Beer
- Small plates
- Cocktails
- Alcohol
Dining options
- Brunch
- Table service
- Dessert
- Dinner
- Seating
- Lunch
Service Options
- Outdoor seating
- Dine-in
- Takeout
- Delivery
Pets
- Dogs allowed
Parking
- Free street parking
- Usually plenty of parking
- Paid street parking
Atmosphere
- Romantic
- Cozy
- Casual
FAQs
What dining options and services does Osteria Cotto e Mangiato offer?
At Osteria Cotto e Mangiato, you can enjoy a variety of dining options including brunch, lunch, and dinner with comfortable table seating. They also provide convenient services like takeout and delivery. For those who prefer dining al fresco, outdoor seating is available, and you can even bring your dog along to enjoy the patio.
Is Osteria Cotto e Mangiato accessible and what are the parking options?
Yes, Osteria Cotto e Mangiato is fully wheelchair accessible, including the entrance, parking lot, seating, and restrooms, ensuring a comfortable visit for everyone. When it comes to parking, you’ll find both free and paid street parking options, with usually plenty of spots available in the vicinity.
What is the overall customer sentiment for Osteria Cotto e Mangiato?
Osteria Cotto e Mangiato holds a strong overall score of 8.2 with 83.4% customer satisfaction. Diners particularly praise the Ambience (8.6), Service (8.3), and Food (8.2), though Value (5.7) is seen as average.
What do customers appreciate most about the dining experience?
Guests frequently highlight the restaurant’s cozy environment, warm and genuine service, and the overall quality of its Italian dishes, often noting the generous portions and authentic flavors.
Are there any common concerns among diners?
Some patrons have expressed concerns about the prices being on the higher side and occasional reports of a rushed dining experience or inconsistent quality for certain menu items like pasta dishes.