Highlights
- Great dessert
- Great wine list
oChef » Collina – San Francisco
Collina - San Francisco
1550 Hyde St, 94109 San Francisco
8.8
von 10
von 10
Photo from Collina
Collina at a glance
San Francisco Nob Hill
- 🍝 Italian Restaurant
€€€€€
Price per Person 61 – 70 €
mentioned by 50 of the guests
#43 von 500 Lokalen in San Francisco
#1 Italian Restaurant von 23 in San Francisco
Excellent
8.8 out of 10
Food
Service
Ambience
Value
421
Reviews
91.9%
Satisfaction
Often praised
- Great Service
- Tasty Food
- Cozy Vibe
Frequently criticized
- Loud Environment
- Pricey Experience
- Narrow Choices
The Italian restaurant Collina invites you to experience a truly memorable dining journey in the heart of San Francisco’s charming Nob Hill neighborhood. You’ll discover a romantic and cozy atmosphere perfect for an intimate dinner or a special occasion.
Known for its great dessert, Collina also boasts an impressive wine list to complement your meal. Whether you’re seeking organic dishes or delightful small plates, you’ll find a thoughtfully curated menu designed to please your palate.
Overview: Introducting Collina
Collina offers a charming and intimate dining experience, often described as a cozy restaurant with a wonderful atmosphere. Guests frequently praise the attentive service, which contributes significantly to a pleasant visit.
However, some have noted that the noise level can be quite high, making quiet conversation a challenge. While the culinary offerings receive strong positive feedback, particularly for dishes like the lasagnette and raviolo, a few diners felt the overall food experience didn’t quite meet expectations or found the menu lacked variety.
The restaurant generally delivers a solid experience, balancing its strengths with a few areas for improvement.
Excellent
8.8 von 10
421
Reviews
91.9%
Satisfaction
17
negative
17
neutral
387
positive
Overall, Collina earns a strong 8.8 on its restaurant score, reflecting a generally positive dining experience. This aligns well with an impressive 91.9% customer satisfaction rate, indicating that most guests leave pleased.
These figures are drawn from a substantial 421 customer remarks, with 387 positive observations outweighing just 17 negative ones. Diving deeper, the Service stands out with an excellent score (9.3), frequently praised for its attentiveness.
The Food also performs exceptionally well (8.7), often highlighted as a key draw. The restaurant’s Ambience (8.8) contributes significantly to the positive experience, though some find it a bit lively.
However, Value (6.2) is perceived as more average, suggesting that while the quality is there, the pricing might be a consideration for some.
What people like
- Attentive Service
- Quality Dishes
- Intimate Setting
What people don't like
- High Noise Level
- Value Concerns
- Limited Menu
Collina comes with a strong recommendation score of 9, suggesting it’s a place many guests would happily revisit. If you’re seeking a restaurant with excellent service and well-prepared Italian dishes in a cozy, intimate setting, it’s certainly worth considering for your next meal out.
However, be mindful of the potentially lively atmosphere and that the value proposition might not appeal to everyone. If a quiet, budget-friendly evening with extensive menu options is your priority, you might want to explore other choices.
Otherwise, Collina offers a delightful experience.
Ähnliche Restaurants in San Francisco
- Italian Restaurant
8.8
von 10
von 10
442
91%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.7
von 10
von 10
353
91.5%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.5
von 10
von 10
139
87.8%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.4
von 10
von 10
520
85.4%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.4
von 10
von 10
325
85.5%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
- Italian Restaurant
8.2
von 10
von 10
621
83.4%
- Food
- Service
- Ambience
Verdict: Our expert take on Collina
Food (8.7 von 10)
mentioned by 99% of the guests
When it comes to the food, this spot truly shines! With an impressive score of 8.7 and an excellent customer satisfaction rate of 90.9%, diners are consistently delighted. Out of 264 comments, a whopping 240 rave about the delicious handmade pasta, exceptional lasagnette, and perfectly crafted arancini, often praising the memorable tiramisu.
However, a few voices, 9 to be exact, noted some areas for improvement. Concerns included dishes being a bit too oily, a perceived lack of creativity in the menu, and some ingredients not tasting as fresh as expected. While these are minor points, they're worth considering for a truly perfect meal.
Food
264
Reviews
90%
Satisfcation
9
negative
15
neutral
240
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Handmade pasta
- Delicious lasagnette
- Exceptional tiramisu
What people don't like
- Oily dishes
- Limited creativity
- Not fresh ingredients
Often praised
- foodMy experience at this restaurant was wonderful! The place is cute and unfussy, offering great food and service. I particularly enjoyed the seared octopus, which literally melts in your mouth.
- lasagnettelike the 14-layer lasagnette and buttery raviolo al uovo, are standout dishes
- spaghettinispaghettini has slight hint of chilli & works well if you are garlic or onion intolerant
- lasagnaThe food truly punches above its weight for a neighborhood spot. Almost every table seemed to be ordering the spaghetti with tomato sauce or the lasagna, which were both delicious. However, the service was quite slow during my visit.
- aranciniFor instance, when splitting a dish among three people, we were only provided with two pieces of bread, which felt like a lapse in etiquette for a semi-fancy Italian establishment. The spaghetti noodles were perfectly al dente, and I very much enjoyed the arancini, though the pieces were smaller than expected. The tiramisu was just okay, described as nice and light.
- chickenthe chicken were all fabulous
- focacciafocaccia and arrancini as appetizers and both were excellent
- ravioloAs a visitor from out of town, I wasn’t sure what to expect, but I was blown away by both the quality of the food and the excellent service. I ordered the chicory salad, arancini balls (the charred scallion aioli is to die for!), and, of course, the famous raviolo—a true treat with its decadent brown butter sauce. I only wish I’d saved room for dessert!
- scallopsWe had... scallops... Very tasty
- tiramisusurprised us with tiramisu to celebrate a birthday
Frequently criticized
- foodmost of the food did not taste all that good
- Italian foodthis menu has nothing to do with Italian food.
- expectationsMy experience at the restaurant was overall solid, though it ultimately fell a bit short of my expectations. I found the lasagna to be good, but not as exceptional as I had hoped.
- flavorsthe flavors did not come together
- gnocchi dishthe gnocchi dish was the disappointment
- menuThe menu lacks of creativity and variety
- musselsthe ones in the dish I tried weren't fresh tasting
- shelled beansthe shelled beans that were recommended to accompany them were very disappointing
If youre looking for a place where the food is consistently excellent and leaves a lasting impression, this restaurant is definitely worth trying. Expect standout Italian classics and dont let a few minor critiques deter you from a truly delicious experience.
Service (9.3 von 10)
mentioned by 90% of the guests
The service here is truly outstanding, boasting an excellent score of 9.3 and a fantastic customer satisfaction rate of 96.7%. Guests consistently praise the attentive service, friendly staff, and overall hospitality, making for an excellent experience in 88 out of 91 comments. While overwhelmingly positive, a few guests noted minor issues.
There were 3 comments mentioning service being kinda slow or concerns about perceived preferential treatment, though these seem to be isolated incidents rather than a widespread problem.
Service
91
Reviews
96%
Satisfcation
3
negative
0
neutral
88
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Attentive, friendly staff
- Exceptional hospitality
- Personalized attention
What people don't like
- Service can be slow
- Perceived unfair priority
Often praised
- serviceMy experience at this restaurant was wonderful! The service was excellent, and it was a pleasure meeting the GM, Danny, who clearly genuinely loved the neighborhood and business. The environment is small and cozy, making it perfect for a date night.
- staffThe space is intimate and elegantly cozy, and the kitchen runs amazingly smooth to deliver a great experience. It's such a bonus when the staff adds to the enjoyment by being attentive and super cool - what a gift!
- serverour server, Cayley (sp?) for her patience and fun, warm professionalism
- ServiceService:5
- waiterour waiter - didn’t get his name but he was so attentive, kind, and generous
- AbrahamAbraham took amazing care of us! So professional and friendly!
- Attentive serviceAttentive service and authentic flavors
- GM, Dannymeeting the GM, Danny, who genuinely loved
- Great serviceGreat service wine and food!
- Michelin star worthy serviceMichelin star worthy service.
Frequently criticized
- breadthey only served us 2 "pieces" of bread
- host's wife and kidshost's wife and kids stopped to eat at the bar and clearly had their ticket pushed to the front of the line
- serviceService is kinda slow
If you're looking for a place where the staff goes above and beyond, this is it! The service is consistently praised for being attentive and friendly, ensuring a wonderful dining experience. You can expect top-notch hospitality here.
Ambience (8.8 von 10)
mentioned by 70% of the guests
The ambience here truly shines, earning a fantastic score of 8.8 and an excellent customer satisfaction of 93.3%. With 56 positive remarks out of 60 total, guests consistently praise the atmosphere, describing it as a cozy restaurant with a romantic setting and intimate space. Many found it to have a warm, inviting feel, perfect for a special evening or a relaxed neighborhood experience.
However, a few of the 60 comments did point out some drawbacks. The main concern revolved around the noise level, with 3 negative opinions noting it could be very loud and not ideal for a quiet conversation. While these instances were rare, its something to consider if youre seeking absolute tranquility.
Ambience
60
Reviews
93%
Satisfcation
3
negative
1
neutral
56
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Cozy, intimate vibe
- Romantic setting
- Warm atmosphere
What people don't like
- Loud noise level
Often praised
- atmosphereThis restaurant is a true testament of what feeling at home and tasting nonna's secret recipes is like. The atmosphere is small, quaint, and humble. The minimal table count and intimate setting makes it feel special to be there.
- AtmosphereAtmosphere:5
- restaurantMy wife and I were fortunate to secure a last-minute table at this beautiful, cozy restaurant. I had heard about it, especially the fabulous 48 layer lasagnette.
- environmentSmall, cozy environment
- placeOur server, Victoria, was the best; our pasta was divine, the wine delish, and the service top-notch. I highly recommend Collina if you're seeking a small, cozy, neighborhood-friendly place for a weeknight dinner or a special night out.
- Cozy restaurantCozy restaurant in Russian Hill.
- ambiancethe spot is cute, small
- ambiencewonderful, quiet but enjoyable ambience
- cozy restaurantThis is a cozy restaurant
- cute restaurantSuch a cute restaurant
Frequently criticized
- conversationnot the place for a quiet conversation
- noise levelNoise level: Very loud, hard to hear
- restaurantcrowded and noisy in the restaurant
If youre looking for a charming, intimate, and often romantic spot with a lively buzz, this place is definitely worth a visit. However, if a quiet, hushed dinner is your top priority, you might find the noise level a bit much. Its perfect for a cozy date night or a friendly gathering where conversation can be a bit more spirited.
Value (6.2 von 10)
mentioned by 9% of the guests
When it comes to value, many diners found the experience quite pleasing! Guests raved about the extremely good quality for the prices paid, often mentioning very reasonable prices overall. There was particular delight around a lovely three-course meal that offered fantastic value, showing that the restaurant can certainly deliver on affordable options.
However, not everyone felt the same way. Some found certain dishes to be quite pricy, with a couple of folks feeling the price was simply too high for what they received. With a score of 6.2, the value here is average, and customer satisfaction sits at a rather mixed 50%.
This suggests that while some find it a steal, others might feel a bit of a pinch, based on 6 total remarks.
Value
6
Reviews
50%
Satisfcation
2
negative
1
neutral
3
positive
Rating distribution
What people like
- Good value for quality
- Reasonable prices
- Affordable three-course meal
What people don't like
- Dishes are pricy
- Price too high
Often praised
- pricesThe prices I paid were extremely good for the quality of food
- three course mealTHIS LOVELY THREE COURSE MEAL ONLY COST $50
Frequently criticized
- pricethe price was way too high for what it was
If youre looking for a good deal, especially on a set menu, you might find some real gems here. However, be mindful that individual dishes could lean towards the pricier side, so its worth checking the menu carefully before you commit.
Wie sind die Preise pro Gast bei Collina?
You’re looking at roughly 69 per person – reported by 50 diners. That puts it in the 61 – 70 € category. For an Italian Restaurant in San Francisco, it’s comfortably mid-range: not a steal, but not bank-breaking either.
Looking at what others spend, prices are quite spread out. While many diners spend in this 61 – 70 € range, there’s also a significant group enjoying more premium experiences, with spending often going above 80 €, suggesting a mix of offerings from mid-range to higher-end.
Here’s a quick look at what guests spend per person, based on the latest 50 reviews.
How this restaurant’s value stacks up against similar spots in San Francisco.
For an Italian restaurant in San Francisco, where dining out can be quite an investment, we think 69 per person feels fair for a quality experience. Its a good spot if youre looking for something a bit special without going all out.
Customer Reviews: what people think about Collina
Price per Person
- 41 - 50 €
Service Intent
- Food Exploration
Service Type
- Dine-in
Wait Time
- Immediate (0–5 min.)
Noise Level
- Quiet
10
Cozy Italian Gem with Incredible Food
My experience at this Italian restaurant was truly wonderful. I was walking by and noticed its cozy atmosphere, which prompted me to save it for a future visit. I was not disappointed! The food was incredible, and the overall experience was enhanced by the atmosphere and service, both of which I rated a perfect 5. The noise level was quiet, making it easy to talk. I will definitely be returning!
- food10
- atmosphere10
- service10
Service Intent
- Casual Outing
Service Type
- Dine-in
10
Fantastic Food, Service, and Atmosphere!
My experience at this restaurant was absolutely fantastic. The food was delicious, especially the mussels. The atmosphere was wonderful, and the staff were very attentive. I particularly appreciated the owner's warmth and how they made everyone feel so welcome. I would highly recommend this place!
- food10
- atmosphere10
- staff10
Service Intent
- Tourist Experience
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
10
Highly Recommend This Gem!
My husband and I visited this restaurant while out of town and we absolutely LOVED it. The scallops were incredible, and the pasta was so delicious. We also really loved the dessert. Everyone was so friendly and attentive, and the inside of the restaurant is well decorated.
- scallops10
- pasta9
- dessert9
Price per Person
- 41 - 50 €
Service Intent
- Food Exploration
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
Wait Time
- Short (6–15 min.)
Noise Level
- Loud
6
Mixed Feelings: Good Scallops, Service Lapses
My experience at this restaurant was a mixed bag. While some dishes were excellent, like the succulent scallop dish with its wonderful sauce, others fell short. The mussels I tried did not taste fresh. Service, while generally attentive (rated 4/5), had some notable oversights. For instance, when splitting a dish among three people, we were only provided with two pieces of bread, which felt like a lapse in etiquette for a semi-fancy Italian establishment. The spaghetti noodles were perfectly al dente, and I very much enjoyed the arancini, though the pieces were smaller than expected. The tiramisu was just okay, described as nice and light. The seasonal fig salad with lemon cucumber was pretty good and seasoned nicely. The noise level was very loud, making conversation difficult. If I lived in the neighborhood, I'd likely recommend this place, but it's not worth going out of my way for.
- scallop dish9
- sauce9
- seasonal fig salad7
- mussels2
- bread3
- noise level2
Price per Person
- 41 - 50 €
Service Intent
- Casual Outing
Group Type
- Couple
Group Size
- Couple
Service Type
- Dine-in
Meal Type
- Dinner
Noise Level
- Quiet
10
Phenomenal Food and Great Service!
My experience at this restaurant was phenomenal. The service was great and the staff were friendly. We always have a great time here and recommend this spot to all our friends.
- service9
- friendly staff10
- food10
Das erwartet dich bei Collina
Loading map…
Planning
- Reservations required
- Accepts reservations
- Dinner reservations recommended
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
- Transgender safespace
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
Popular for
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Amenities
- Restroom
- Bar onsite
Offerings
- Vegan options
- Wine
- Coffee
- Beer
- Small plates
- Organic dishes
- Vegetarian options
- Private dining room
- Alcohol
Dining options
- Dinner
- Table service
- Catering
- Dessert
Service Options
- Dine-in
Parking
- Free street parking
Atmosphere
- Romantic
- Cozy
FAQs
Are reservations required to dine at Collina in San Francisco?
Yes, reservations are required at Collina. Dinner reservations are highly recommended to secure your table and enjoy the romantic, cozy atmosphere of this Italian restaurant in Nob Hill.
What dietary options and beverages are available at Collina?
Collina offers vegan options, vegetarian options, organic dishes, and small plates. You can enjoy wine, coffee, and beer, with a full bar onsite providing alcohol. This ensures a diverse and satisfying dining experience.
What is Collina's overall rating and what do customers think about it?
Collina holds a strong restaurant score of 8.8, with 91.9% customer satisfaction. Guests particularly praise the Service (9.3), Ambience (8.8), and Food (8.7), though Value (6.2) is considered average.
What are some standout dishes at Collina?
Diners frequently highlight the lasagnette and the raviolo with its decadent brown butter sauce as particularly enjoyable. The seared octopus and arancini also receive positive mentions.
Is Collina a good choice for a quiet dinner?
While many appreciate Collina’s cozy and intimate setting, some guests have noted that the noise level can be quite high, making it less ideal for a quiet conversation.
Opening hours
Monday – Thursday
5:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday – Saturday
5:00 PM – 9:30 PM
Sunday
5:00 PM – 9:00 PM